Hume’s “Wilt Chamberlain Argument” and taxation
2012; Cambridge University Press; Volume: 42; Issue: S1 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1080/00455091.2012.972143
ISSN1911-0820
Autores Tópico(s)Economic Theory and Institutions
ResumoRobert Nozick addresses the idea of egalitarian redistribution in an argument standardly considered original: the “Wilt Chamberlain Argument”. However, this argument (without reference to Wilt Chamberlain) is found in David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals , first published in 1751. Placing this argument within a Humean and Hayekian, rather than a Lockean or Kantian, perspective radically changes its import for issues of economic justice. Rather than vindicating the radical individualism of Nozick and other libertarians, applied to our circumstances using Hume's conventionalist and evolutionary account of justice, Hume's Wilt Chamberlain argument vindicates moderate redistribution constrained by the rule of general laws and the goal of fostering innovation and industriousness.
Referência(s)