Psychiatric and General Medical Conditions Comorbid With Schizophrenia in the National Hospital Discharge Survey
2009; American Psychiatric Association; Volume: 60; Issue: 8 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1176/ps.2009.60.8.1059
ISSN1557-9700
AutoresNatalya S. Weber, David N. Cowan, Amy M. Millikan, David W. Niebuhr,
Tópico(s)Mental Health Treatment and Access
ResumoBack to table of contents Previous article Next article ArticleFull AccessPsychiatric and General Medical Conditions Comorbid With Schizophrenia in the National Hospital Discharge SurveyNatalya S. Weber M.D., M.P.H.David N. Cowan Ph.D., M.P.H.Amy M. Millikan M.D., M.P.H.David W. Niebuhr M.D., M.P.H.Natalya S. Weber M.D., M.P.H.David N. Cowan Ph.D., M.P.H.Amy M. Millikan M.D., M.P.H.David W. Niebuhr M.D., M.P.H.Published Online:13 Jan 2015https://doi.org/10.1176/ps.2009.60.8.1059AboutSectionsPDF/EPUB ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack Citations ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InEmail Rates of morbidity and mortality from general medical conditions among patients with schizophrenia are elevated compared with rates in the general U.S. population ( 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ), and this gap has widened in recent decades ( 8 , 9 , 10 ). Fifty percent ( 11 ) to 74% ( 12 ) of patients with schizophrenia have been reported to have one or more comorbid psychiatric or general medical conditions that may worsen the prognosis and contribute to increased morbidity and mortality. These rates are likely underestimates, because many comorbid illnesses are misdiagnosed or undiagnosed among patients with schizophrenia as a result of a suboptimal integration of general medical and psychiatric services, barriers to care delivery, and patients' poor ability to recognize medical problems and their reluctance to seek help ( 13 , 14 ). High rates of cigarette smoking ( 2 , 3 , 15 , 16 , 17 ), alcohol and illicit drug abuse ( 11 ), and poor diet and lack of exercise ( 18 ) in this population may contribute to increased rates of cardiopulmonary ( 3 , 11 , 12 , 19 , 20 ), metabolic ( 2 , 3 , 11 , 12 , 16 , 21 ), and gastrointestinal ( 12 , 22 ) diseases. Poor hygiene, use of injection drugs ( 23 ), and engagement in high-risk sexual behavior ( 24 , 25 ) among individuals with schizophrenia are associated with higher risk of gastrointestinal, blood-borne, and sexually transmitted infectious diseases, including hepatitis ( 2 , 3 , 26 , 27 ) and HIV ( 2 , 3 , 12 , 27 ). Compared with the general U.S. population, individuals with schizophrenia more often face homelessness ( 28 , 29 , 30 ), substandard living conditions ( 31 ), and lack of access to medical care and are less likely to receive general medical check-ups ( 32 ). Psychotropic medications that help alleviate symptoms of schizophrenia and improve overall disease prognosis may have significant side effects, including extrapyramidal symptoms and tardive dyskinesia, weight gain, obesity, hyperglycemia and diabetes ( 33 , 34 ), and cardiovascular disease ( 34 ). The association of schizophrenia with some general medical conditions, such as metabolic syndrome ( 35 ) and type II diabetes ( 36 , 37 ), after analyses control for other factors, may indicate shared etiopathogenic pathways. Virtually all existing studies of comorbid disorders in schizophrenia test hypotheses and focus on a single condition. To our knowledge no systematic analysis of disorders comorbid with schizophrenia has been conducted in the U.S. hospitalized population. In addition, most previous studies have relied on relatively small and nonrepresentative samples. To overcome such limitations and seek new information about poorly examined comorbid conditions, we used National Hospital Discharge Survey (NHDS) data to conduct a systematic analysis of the occurrence of more than one ICD-9 code in the discharge records of hospitalizations for schizophrenia and hospitalizations for other reasons. Demographic characteristics of hospitalized patients with schizophrenia and the proportion of total discharges of patients with schizophrenia over time were also explored. MethodsData source The NHDS is conducted annually by the National Center for Health Statistics, a branch of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. NHDS uses a stratified, multistage probability design and covers discharges from short-stay (average stay of less than 30 days) hospitals (except federal, military, and Department of Veterans Affairs hospitals and hospital units of institutions such as prisons) located in the 50 states and the District of Colombia. The design enables users to produce U.S. national and regional estimates of characteristics of hospitalized patients, length of stay, diagnoses, and procedures in hospitals of various sizes and types of ownership ( www.cdc.gov/nchs/about/major/hdasd/nhds.htm ). The 1979–2003 multiyear public use data and documentation files were used for this study. The multiyear file has standardized coding of variables across the data years. The data elements used in the study reported here included several demographic characteristics, date of hospitalization, length of stay, source of payment, and up to seven ICD-9 code diagnoses. ICD-9 codes are compatible with codes provided in the DSM, which is used for evaluating and coding psychiatric disorders. In the NHDS sample individuals can be included more than once if they have more than one hospitalization during the sampling period and if data for the hospitalization are captured by the sampling methods. Therefore, all estimates reported here refer to discharges and not to individuals. However, the overall likelihood of data capture during the sampling procedures is less than 1%. Thus the probability that a single individual was represented more than once in the unweighted sample is quite low. NHDS data are publicly available and contain no patient-identifying information. Thus there was no danger of unauthorized disclosure and no need for informed consent. The Walter Reed Army Institute of Research Institutional Review Board approved this study. Study population For descriptive and time trend analyses, all discharge records for persons aged one year and older were included (N=5,733,781). Comorbidity was examined only in the discharge records of patients between the ages of 15 and 64 (N=2,623,229), because this age group accounted for more than 85% of the discharges that listed schizophrenia as a diagnosis. Hospitalizations associated with normal childbirth ( ICD-9 code V 27) were excluded. Only discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia were defined as cases in the comorbidity analyses; records that had schizophrenia codes in any other position were excluded. Among the 2,623,229 discharges, a total of 1,963,155 (74.8%) listed more than one diagnosis. Among discharges with more than one diagnosis, 26,279 (1.3%) had a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia. The proportions of comorbid conditions in this group were compared with the proportions in the group with any other primary diagnosis (N=1,936,876). [A figure displaying the study subgroups is available as an online supplement to this article at ps.psychiatryonline.org .] Data coding NHDS discharge records list between one and seven diagnoses; records with at least one diagnosis of a schizophrenia disorder ( ICD-9 codes 295.0–295.9) were classified as discharges with schizophrenia (N=64,113). All other records were considered to be discharges without schizophrenia. A record was considered to list a comorbid condition if it listed more than one ICD-9 discharge diagnosis. In this report comorbid conditions are presented as three-digit ICD-9 codes, except for diabetes type II, which has to be a five-digit ICD-9 code, with 250 as the first three digits, a number from 1 through 9 as the fourth digit (indicating complications), and a fifth digit of 0 or 2. Diabetes type II was included in the analysis because of previously reported associations with schizophrenia ( 21 , 38 ). Statistical analysesWe used the NHDS variable "weight" to provide national estimates (weighted frequencies) for demographic characteristics, region, source of payment, and length of stay for hospital discharges with schizophrenia compared with those without schizophrenia. Frequencies of comorbid conditions were analyzed for discharges with schizophrenia as the primary diagnosis and for those with any other primary diagnosis.Because the NHDS variable "weight" is not designed to provide national estimates of the co-occurrence of diagnoses, these estimates were not used to determine the proportions of concurrent conditions and their associations with primary diagnosis. The results of weighted and unweighted analyses were essentially the same.We counted and sorted by frequencies all concurrent conditions and calculated proportional morbidity and the proportional morbidity ratio (PMR) in order to examine the prevalence of disorders among discharges with and without a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia. The PMR was calculated for every comorbid condition that was more prevalent among the discharges with schizophrenia and that had a proportional morbidity of at least .5%. Because of the definition used, it is possible to have a cumulative prevalence (or count) of conditions up to six times greater than the count of records.ResultsTable 1 presents demographic information from the records of patients with and without a diagnosis of schizophrenia weighted to reflect all U.S. hospital discharges. The overall proportion of discharges with schizophrenia as a diagnosis (not necessarily the primary diagnosis) was 1.0%, and the proportion varied significantly (p<.001) by demographic group. The proportion with schizophrenia was higher among males (1.3%) than females (.8%) and among blacks (1.8%) than whites (.9%) or the "other" racial-ethnic group (1.0%). The proportion was highest among the group aged 15 to 44 (1.6%), followed by the group aged 45 to 64 (1.3%). It was also highest among discharges in the Northeast region (1.5%). The proportion of discharges with schizophrenia was highest among those with Medicaid as source of payment (2.4%), followed by other government funding (1.7%), other sources of payment (1.3%), and Medicare (1.2%). Table 1 Characteristics of all U.S. hospital discharges (1979–2003) by whether or not schizophrenia was listed as a discharge diagnosisTable 1 Characteristics of all U.S. hospital discharges (1979–2003) by whether or not schizophrenia was listed as a discharge diagnosisEnlarge table As shown in Figure 1 , the proportion of discharges with any diagnosis of schizophrenia (primary or nonprimary) increased significantly over time (p<.001). The trend in discharges with paranoid schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, and schizophrenia not otherwise specified was significant among both males and females (p<.001) (data not shown). Among males the trend was mostly attributable to increases in schizoaffective disorder and paranoid schizophrenia, whereas among females it was primarily attributable to an increase in schizoaffective disorder. In the early 1980s schizoaffective disorder was the least prevalent type among males and females. Starting in the late 1980s it became the most prevalent type among males. This trend was evident among females starting in early 1990s. Figure 1 Percentages of four types of schizophrenia diagnoses listed in hospital discharge records, 1979–2003The mean±SE length of hospital stay for discharges with any diagnosis of schizophrenia over the study period was 12.50±.09 days, compared with 6.00±.01 days for discharges without schizophrenia. The mean length of hospital stay for all discharges with schizophrenia decreased significantly (p<.001) from 15.81±.51 days in 1979 to 9.92±.37 in 2003. There was also a significant but less substantial decline in the length of stay among discharges without schizophrenia, from 7.19±.02 days in 1979 to 4.82±.02 days in 2003 (p<.001). The median number of comorbid conditions for discharges with and without any diagnosis of schizophrenia was two among all hospitalizations (aged 15 to 64) and three for discharges restricted to those with two or more ICD-9 codes. Among 55,292 discharge records that listed a diagnosis of schizophrenia, most (75%, N=41,587) listed it as the primary diagnosis (that is, in the first position), including 26,279 records with at least one comorbid condition. Table 2 presents data on the number of conditions and proportional morbidity for the 20 most prevalent (>2%) comorbid conditions for the two discharge groups. Psychiatric and behavior-related diagnoses accounted for 45% of comorbid diagnostic categories among schizophrenia discharges, compared with 15% among other discharges. Table 2 Comorbid conditions in discharge records from the National Hospital Discharge Survey (1979–2003), by whether the primary diagnosis was schizophrenia (N=26,279) or another diagnosis (N=1,936,876)Table 2 Comorbid conditions in discharge records from the National Hospital Discharge Survey (1979–2003), by whether the primary diagnosis was schizophrenia (N=26,279) or another diagnosis (N=1,936,876)Enlarge table As shown in Table 3 , the proportion of discharges with comorbid mental disorders was much higher among discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia, including mild mental retardation (PMR=19.5), personality disorders (PMR=7.6), affective psychoses (PMR=4.6), nondependent abuse of drugs (PMR=3.4), adjustment reaction (PMR=2.2), alcohol dependence (PMR=2.1), drug dependence (PMR=1.9), depressive disorder not elsewhere classified (PMR=1.8), and neurotic disorders (PMR=1.8). In addition, discharge records with schizophrenia as the primary diagnosis were significantly more likely (p<.05) to list the following nonpsychiatric comorbid conditions with a proportional morbidity of more than 2%: acquired hypothyroidism (PMR=2.9), obesity and other hyperalimentation (PMR=2.0), asthma (PMR=1.5), chronic airway obstruction not elsewhere classified (PMR=1.4), essential hypertension (PMR=1.2), and diabetes type II (PMR=1.2). Proportional morbidity of diabetes type II was 6.7% for discharges with schizophrenia and 7.3% for those without schizophrenia (PMR=1.2, 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.2–1.3, p<.001) (data not shown). Discharge records with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia were also significantly more likely (p<.005) to list other less prevalent (.5%–2%) comorbid nonpsychiatric conditions ( Table 4 ). Other extrapyramidal symptoms and abnormal movement disorder was present among 1.8% of discharges with schizophrenia, and poisoning by a psychotropic agent was present among .5%, compared with .1% and .2%, respectively, among discharges without schizophrenia. Table 3 Proportional morbidity ratios (PMRs) for the most prevalent comorbid conditions in discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia (N=26,279) in the National Hospital Discharge Survey, 1979–2003Table 3 Proportional morbidity ratios (PMRs) for the most prevalent comorbid conditions in discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia (N=26,279) in the National Hospital Discharge Survey, 1979–2003Enlarge tableTable 4 Proportional morbidity and proportional morbidity ratios (PMRs) for comorbid conditions in discharges from the National Hospital Discharge Survey (1979–2003), by whether the primary diagnosis was schizophrenia or another diagnosisTable 4 Proportional morbidity and proportional morbidity ratios (PMRs) for comorbid conditions in discharges from the National Hospital Discharge Survey (1979–2003), by whether the primary diagnosis was schizophrenia or another diagnosisEnlarge tableDiscussion Consistent with previous findings, the proportion of hospital discharges that included any diagnosis of schizophrenia was higher among males than among females ( 39 , 40 ), among blacks than among other racial-ethnic groups ( 41 , 42 ), and in discharges in the Northeast—the area with higher urbanicity—compared with other U.S. regions ( 39 , 43 , 44 ). The increase in the proportion of discharges with schizophrenia over the study period could be partly explained by changes in diagnostic criteria. The concept of schizophrenia was very narrow in DSM-III (1980) ( 45 , 46 , 47 ) and even narrower in DSM-III-R (1987) ( 45 , 47 , 48 ), and thus the proportion of discharges with schizophrenia declined over that period. As criteria progressively broadened in DSM-IV (1994) and DSM-IV-TR (2000), the proportion increased. However, DSM-IV criteria were introduced cautiously to avoid an increase in the epidemiological base rate of schizophrenia so that prevalence estimates would not change substantially ( 47 ). In fact, high diagnostic agreement was found between DSM-III-R and DSM-IV ( 49 ). Changes in criteria from DSM-III through DSM-IV-TR also likely contributed to the increase in the proportion of discharges with schizoaffective disorder ( 46 ). In addition, there has been considerable controversy about the stability and usefulness of the diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder since it was introduced in 1933 ( 50 , 51 , 52 ). In our study we used a very broad case definition that included schizophrenia disorders listed in the ICD-9 classification instead of using the DSM-IV-TR definition of schizophrenia. We did this in order to overcome uncertainties in regard to the diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder and to capture fluctuations in the population of cases that were artifacts of changes in DSM definitions of schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder. The high prevalence rates of comorbid psychiatric conditions, such as mild mental retardation (PMR=19.5) and personality disorders (PMR=7.6), among discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia is in accordance with the multiaxial assessment system. As noted in DSM-IV-TR, the multiaxial system is used for psychiatric assessments to facilitate comprehensive and systematic evaluation with attention to various mental disorders and general medical conditions. Use of the multiaxial system could at least partly explain the much higher prevalence of psychiatric conditions among discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia. Consistent with previous findings ( 53 , 54 , 55 , 56 , 57 , 58 , 59 , 60 ), this study found a higher proportion of alcohol dependence (PMR=2.1), drug dependence (PMR=1.9), nondependent abuse of drugs (PMR=3.4), and psychiatric comorbid conditions including depressive symptoms (PMR=4.6 and 1.8) among discharges with schizophrenia. Of the nonpsychiatric comorbid conditions, acquired hypothyroidism was nearly three times more prevalent among discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia. This finding is in line with those of previous studies ( 2 , 6 , 61 ) and case reports ( 62 , 63 ), but reasons for this association remain unclear. The observed increase in metabolic disorders among discharges with schizophrenia is also consistent with previous reports ( 2 , 3 , 11 , 12 , 16 , 21 , 37 , 64 ). Obesity and other hyperalimentation were observed more frequently among discharges with schizophrenia. From 1979 through 1983 the likelihood of comorbid obesity was not significantly different between discharges with and without a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia, but in 1984–1988 the PMR rose to 1.5 (CI=1.3–1.9) and in subsequent years the average PMR was 2.0 (CI=1.9–2.1). A less substantial increase was found for diabetes mellitus type II (PMR=1.2) among discharges with schizophrenia. This increase was driven only by the difference in 1998–2003. The temporal increase in obesity and diabetes type II among discharges with schizophrenia might reflect increased use of some second-generation antipsychotic medications ( 65 ). Certain second-generation psychotropic agents can increase levels of triglycerides and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol and decrease high-density lipoprotein cholesterol ( 14 , 65 , 66 ). However, we did not find an increase in these conditions among discharges with schizophrenia, probably for at least two reasons. First, the ICD-9 codes lack specificity to capture dyslipidemia. Second, screening for and treatment of dyslipidemia are reported to be lower among psychiatric patients than among patients without psychiatric disorders ( 14 , 67 ). Chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases were prevalent in a larger proportion of discharges with schizophrenia, specifically asthma (PMR=1.5), chronic airway obstruction not elsewhere classified (PMR=1.4), and chronic bronchitis (PMR=1.2). The prevalence of tobacco use disorder ( ICD-9 305.1) was 1.6 times higher (CI=1.5–1.7) among discharges with schizophrenia. These results are consistent with other findings of a high prevalence of smoking among persons with schizophrenia ( 7 , 56 , 64 ). When tobacco use disorder was added to the multivariable models, the PMR for chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases did not change substantially, which is consistent with recent findings ( 68 ). It is of interest that epilepsy was twice as prevalent among discharges with schizophrenia. This association has no clear pathogenic mechanism and has been reported in only a few previous studies ( 6 , 64 , 69 ). Among discharges with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia, we also found PMRs of 6.5 for dermatophytosis, 3.3 for diseases of sebaceous glands, and 2.9 for contact dermatitis and other eczema. Although the associations between these conditions and schizophrenia are largely unexplored, some supportive findings exist in the literature ( 2 , 70 , 71 ). Also consistent with previous findings ( 6 , 26 , 27 ), the prevalence of viral hepatitis was higher (PMR=1.4) among discharges with schizophrenia. Higher rates of general medical conditions among persons with schizophrenia may be attributable to unhealthy behaviors, low socioeconomic status, and side effects of psychotropic medications. Poor socioeconomic status in itself can reduce access to medical care and increase exposure to unhealthy behaviors and lifestyles. In addition, schizophrenia may share etiopathogenic pathways with some other medical conditions. This study may have underestimated PMRs for a few reasons. Records selected for comorbidity analyses had schizophrenia as a primary diagnosis, and the patients were presumably attended by psychiatrists. Mental health was most likely the major focus of diagnostic and treatment procedures for these hospitalizations. Therefore, the likelihood that these individuals were routinely screened for a variety of non-life-threatening medical conditions is probably lower than for those who were admitted with a primary diagnosis of a general medical condition. Consistent with this assumption is our finding of a higher prevalence of a few poorly specified conditions and disorders among discharges with schizophrenia. In addition, patients with schizophrenia are much less likely to be aware of their general medical problems and to communicate with health care providers about them ( 58 ), which makes it more likely that these problems were not evaluated during primarily psychiatric hospitalizations. Our study has several strengths. We have described comorbidity among hospital discharge records in a large nationally representative database. This unique and robust data source has been relatively neglected in previous psychiatric research. We systematically determined the most prevalent comorbid conditions for hospitalizations with a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia and for those with any other primary diagnosis and examined temporal trends in the diagnostic coding of schizophrenia types and length of hospitalization over a 25-year period. The multiyear data set was used to standardize variables across years and decrease year-to-year variability. The analysis of proportional morbidity was adjusted for sex, race, age, and geographic region and selectively adjusted for tobacco use disorder.However, the study has some limitations. First, the observations in these data are hospitalizations, and it is possible that an individual was represented more than once. This is an important confound warranting investigation. If individuals with schizophrenia are more likely to be hospitalized than those without schizophrenia, then the proportional morbidity of schizophrenia among hospital discharges could be overestimated. Also, if individuals with schizophrenia and a comorbid condition have a higher rate of rehospitalization than those with other primary diagnoses and the same comorbid condition, the PMRs for this condition would be biased away from the null. However, because the probability of the same person's being represented in the unweighted data set more than once is low, any such bias would be unlikely to materially change our results or conclusions.In addition, changes in diagnostic criteria during the study years—particularly the increasing emphasis on listing "comorbid conditions" as part of the diagnosis rather than considering the additional symptoms to be an expression of the primary disorder—could contribute to observations of increasing comorbidity. However, the increase in comorbidity in later study years somewhat compensates for the underestimation of comorbidity in earlier study years, resulting in a realistic median number of comorbid conditions for the overall study population.Also, our data are cross-sectional. No directionality can be assumed in associations between conditions, and associations do not suggest cause-and-effect relationships. Finally, a database of hospital discharges may disproportionately capture some schizophrenia subpopulations that may have higher rates of hospitalization—for example, individuals with more severe illnesses, those who receive less outpatient care, and those who lack insurance. Thus we cannot extrapolate our findings to the population of nonhospitalized patients with schizophrenia who receive outpatient care in the community, which is presumably much larger but which comprises patients with less severe symptoms.ConclusionsKnowledge of the risks of comorbid psychiatric and general medical conditions is critical for both clinicians and patients with schizophrenia. Closer attention to prevention, early diagnosis, and treatment of comorbid conditions may decrease associated morbidity and mortality and improve prognosis among patients with schizophrenia.Acknowledgments and disclosuresThis work was funded by the Stanley Medical Research Institute and the Department of the Army. The authors thank E. Fuller Torrey, M.D., and Robert Yolken, M.D., for careful review of the manuscript. The views expressed are those of the authors and should not be construed to represent the positions of the Department of the Army or Department of Defense.The authors report no competing interests.The authors are affiliated with the Department of Epidemiology, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, 503 Robert Grant Ave., Silver Spring, MD 20910 (e-mail: [email protected]). Portions of this work were presented at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association (APA), May 3–8, 2008, Washington, D.C., and the APA's Institute on Psychiatric Services, October 2–5, 2008, Chicago.References1. Brown S, Inskip H, Barraclough B: Causes of the excess mortality of schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry 177:212–217, 2000Google Scholar2. Carney CP, Jones L, Woolson RF: Medical comorbidity in women and men with schizophrenia: a population-based controlled study. Journal of General Internal Medicine 21:1133–1137, 2006Google Scholar3. Goff DC, Cather C, Evins AE, et al: Medical morbidity and mortality in schizophrenia: guidelines for psychiatrists. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 66:183–194, 2005Google Scholar4. Newman SC, Bland RC: Mortality in a cohort of patients with schizophrenia: a recor
Referência(s)