The Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) and popular support: counterterrorism towards an insurgency nature
2012; Routledge; Volume: 23; Issue: 3 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1080/09592318.2012.661610
ISSN1743-9558
Autores Tópico(s)Political Conflict and Governance
ResumoAbstract The PKK has been a prolonged problem in Turkey, and various measures have been adopted to diminish and end the violence. In addition to the impacts on violence, these policies have also had an impact on public opinion and ethnic awareness of Kurds in Turkey. This article analyzes these policies and their effects on electoral support for the PKK by examining the vote shares of the pro-PKK political parties in national and local elections. It concludes that Turkey has conceptualized the issue solely as a problem of terrorism, but the goal, strategy, organization, and format of violence used by the PKK reflect the nature of an insurgency. Therefore, it is argued that Turkey, by ignoring the insurgency features, has disregarded the legitimate parts of the cause and related popular support, and thus has responded mostly with deterrent measures apart from the reforms of recent years. Results have shown that policies of deterrence culminated in a steady level of support for the PKK indicating that low level of legitimacy – as they were perceived by the people – of the policies resulted in viable popular and political support for the PKK. Despite the recent accommodative reforms, the existence of pro-PKK parties rallying electoral support in the political arena provided sustained level activities in the conventional politics in Turkey's municipal and national political system, in which they pursue pro-PKK agendas, such as 'Autonomy' and 'Confederation' as well as activities to increase the distinction in identity around the ethnic consciousness for more popular support. Yet, no clear pattern is identified between violence level and popular support in the macro-scale. Keywords: PKKpopular supportcounterterrorisminsurgencypolitical violenceTurkey Notes 1. Durna et al. Durna, T., Goktepe, F. and Keeling, D.G. 2008. "The history of the PKK". In The PKK, a Decades-Old Brutal Marxist-Leninist Separatist Terrorist Organization, Edited by: Teymur, S. and Smith, C. 9–17. Washington, DC: The Turkish Institute for Security and Democracy (TISD). [Google Scholar], 'The History of the PKK'; Ozdogan Ozdogan, A. 2008. A Model of Terrorism: Strategic Interactions and Contextual Details, American University. [Google Scholar], A Model of Terrorism; and Rodoplu et al. Rodoplu, U., Arnold, J. and Ersoy, G. 2003. Terrorism in Turkey. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, 18(2): 152–60. [Crossref], [PubMed] , [Google Scholar], 'Terrorism in Turkey'. 2. ISVG is an open-source relational database that provides data on terrorist, extremist groups, and transnational criminal activities throughout the world. START/GTD is an open-source database collecting systematic information on terrorism. 3. For example, please see Bal and Ozkan Bal, I., and E. Ozkan. 'Dunyada Onemli Olaylar Kronolojisi – PKK Teror Orgutu Kronolojisi (1976–2006)' (2006). http://www.usak.org.tr/dosyalar/dergi/z6UFq2LoFkdiuzBbZSt9qHMi7u4Ke2.pdf (accessed 3 May 2009). [Google Scholar], 'PKK Teror Orgutu Kronolojisi (1976–2006)'; Simsek Simsek, Y., 'Impact of Terrorism on Migration Patterns in Turkey'. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation. Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia, 2006. [Google Scholar], 'Impact of Terrorism on Migration Patterns in Turkey'; and Yonah et al. Yonah, A., Brenner, E.H. and Krause, S.T. 2008. Turkey: Terrorism, Civil Rights and the European Union, New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar], Turkey: Terrorism, Civil Rights and the European Union. 4. Please see Barkey and Fuller Barkey, H.J. and Fuller, G.E. 1998. Turkey's Kurdish Question, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. [Google Scholar], Turkey's Kurdish Question; Kirisci and Winrow Kirisci, K. and Winrow, G.M. 1997. The Kurdish Question and Turkey: An Example of a Trans-State Ethnic Conflict, London & Portland, OR: Frank Cass. [Google Scholar], The Kurdish Question and Turkey; Kocher Kocher, M. 2002. The Decline of the PKK and the Viability of a One-State Solution in Turkey. International Journal on Multicultural Societies, 4(1): 1–20. [Google Scholar], 'The Decline of the PKK and the Viability of a One-State Solution in Turkey'; Marcus Marcus, A. 2007. Blood and Belief: The PKK and the Kurdish Fight for Independence, New York: New York University Press. [Google Scholar], Blood and Belief; and Watts Watts, N. 2006. Activists in Office: Pro-Kurdish Contentious Politics in Turkey. Ethnopolitics, 5(2): 125–44. [Taylor & Francis Online] , [Google Scholar], 'Activists in Office'. 5. The PKK has shifted its goal from establishing an independent state (secession), to constitutional recognition of Kurdish people (cultural and political values), to autonomy (implicitly confederation). 6. Taber Taber, R. 2002. War of the Flea: The Classic Study of Guerrilla Warfare, United States, Dulles, Virginia: Potomac Books Inc.. [Google Scholar], War of the Flea. 7. The ERNK (The Liberation Front of Kurdistan) is the political apparatus of the PKK created in 1985. ERNK performed all political activities of the PKK in and out of Turkey. ERNK's main responsibility was financing and lobbying for acceptance of the PKK as a legitimate political representation of the Kurdish people. ARGK, (Kurdish People's Liberation Army) simply served as the PKK's army apparatus and was responsible for waging guerrilla warfare against the Turkish Republic. ARGK was not the first and only military unit of the PKK. 8. Unal Unal, M.C. 2011. "The Dichotomy in the Perception, Conception and the Response to Terrorism: The case of the PKK". In Counter Terrorism in Diverse Communities, Edited by: Ekici, S. 268–81. Amsterdam, Netherlands, Fairfax, VA, USA: IOS Press BV. [Google Scholar], 'Dichotomy'. 9. Frey and Luechinger Frey, B.S., and S. Luechinger. 'How to Fight Terrorism: Alternatives to Deterrence'. Zurich IEER Working Paper No. 137 (19 November 2002). [Google Scholar], 'How to Fight Terrorism'; 'Landes Landes, W. 1978. An Economic Study of US Aircraft Hijacking, 1961–76. Journal of Law and Economics, 21: 1–32. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], An Economic Study of US Aircraft Hijacking, 1961–76'; Sandler and Enders Sandler, T. and Enders, W. 2004. An Economic Perspective on Transnational Terrorism. European Journal of Political Economy, 20(2): 301–16. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], 'An Economic Perspective on Transnational Terrorism'; and Sandler et al. Sandler, T., Tschirhart, J. and Cauley, J. 1983. A Theoretical Analysis of Transnational Terrorism. American Political Science Review, 77(1): 36–54. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'A Theoretical Analysis of Transnational Terrorism'. 10. Braithwaite Braithwaite, J., 'Thinking Critically About the War Model and the Criminal Justice Model for Combating Terrorism'. Paper presented at the Law and Society Association Meeting Panel on 'Finding Ground Between Traditional Adversaries', 2002. [Google Scholar], 'Thinking Critically'. 11. Please see Bock Bock, A.M., 'Negotiate with Terrorists! or: Why Terrorism Cannot be Deterred'. (2007). http://www.friedrich-ebert-stiftung.de/ipg/arc_07_d/01_07_d/pdf/12_RE_Bock_GB.pdf 9 (accessed 18 October 2008). [Google Scholar], 'Negotiate with Terrorists!'; Frey and Luechinger, 'How to Fight Terrorism'; Martin Martin, B. 2006. Instead of Repression. Social Alternatives, 25(1): 62–84. [Google Scholar], 'Instead of Repression'; Nevin Nevin, J. 2003. Retaliating against Terrorists. Behavior and Social Issues, 12(2): 109–128. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], 'Retaliating against Terrorists'; Schnellenbach Schnellenbach, J. 2006. Appeasing Nihilists? Some Economic Thoughts on Reducing Terrorist Activity. Public Choice, 129(3): 301–13. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Appeasing Nihilists?'; and Turk Turk, A. 2002. Confronting Enemies Foreign and Domestic: An American Dilemma?. Criminology & Public Policy, 1(3): 345–50. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], 'Confronting Enemies'. 12. Cluskey Cluskey, F. 1989. "The Irish Response". In International Terrorism, Challenge and Response: Proceedings of the Jerusalem Conference on International Terrorism, Edited by: Netanyahu, B. 180–6. Jerusalem: The Jonathan Institute. [Google Scholar], 'The Irish Response'; Martin, 'Instead of Repression'; Nevin, 'Retaliating against Terrorists'; and Shultz Shultz, R. 1979. Coercive Force and Military Strategy: Deterrence Logic and the Cost-Benefit Model of Counterinsurgency Warfare. Political Research Quarterly, 32(4): 444–66. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Coercive Force and Military Strategy'. 13. Collins Collins, S.D. 2004. Dissuading State Support of Terrorism: Strikes or Sanctions? (An Analysis of Dissuasion Measures Employed Against Libya). Studies in Conflict and Terrorism, 27(1): 1–18. [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Dissuading State Support of Terrorism'; Crenshaw Crenshaw, M. 1999.. "On How Terrorism Ends". In Special Report: How Terrorism Ends, 2–4. Washington DC: : US Institute of Peace. http://www.usip.org/pubs/specialreports/sr990525.pdf (accessed 23 July 2008) [Google Scholar], 'On How Terrorism Ends'; Frey and Luechinger, 'How to Fight Terrorism'; and Martin, 'Instead of Repression. 14. Crenshaw, 'On How Terrorism Ends'. 15. Tyler Tyler, T. 2000. Multiculturalism and the Willingness of Citizens to Defer to Law and to Legal Authorities. Law & Social Inquiry, 25(4): 983–1019. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Multiculturalism and the Willingness of Citizens'; Tyler et al. Tyler, T., Degoey, P. and Smith, H. 1996. Understanding Why the Justice of Group Procedures Matters: A Test of the Psychological Dynamics of the Group-Value Model. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70(5): 913–30. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Understanding Why the Justice of Group Procedures Matters'. 16. Aktan and Koknar Aktan, G.S. and Koknar, A.M. 2002. "Turkey". In Combating Terrorism: Strategies of Ten Countries, Edited by: Alexander, Y. 260–98. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. [Google Scholar], 'Turkey'. 17. Based upon the recommendation of National Security Council (NSC), which consists of top level military and government officials and is chaired by the president, the Board of Ministers submitted a bill to grant a state of emergency in the region in 1987. 18. Alexander, Turkey. 19. US Department of State US Department of State. Turkey: Country Reports on Human Rights Practices (2001). http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2000/eur/844.htm (accessed 24 April 2009). [Google Scholar], Turkey; Aktan and Koknar, 'Turkey'. 20. Larrabee and Lesser Larrabee, F. and Lesser, I. 2002. Turkish Foreign Policy in an Age of Uncertainty, Pittsburgh, PA: Rand Corporation. [Google Scholar], Turkish Foreign Policy; 'Backgrounder: The Word of a Syrian'. 21. 'Nevruz' meaning new day, denotes the arrival of spring and is celebrated on 21 March. 22. The Act of 2923 banned mother tongue education other than in the official state language, which is Turkish (O'Neil O'Neil, M.L. 2007. "Linguistic Human Rights and the Rights of Kurds". In Human Rights in Turkey, Edited by: Kabasakal Arat, Z. 72–86. Pennsylvania: University of Pennsylvania Press. [Google Scholar], 'Linguistic Human Rights'). Mother tongue education is currently among the demands of the Peace and Democracy Party (BDP), which is pro-PKK and a political wing for the PKK. 23. The Act of 2923 banned mother tongue education other than in the official state language, which is Turkish (O'Neil O'Neil, M.L. 2007. "Linguistic Human Rights and the Rights of Kurds". In Human Rights in Turkey, Edited by: Kabasakal Arat, Z. 72–86. Pennsylvania: University of Pennsylvania Press. [Google Scholar], 'Linguistic Human Rights'). Mother tongue education is currently among the demands of the Democratic Society Party (DTP), which is pro-PKK and a political wing for the PKK 24. Turkmen Turkmen, F. 2007. "Turkey's Participation in Global and Regional Human Rights Regimes". In Human Rights in Turkey, Edited by: Kabasakal Arat, Z. 249–61. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], 'Turkey's Participation'. 25. Repentance Laws (8 times recurrently and they reflect slight differences from one another): 1985 (2 years), 1988 (2 years), 1990 (1 year), 1992 (2 years), 1995 (4 months), 1999 (6 months), 2000 (6 months), June 2003 (6 months). 26. Ozer and Gunbeyi Ozer, M. and Gunbeyi, M. 2008. "The Kurdish Opposition in Turkey". In The PKK: A Decades-Old Brutal Marxist-Leninist Separatist Terrorist Organization, Edited by: Teymur, S. and Smith, C. 133–58. Washington, DC: The Turkish Institute for Security and Democracy (TISD). [Google Scholar], 'The Kurdish opposition in Turkey'. 27. Barkey and Fuller, Turkey's Kurdish Question. 28. The Social Democratic Populist Party (Sosyal Demokrat Halkci Parti, SHP), representing the center-left, was one of the major political parties in Turkey's political arena at the time. 29. Watts, 'Activists in Office'. 30. 'People's War' is a revolutionary insurgent concept indicating the process of revolution of civilian masses from rural areas to urban areas, as theorized by Mao Zedong, the Chinese insurgent leader (Mao Tse-Tung Tse-Tung, Mao. 2000. On Guerrilla Warfare, trans. S. Griffith Illinois, IL: University of Illinois Press. [Google Scholar], On Guerrilla Warfare). 31. In the case of HEP's expected closure, another political party was also founded on 19 November 1992, the Freedom and Democracy Party (Ozgurluk ve Demokrasi Partisi, OZDEP). However, it had a very short life and was shut down on 23 November 1993. 32. OZEP later abolished itself and became part of HEP before the closure of HEP. Another political party was created, the Democracy Party (Demokrasi Partisi, DEP), on 12 July 1993, and 18 parliamentarians resigned from HEP and joined the DEP. 33. Some of the party leaders and members were banned from political activities for a certain amount of time based on their activities under the party affiliation. 34. In Turkey's electoral system, political parties have to meet certain criteria to participate officially in national and local elections. The most important criterion is that in the national elections, only parties that receive over 10% of the overall (nationwide) votes can be represented in the Turkish Grand National Assembly. This criterion was introduced into the Turkish electoral system in 1983. 35. Watts, 'Activists in Office'. 36. In Turkey, there are 16 great municipalities which are the biggest metropolitan areas with large populations, such as Istanbul, Ankara, and Izmir. Diyarbakir Province municipality is one these great municipalities. 37. In Turkey's electoral system, the threshold cast for independent candidates to make it to the National Assembly is calculated as follows: the votes cast for parties exceeding a 10% threshold are added to the votes cast for independents and divided by the number of representative seats for that particular province. 38. Please see Barkey and Fuller, Turkey's Kurdish Question; Kirisci and Winrow, The Kurdish Question and Turkey; Kocher, 'The Decline of the PKK'; and Watts, 'Activists in Office'. 39. Kirisci and Winrow, The Kurdish Question and Turkey; Simsek, 'Impact of Terrorism on Migration Patterns in Turkey'. 40. As discussed earlier, certain demographic changes occurred as a result of the state's policy of forced evacuation of rural villages that began in 1990 and lasted until the early 2000s. 41. Barkey and Fuller, Turkey's Kurdish Question. 42. Ergil Ergil, D. 2000. The Kurdish Question in Turkey. Journal of Democracy, 11(3): 122–35. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'The Kurdish Question in Turkey'; Simsek, 'Impact of Terrorism on Migration Patterns in Turkey'; and Zucconi Zucconi, M. 1999. The Kurdish Question and Migration in Turkey, Graphorama, Rome: CSS. [Google Scholar], The Kurdish Question and Migration in Turkey. 43. Chandra Chandra, K. 2009. Why Voters in Patronage Democracies Split Their Tickets: Strategic Voting for Ethnic Parties. Electoral Studies, 28(1): 21–32. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Why Voters in Patronage Democracies Split Their Tickets'. 44. Boatright Boatright, R. 2007. Who Are the Spatial Voting Violators?. Electoral Studies, 27(1): 116–125. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Who Are the Spatial Voting Violators?'. 45. For example, please see the studies of Kocher, 'The Decline of the PKK'; and Simsek, 'Impact of Terrorism on Migration Patterns in Turkey'. 46. Kocher, 'The Decline of the PKK'. 47. O'Neil, 'Linguistic Human Rights'. 48. DTP competed with independent candidates in 2007 national elections because of the 10% threshold requirement to be represented in the Grand National Assembly. The figure of 5.2% from the national elections of 2007 includes the total votes of independent candidates with no political party affiliation who gained 21 seats. Therefore, calculating the vote share of DTP in 2007 elections leads to an even lower total vote. 49. Cizre Cizre, Ü. 2008. Secular and Islamic Politics in Turkey: The Making of the Justice and Development Party, Routledge Studies in Middle Eastern Politics London: Routledge. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Secular and Islamic Politics in Turkey. 50. Crenshaw Crenshaw, M., ed. 1995. Terrorism in Context, University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press. [Google Scholar], Terrorism in Context. 51. The data does not cover the violence level beyond 2007, so the local election results of 2009 is not analyzed. 52. Unal Unal, M.C. 2012. Counterterrorism in Turkey: Policy Choices and Policy Effects Toward the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), Democracy and Extremism, London: Routledge. [Google Scholar], Counterterrorism in Turkey. 53. Kocher, 'The Decline of the PKK'. 54. Unal, Counterterrorism in Turkey. 55. In economic theory, zero-sum refers to a situation in which a participant's gain or loss is exactly balanced by the losses or gains of the other participant(s). The sum of total gains and the total losses of the participants are subtracted, they will sum to zero. 56. Watts, 'Activists in Office'. 57. Kurdish Communities Union, Turkey Council (KCK/TM), The PKK's recent organizational structure for pursuing its political goal on the social context.
Referência(s)