The Petitio: Aristotle's Five Ways
1982; Cambridge University Press; Volume: 12; Issue: 1 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1080/00455091.1982.10715784
ISSN1911-0820
Autores Tópico(s)Classical Philosophy and Thought
ResumoIf one looks to the current textbook lore for reliable taxonomic and analytical information about the petitio principii, one is met with conceptual disarray and much too much nonsense. The present writers have recently attempted to furnish the beginnings of a theoretical reconstruction of this fallacy which is at once faithful to its formidable complexity yet useful as guide for its detection and avoidance. The fact is that the petitio has had a lengthy and interesting history, and in this paper we shall want to explore certain features of its development, such as it may have been. The principal origins of the concept of circular argument are to be found in Aristotle. The Aristotelian doctrine recurs with variations in the sophismata literature of the middle ages and in logic texts and manuals right up to the present day.
Referência(s)