Is a Halakhic State Possible? The Paradox of Jewish Theocracy
2004; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 11; Issue: 1 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1080/1353712042000324490
ISSN1743-9086
Autores Tópico(s)Middle East Politics and Society
ResumoIs a consistent Jewish religious position requires either fashioning the State of Israel into a halakhic theocracy or negating it completely? If Torah observers gained control over Israeli society, would their faith require them (or permit them) to impose the Torah's laws on one and all, even against the will of the community and its elected representatives? Would there be no escape from having the rule of Torah undercut that of the State? In this article we propose a negative answer to these questions. We argue that the vision of a halakhic theocracy is vulnerable to challenges on two main levels – on the basis of the age-old inner logic of the Jewish tradition and on account of the actual condition of the contemporary Jews. However, criticism of the ‘halakhic state’ does not imply endorsement of the opposing slogan, ‘separating of religion and Jewish state’. The latter gives rise to its own set of serious difficulties, from the perspective of the religion of Israel and of the State of Israel alike. Both positions may be refutable equally. Yet, there is a wide range of useful political and cultural options available between these two poles.
Referência(s)