Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Teachers' Accounts of the Usefulness of Multigrade Teaching in Promoting Sustainable Human-Development Related Outcomes in Rural South Africa

2010; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 36; Issue: 1 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/03057071003607428

1465-3893

Byron A. Brown,

Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies

Abstract Education has an enormous role to play in efforts to promote and achieve sustainable development in South Africa. But one challenge facing the education sector is a shortage of teachers in different phases of the school system. Multigrade teaching is seen as a means to overcome the effects of the teacher shortage and, through the opening of access to basic education, to contribute towards achieving Education For All (EFA). Furthermore, with multigrade teaching there is scope for 'interactions' among learners of, inter alia, different ages, levels of maturity, grades, and abilities. Because the diversity and differences among learners is sharply increased in a multigrade class, the interaction processes and curricula aspects are affected. The multigrade teaching debate has largely ignored the possibility that aspects of the multigrade teaching process could be utilised to support sustainable human development (SHD). Using a qualitative approach, this article examines multigrade teachers' views about multigrade teaching and group-work as its methodology, and the extent to which teachers use group-work to promote measures relevant to SHD – such as peaceful social interaction, shared responsibility, and civic participation. Evidence from 10 case studies, which involved 25 multigrade teachers, shows that while multigrade teaching seems a useful medium to promote social outcomes necessary for SHD, the ways in which it is implemented, and the context in which this is done, matter. It highlights key implementation and contextual issues to address whether multigrade teaching is to contribute meaningfully to sustainable human development. Notes 1 B. Brown, 'Multigrade Teacher Experiences, Skills and other Dilemmas' (paper presented at the Eastern Cape Provincial Department of Education Conference, Regent Hotel, East London, 12 March, 2007); A. Kassiem, 'Educators Feel Crunch of Teacher Shortage', IOL Bulletin Online, http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?from = rss_South+Africa&set_id = 1&click_id = 13&art_id = vn20070520235116644C994448, accessed 18 August 2007. 2 Brown, 'Multigrade Teacher Experience'; J. Joubert, 'Training of Teachers for Rural / Multi-Grade Schools in SA' (paper presented at the International Rural Network Conference, Inverness, Scotland, June 2004). 3 Brown, 'Multigrade Teacher Experience'; G. Mathot, 'A Survey of Multigrade Schools in the Eastern Cape' (University of Fort Hare In-service Programmes, University of Fort Hare, 1998); DoE, Teachers for the Future: Meeting Teacher Shortage to Achieve Education for All (Pretoria, Department of Education, 2005). 4 DoE, 'Report of the Ministerial Committee on Rural Education: A New Vision for Rural Schooling' (Pretoria, Department of Education, 2005); A. Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings' (Paper prepared for the UNESCO 2005 EFA Monitoring Report. Online, available at www.skoleplassen.hisf.no/Rapportar/LearningandTeachinginMultigrade, accessed September 2007). 5 S. Veenman, 'Cognitive and Noncognitive Effects of Multigrade and Multi-Age Classes: A Best-Evidence Synthesis', Review of Educational Research, 65, 4 (1995), pp. 319–81; B. Miller, Teaching and Learning in the Multigrade Classroom: Student Performance and Instructional Routines (1991); ERIC Digest, ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED335178; D.A. Mason and R. Burns, 'Reassessing the Effects of Combination Classes', Education Research and Evaluation, 3, 1 (1997), pp. 1–53; A. Little, Multi-grade Teaching: Evidence from Practice and Research (London, ODA, 1995); A. Little, 'Multigrade Teaching: Towards an International Research and Policy Agenda', International Journal of Educational Development, 21 (2001), pp. 481–97. 6 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings'; V. Juvane, 'Redefining the Role of Multi-Grade Teaching: Policy Lessons, Options and Priorities', ADEA, Working Group on the Teaching Profession-Education for Rural People, Working Paper 092 (2005); I. Birch and M. Lally, 'Multigrade Teaching in Primary Schools' (Asia-Pacific Centre of Educational Innovation for Development, Bangkok, UNESCO Principal Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific, 1995). 7 Veenman, 'Cognitive and Noncognitive Effects of Multigrade and Multi-age Classes'; V. Russell, K. Rowe and P. Hill, 'Effects of Multigrade Classes on Student Progress in Literacy and Numeracy: Quantitative Evidence and Perceptions of Teachers and School Leaders' (paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Australian Association for Research in Education (AARE), Adelaide, March 1998); C. Kyne, 'The Grouping Practices of Teachers in Small Two-teacher Primary Schools in the Republic of Ireland', Journal of Research in Rural Education, 20, 17 (2005), pp. 1–20. 8 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings'. 9 WCED, Our Common Future: Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development (Cape Town, Oxford University Press, 1987). 10 WCED, Our Common Future: Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development (Cape Town, Oxford University Press, 1987), p. 57. 11 Cited in J. Oucho, 'Population Policies and Sustainable Development in Africa' (paper presented at the Seminar for Population Commission Officials, Nairobi, Kenya, March 24–26 1998), p. 7. 12 C. Butz, 'Socially Responsible Investment: Avoiding the Financial Materiality Trap', Discussion Paper, ETHOS, 2 (2007), p. 2. 13 C. Butz, 'Socially Responsible Investment: Avoiding the Financial Materiality Trap', Discussion Paper, ETHOS, 2 (2007), p. 2. 14 Cited in Oucho, 'Population Policies and Sustainable Development in Africa', p. 7. 15 S. Castles, 'Studying Social Transformation', International Political Science Review (Special issue, 2000), 16 UNDP, Human Development Report 1999 (New York, Oxford University Press, 1999), p. 34. 17 Castles, 'Studying Social Transformation', p. 10. 18 Castles, 'Studying Social Transformation'; Butz, 'Socially Responsible Investment', p. 2. 19 R. Morgan, Population Growth and Policies in Sub-Saharan Africa (Washington, DC, World Bank, 1994), p. 46. 20 K. Corrigan, B. Hemmings and R. Kay, 'Single-age and Multi-age Groupings in Kindergarten and their Effect on Literacy Achievement', available at www.multigradeliteracy.ac.au, accessed March 2008. 21 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings'; Juvane, 'Redefining the Role of Multi-Grade Teaching'. 22 Mason and Burns, 'Reassessing the Effects of Combination Classes'; P. Ninnes, 'The Bhutan Multi-grade Attachment Program', in L. Cornish (ed.), Reaching EFA through Multi-grade Teaching: Issues, Contexts and Practices (Armidale, Kardoorair Press, 2006), pp. 115–36. 23 B. Brown, 'Challenges in the Use of Multigrade Teaching to Promote Sustainable Human Development in South Africa', Commonwealth Youth and Development, 6, 2 (2008), pp. 70–82; V. Jordaan and J. Joubert, 'Training of Teachers in Poor Areas Through a Multigrade Intervention to Achieve Millennium Development Goals: Our Experiences'. Available at url: www.wikieducator.org/images/f/ff/PID_708.pdf, accessed March, 2007. 24 Brown, 'Challenges in the Use of Multigrade Teaching'; Jordaan and Joubert, 'Training of Teachers in Poor Areas Through a Multigrade Intervention'. 25 S. Aikman and P. Pridmore, 'Multigrade Schools in Remote Areas of Vietnam', International Journal of Educational Development, 21, 6 (2001), pp. 521–36; E. Brinswic and J. Valerien, 'Multigrade Schools: Improving Access in Rural Africa' (Paris, UNESCO, 2004); E. Hargreaves, C. Montero, N. Chau, M. Sibli and T. Thanh, 'Multigrade Teaching in Peru, Sri Lanka and Vietnam: An Overview', International Journal of Educational Development, 21, 6 (2001), pp. 499–520. 26 Brown, 'Challenges in the Use of Multigrade Teaching'; DoE, Teachers for the Future, p. 7; Jordaan and Joubert, 'Training of Teachers in Poor Areas Through a Multigrade Intervention'; HRW, 'Forgotten Schools: Rights to Basic Education for Children on Farms in South Africa' (A Human Rights Watch Report, May 2004). 27 Brown, 'Challenges in the Use of Multigrade Teaching'; DoE, Teachers for the Future, p. 7; Mathot, 'A Survey of Multigrade Schools in the Eastern Cape'. 28 DoE, Teachers for the Future; DoE, 'An Assessment of Multigrade Schools in the Eastern Cape', Working Paper, 2008c, p. 14. 29 HRW, 'Forgotten Schools', p. 1. 30 Brown, 'Challenges in the Use of Multigrade Teaching'. 31 See Mathot, 'A Survey of Multigrade Schools in the Eastern Cape'. 32 L. Benveniste and P. McEwan, 'Constraints to Implementing Educational Innovations: The Case of Multigrade Schools', International Review of Education, 46, 1 & 2 (2000), pp. 31–48. 33 Mathot, 'A Survey of Multigrade Schools in the Eastern Cape'. 34 Brown, 'Challenges in the Use of Multigrade Teaching'. 35 Joubert, 'Training of Teachers for Rural / Multi-grade Schools in SA'. 36 G. Lingam, 'Pedagogical Practices: The Case of Multi-class Teaching in Fiji Primary School', Educational Research and Review, 2, 7 (2007), pp. 186–92. 37 Corrigan et al., Single-age and Multi-age Groupings in Kindergarten'; B. Brown, 'Multigrade Teaching: A Review of the Literature – Trends, Issues', Research Project for the CEPD, 2007. 38 P. Pridmore, 'Adapting the Primary-School Curriculum for Multigrade Classes in Developing Countries: A Five-Step Plan and an Agenda for Change', Journal of Curriculum Studies, 39, 5 (2007), pp. 559–76. 39 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings'. 40 V. Son, P. Pridmore, B. Nga, D. Mi and P. Kick, 'Renovating the Teaching of Health in Multigrade Primary Schools: A Teacher's Guide to Health in Natural and Social Sciences (Grades 1, 2 and 3) and Science (Grade 5)', (Hanoi, Vietnam, British Council/National Institute of Educational Sciences, 2002). 41 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings', p. 13; Pridmore, 'Adapting the Primary-School Curriculum for Multigrade Classes in Developing Countries'. 42 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings', p. 13. 43 V. Colbert, C. Chiappe and J. Arboleda, 'The New School Program: More and Better Primary Education for Children in Rural Areas in Colombia', in H. Levin and M. Lockheed (eds), Effective Schools in Developing Countries (London, Falmer Press, 1993), pp. 45–61. 44 Kyne, 'The Grouping Practices of Teachers in Small Two-Teacher Primary Schools in the Republic of Ireland'; Ninnes, 'The Bhutan Multi-grade Attachment Program'; p. 125. 45 Colbert et al., 'The New School Program'; G. Psacharopoulos, C. Rojas and E. Velez, 'Achievement Evaluation of Colombia's Escuela Nueva: Is Multigrade the Answer?', Comparative Education Review, 37, 3 (1993), pp. 263–76; C. Forero-Pineda, D. Escobar-Rodriquez and D. Molina, 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia', in A. Little (ed.), Education for All and Multigrade Teaching: Challenges and Opportunities (Netherlands, Springer, 2006), pp. 265–300. 46 Kyne, 'The Grouping Practices of Teachers in Small Two-Teacher Primary Schools'. 47 Colbert et al., 'The New School Program'. 48 E. Schiefelbein, 'Redefining Basic Education for Latin America: Lessons to be Learnt from the Colombian Escuela Nueva' (Paris, UNESCO, 1992). 49 Colbert et al., 'The New School Program'. 50 Benveniste and McEwan, 'Constraints to Implementing Educational Innovations'. 51 V. Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully', Presentation by the Escuela Nueva Foundation, Bogotá, Colombia, June, 2007. Online: www.escuelanueva.org, accessed 10 March 2007. 52 V. Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully', Presentation by the Escuela Nueva Foundation, Bogotá, Colombia, June, 2007. Online: www.escuelanueva.org, accessed 10 March 2007, p. 2. 53 Benveniste and McEwan, 'Constraints to Implementing Educational Innovations'. 54 Colbert et al., 'The New School Program'. 55 Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully'. 56 Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully', p. 3. 57 Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully', p. 14. 58 Colbert et al., 'The New School Program'; Schiefelbein, 'Redefining Basic Education for Latin America. 59 Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully', p. 15. 60 Colbert de Arboleda, 'Learning to Learn and Coexist Peacefully', p. 47. 61 M. Veenman and J. Raemaekers, 'Long-term Effects of a Staff Development Programme on Effective Instruction and Classroom Management for Teachers in Multigrade Classes', Educational Studies, 21, 2 (1995), pp. 167–85; Ninnes, 'The Bhutan Multi-grade Attachment Program'. 62 Veenman and Raemaekers, 'Long-term Effects', p. 167. 63 Veenman and Raemaekers, 'Long-term Effects', p. 167. 64 Veenman and Raemaekers, 'Long-term Effects'; M. Vithanapathirana, 'Training Modules on Multigrade Teaching for Multigrade Teachers in Sri Lanka' (Colombo, University of Colombo, Faculty of Education, 2006). 65 Mason and Burns, 'Reassessing the Effects of Combination Classes'; Wright, 'Multigrade Teaching in Belize'. (paper presented to the Belize Teacher Training College, August 2000). 66 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings'; Lingam, 'Pedagogical Practices'. 67 Joubert, 'Training of Teachers for Rural/Multi-grade schools in SA'; A. Croft, 'Prepared for Diversity? Teacher Education for Lower Primary Classes in Malawi', in Little (ed.), Education For All and Multigrade Teaching (Netherlands, Springer, 2006), pp. 103–26. 68 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'; Psacharopoulos et al., 'Achievement Evaluation of Colombia's Escuela Nueva'. 69 Wright, 'Multigrade Teaching in Belize'. 70 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'; Psacharopoulos et al., 'Achievement Evaluation of Colombia's Escuela Nueva'; A. Sadovnik, P. Cookson and S. Semel, Exploring Education: An Introduction to the Foundations of Education, 2nd edn (London, Allyn & Bacon, 2001), p. 120. 71 Croft, 'Prepared for Diversity?'; Joubert, 'Training of Teachers for Rural/Multi-grade Schools in SA'; Pridmore, 'Adapting the Primary-School Curriculum for Multigrade Classes in Developing Countries', p. 559. 72 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'. 73 Butz, 'Socially Responsible Investment', p. 1; Castles, 'Studying Social Transformation', p. 10; UNDP, Human Development Report 1999 (New York, Oxford University Press, 1999), p. 34. 74 A. Bates, 'Transitioning to Sustainability', available at www.thefarm.org/permaculture/petrocolecovilab.htm, accessed 10 May 2005. 75 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'. 76 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'; Psacharopoulos et al., 'Achievement Evaluation of Colombia's Escuela Nueva'; Colbert et al., 'The New School Program'; D. Pratt, 'On the Merits of Multi-age Classrooms', Research in Rural Education, 3, 3 (1986), pp. 111–15. 77 Lingam, 'Pedagogical Practices'. 78 Croft, 'Prepared for Diversity?'; Pridmore, 'Adapting the Primary-School Curriculum for Multigrade Classes in Developing Countries'. 79 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia', p. 267. 80 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia', p. 267. 81 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia' 82 Psacharopoulos et al., 'Achievement Evaluation of Colombia's Escuela Nueva'; Miller, 'Teaching and Learning in the Multigrade Classroom'; B. Ford, 'Multi-age Grouping in the Elementary School and Children's Affective Development: A Review of Recent Research', The Elementary School Journal (1977), pp. 149–59. 83 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'. 84 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia' 85 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings'. 86 Little, 'Learning and Teaching in Multigrade Settings', p. 5. 87 Croft, 'Prepared for Diversity?', p. 130. 88 D. Wood, How Children Think and Learn: Understanding Children's Worlds (London, Blackwell, 2005), p. 12. 89 Cited in Wood, How Children Think and Learn, p. 18. 90 Croft, 'Prepared for Diversity?'. 91 M. Mpotokwane, 'The Concept of Sustainable Development', in B. Chilisa, L. Mafela and J. Preece (eds), Educational Research for Sustainable Development (Gaborone, Lighthouse, 2003), pp. 105–21. 92 C. Berry, 'Learning Opportunities For All', in Little (ed.), Education For All and Multigrade Teaching, pp. 67–86. 93 Morgan, Population Growth and Policies in Sub-Saharan Africa. 94 Wood, How Children Think and Learn; B. Bernstein, 'Social Class and Pedagogic Practice', in B. Bernstein (ed.), Class, Codes and Control: The Structure o Pedagogic Discourse, Volume 4 (London, Routledge, 1990), pp. 63–93. 95 D. Denver and G. Hands, 'Does Studying Politics Make a Difference? The Political Knowledge, Attitudes and Perceptions of School Students', British Journal of Political Science, 20 (1990), pp. 263–79; J. Bynner and S. Ashford, 'Politics and Participation: Some Antecedents of Young People's Attitudes to the Political System and Political Activity', European Journal of Social Psychology, 24, (1994), pp. 223–36. 96 B. Crick, 'The Presuppositions of Citizenship Education', Journal of Philosophy of Education, 33 (1999), pp. 337–52; F. Haegel, 'The Effect of Education on the Expression of Negative Views of Immigrants in France: The Influence of the Republican Model Put to the Test', in L. Hagendoorn and S. Nekuee (eds), Education and Racism (Aldershot, Ashgate, 1999), pp. 33–46. 97 C. Hahn, Becoming Political (New York, State University of New York Press, 1998), p. 117; D. Campbell, Voice in the Classroom: How an Open Classroom Environment Facilitates Adolescents' Civic Development (Notre Dame IN, University of Notre Dame, 2004). 98 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia'. 99 See M. Saunders, P. Lewis and A. Thornhill, Research Methods for Business Students, 3rd edn (Harrow, Prentice Hall, 2003), p. 140. 100 See M. Saunders, P. Lewis and A. Thornhill, Research Methods for Business Students, 3rd edn (Harrow, Prentice Hall, 2003), p. 140 101 DoE, Teachers for the Future, p. 44. 102 M. Miles and A. Huberman, Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook (Thousand Oaks, Sage, 1994). 103 M. Miles and A. Huberman, Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook (Thousand Oaks, Sage, 1994); J. Corbin and A. Strauss, Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory, Procedures and Techniques (Newbury Park, Sage, 1990). 104 Cited in B. Brown and S. Schulze, 'The Development of Working Relationships between Indigenous and Expatriate Teachers', Journal of the Botswana Educational Research Association, 10, 1 (2002), pp. 3–20. 105 'The Revised National Curriculum Statement', Maskew Miller Longman, www.mml.co.za/revised_national_curriculum_statement.htm, accessed June 2002. 106 Forero-Pineda et al., 'Escuela Nueva's Impact on the Peaceful Social Interaction of Children in Colombia', p. 267. 107 Cited in Little (ed.), Education For All and Multigrade Teaching, p. 18. 108 DoE, Teachers for the Future. 109 Joubert, 'Training of Teachers for Rural / Multi-grade Schools in SA'.