Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Refugees, idps and Citizenship Rights: the perils of humanitarianism in the African Great Lakes region

2013; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 34; Issue: 5 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/01436597.2013.800740

1360-2241

Patricia Daley,

Historical and Contemporary Political Dynamics

Abstract Persistent civil warfare has created a crisis of protection for vulnerable refugees/returnees and internally displaced people ( idps ) in the African Great Lakes region. This is in the context of increasing state hostility towards refugees, intensified inter-group competition among citizens, and rising xenophobia towards African 'foreigners'. Humanitarian solutions are often de-contextualised from struggles over entitlements, citizenship and exclusionary practices based on social hierarchies, ethnicity and indigeneity. Hence, they tend to contribute to rather than alleviate the marginality experienced by the displaced. This article argues for further exploration of the processes of identity construction that accompany displacement and humanitarianism and their problematic relationship with sovereignty and citizenship. It suggests that transcending marginality requires greater emphasis on political agency within refugee and idp communities—for their voices to be part of negotiations and conversations on repatriation and integration—in order for them to rejoin the political community. Notes 1 G Agamben, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1998, p 133. 2 Ibid, p 134. 3 The term 'forcedly displaced' is used here to refer to both refugees and idps: people who have been forced to leave their normal place of residence as a result of conflict or persecution. 4 R Lemarchand, The Dynamics of Violence in Central Africa, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2009; F Reyntjens, The Great African War: Congo and Regional Geopolitics, 1996–2006, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009; and S Autesserre, The Trouble with Congo: Local Violence and the Failure of International Peace-building, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010. 5 P Daley, 'The politics of the refugee crisis in Tanzania', in H Campbell & H Stein (eds), Tanzania and the imf : The Dynamics of Liberalization, Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1992, pp 125–146; S Chaulia, 'The politics of refugee hosting in Tanzania: from open door to unsustainability, insecurity and receding receptivity', Journal of Refugee Studies, 16(2), 2003, pp 147–166; J Milner, Refugees, the State and the Politics of Asylum in Africa, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009; and M Morel, 'The lack of refugee-burden-sharing in Tanzania: tragic effects', Afrika Focus, 22(1), 2009, pp 107–114. 6 P Collier, War, Guns and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places, London: Bodley Head, 2009. 7 J Pottier, 'Displacement and ethnic reintegration in Ituri, DR Congo: challenges ahead', Journal of Modern African Studies, 46(3), 2008, pp 427–450; and M Mamdani, 'The invention of the indigène', London Review of Books, January 2011, p 20. 8 M Mamdani, Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1996; and Mamdani, When Victims Become Killers: Colonialism, Nativism, and the Genocide in Rwanda, Oxford: James Currey, 2001. 9 S Dorman, D Hammett & P Nugent (eds), Making Nations, Creating Strangers: State and Citizenship in Africa, Leiden: Brill, 2007; P Geschiere, The Perils of Belonging: Autochthony, Citizenship, and Exclusion in Africa and Europe, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2009; and E Lochery, 'Rendering difference visible: the Kenyan state and its Somali citizens', African Affairs, 111(445), 2012, pp 615–639. 10 N Soguk, States and Strangers: Refugees and Displacements of Statecraft, Borderlines II, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1999; and P Nyers, Rethinking Refugees: Beyond States of Emergency, New York: Routledge, 2006. 11 Agamben, Homo Sacer, pp 132, 133. 12 Nyers, Rethinking Refugees, p xvii. 13 LH Malkki, 'Speechless emissaries: refugees, humanitarianism, and dehistoricization', Current Anthropology, 11(3), 1996, pp 337–404. 14 M Foucault, Society Must be Defended, London: Penguin, 1997. 15 A Mbembe, 'Necropolitics', Public Culture, 15(1), 2003, p 26. 16 Mamdani, Citizen and Subject. 17 J Herbst, States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control, Princeton, NJ: Princeton Paperbacks, 2000. 18 Dorman et al, Making Nations, Creating Strangers; and P Geschiere & FB Nyamjoh, 'Capitalism and autochthony: the seesaw of mobility and belonging', Public Culture, 12(20), 2000, pp 423–452. 19 Geschiere, The Perils of Belonging, p 25. 20 CJ Gray, 'Cultivating citizenship through xenophobia in Gabon, 1960–1995', Africa Today, 45(3–4), 1998, pp 389–410. 21 Dorman et al, Making Nations, Creating Strangers; B Manby, Struggles for Citizenship in Africa, London: Zed Books, 2009; and B Rutinwa, Addressing Irregular Settlement in North West Tanzania: A Legal and Protection Perspective, University of Dar es Salaam, International Migration Management Project Working Paper No 1, 2010. 22 N Kersting, 'New nationalism and xenophobia in Africa—a new inclination?, Africa Spectrum, 44(1), 2009, p 10. 23 Lochery, 'Rendering difference visible', p 615. 24 J-J Rousseau, The Social Contract, London: Penguin, 1968. 25 M Duffield, 'The liberal way of development and the development–security impasse: exploring the global life-chance divide', Security Dialogue, 41, 2010, pp 53–76. 26 Manby, Struggles for Citizenship in Africa; and Mamdani, 'The invention of the indigène'. 27 K Jacobsen, 'Can refugees benefit the state? Refugee resources and African state-building', Journal of Modern African Studies, 450(4), 2002, p 2. 28 Ibid. 29 J Stevens, 'Prisons of the stateless: the derelictions of unhcr', New Left Review, 42, 2006, pp 53–67. 30 A Slaughter & J Crisp, 'A surrogate state? The role of unhcr in refugee situations', unhcr : New Issues in Refugee Research, 168, p 12, at http://www.unhcr.org/4981cb432.html, accessed June 2010. 31 L Landau, The Humanitarian Hangover: Transnationalization of Governmental Practice in Tanzania's Refugee-populated Areas, unhcr: New Issues in Refugee Research Working Paper 40, p 1. 32 Ibid, p 21. 33 S Turner, 'Sovereign spaces—contesting sovereignties in a refugee camp', in TB Hansen & F Stepputat (eds), Sovereign Bodies: Citizens, Migrants and the State in the Post-colonial World, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2005, p 531. 34 A Branch, 'Humanitarianism, violence, and the camp in Northern Uganda', Civil Wars, 11(4), 2009, pp 477–501. 35 Ibid, p 480. 36 Malkki, 'Speechless emissaries'; Daley, 'The politics of the refugee crisis in Tanzania'; and Turner, 'Sovereign spaces'. 37 Turner, 'Sovereign spaces', p 332. 38 Centre for the Study of Forced Migration (csfm), University of Dar es Salaam & International Refugee Rights Initiative, Social Science Research Council, Going Home or Staying Home? Ending Displacement for Burundian Refugees in Tanzania, Citizenship and Forced Migration in the Great Lakes Region Working Paper 1, November 2008. 39 Turner, 'Sovereign spaces'. 40 unhcr, 'Regional operations profile—Central Africa and the Great Lakes', 2012, at http://www.unhcr.org/pages/49e45a6c6.html, accessed 28 January 2013. 41 Ibid. 42 Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (ocha), DRC Humanitarian Action Plan 2011, at http://ochaonline.un.org/humanitarianappeal/, accessed 9 November 2011. 43 UN ohchr, Democratic Republic of Congo, 1993–2003: Report of the Mapping Exercise documenting the most serious violations of human rights and international humanitarian law committed within the territory of the Democratic Republic of the Congo between March 1993 and June 2003, 2010; and Mamdani, 'The invention of the indigène'. 44 unfpa, 'More than 8000 women raped last year by fighters in the Eastern Congo', UN News Centre, 9 February 2010. 45 Chaulia, 'The politics of refugee hosting in Tanzania'; and M Ibrahim, 'The securitization of migration: a racial discourse', International Migration, 43(5), pp 163–187. 46 P Daley, Gender and Genocide: The Search for Spaces of Peace in the Great Lakes Region of Africa, Oxford: James Currey, 2008. 47 H Adelman, 'The use and abuse of refugees in Zaire', in SJ Stedman & F Tanner (eds), Refugee Manipulation: War, Politics, and the Abuse of Human Suffering, Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 2003, pp 95–134. 48 KNF Emizet, 'The massacre of refugees in Congo: a case of UN peace-keeping failure and international law', Journal of Modern African Studies, 38(2), 2000, pp 163–202; and Adelman, 'The use and abuse of refugees in Zaire'. 49 Human Rights Watch (hrw), 'You Will Be Punished': Attacks on Civilians in Eastern Congo, New York: hrw, December 2009. 50 F Reyntjens, 'Constructing the truth, dealing with dissent, domesticating the world: governance in post-genocide Rwanda', African Affairs, 110(438), 2011, pp 1–34. 51 United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (unhcr), 'Country Operations Profile Rwanda', 2011, at http://www.unhcr.org/pages/49e45c576.html, accessed 8 November 2011. 52 'Refugees face hunger threat as farming ban bites', The Citizen (Tanzania), 24 March 2010. 53 unhcr, Regional Conference on Refugee Protection and International Migration: Mixed Movements and Irregular Migration from the East and Horn of Africa and Great Lakes Region to Southern Africa, concept paper, Dar es Salaam, 6–7 September 2010, at http://www.unhcr.org/4d5256469.pdf. 54 Chaulia, 'The politics of refugee hosting in Tanzania'; csfm et al, Going Home or Staying Home?; and Manby, Struggles for Citizenship in Africa. 55 Morel, 'The lack of refugee-burden-sharing in Tanzania'. 56 unhcr, Comprehensive Solutions to Burundian Refugees in Tanzania's Old Settlements: Update and Budget Revision, May 2009; and unhcr, '2010 unhcr country operations profile—Burundi', at http://www.unhcr.org, accessed 8 April 2010. 57 D Newman, 'Coercion and intimidation in the voluntary repatriation of 37 000 Burundian refugees from Mtabila Camp', Fahamu: Networks for Social Justice, June 2009, at http://www.pambazuka.org/actionalerts/images/uploads/FINAL_Mtabila_report.pdf, accessed 8 April 2010. 58 'Burundi: returnee families need shelter', Integrated Refugee Information Network (irin), 27 October 2009. 59 'Burundi: "peace villages" come with a price', irin, Bujumbura, 31 March 2010. 60 S Fransen & K Kuschminder, Back to the Land: The Long-term Challenges of Refugee Return and Reintegration in Burundi, unhcr: New Issues in Refugee Research Working Paper 242, August 2012. 61 K Vlassenroot & C Huggins, 'Land, migration and conflict in Eastern DR Congo', Eco-Conflicts (African Centre for Technology Studies), 3(4), 2004, pp 1–4. 62 B Baha, The Politics of Investment in Large Scale Agricultural Ventures: Case of Mpanda, Rukwa Tanzania, Report for Land Rights and Research and Resources Institute/haki/Ardhi, Dar es Salaam, 2010, at http://www.oaklandinstitute.org/politics-investment-large-scale-agricultural-ventures-case-mpanda-rukwa-tanzania, accessed 9 November 2011. 63 P Daley, 'Refugees and underdevelopment in Africa: the case of Barundi Refugees in Tanzania', DPhil thesis, Faculty of Anthropology and Geography, University of Oxford, 1989. 64 United Republic of Tanzania, Prime Minister's Office Regional Administration and Local Government, National Strategy for Community Integration Programme (2010–2014), 2010, p 5. 65 In 2011 the Regional Commissioner for Mtwara went on television to criticise the relocation plans and others followed suit. 66 Interview with government advisor, Dar es Salaam, 2011. 67 Manby, Struggles for Citizenship in Africa. 68 C Chachage, Land Acquisition and Accumulation in Tanzania: The Case of Morogoro, Iringa and Pwani Region, Dar es Salaam: pelum Tanzania, 2010; and E Sulle & F Nelson, Biofuels, Land Access and Rural Livelihoods in Tanzania, London: iied/Tanzania Natural Resource Forum, 2009. 69 Interview in Dar es Salaam with key informant, October 2011. 70 hrw, Burundi: Emptying the Hills—Regroupement in Burundi, New York: hrw, 2000. 71 Ibid. 72 idmc, Burundi: Secure Tenure and Land Access still Challenges for Long Term idps , 18 August 2011, at http://www.internal-displacement.org/8025708F004BE3B1/(httpInfoFiles)/7F8593C16A45E842C12578F000525A48/$file/Burundi+-+August+2011.pdf. 73 Ibid. 74 hrw, Always on the Run: The Vicious Cycle of Displacement in Eastern Congo, New York: hrw, 2010. 75 Ibid. 76 unhcr, 'DR Congo—new displacement in North Kivu', Briefing Notes, 26 January 2010, at http://www.unhcr.org/4b5ee9ae9.html, accessed 8 April 2010. 77 hrw, Always on the Run. 78 G Nzongola-Ntalaja, The Congo: From Leopold to Kabila—A People's History, London: Zed Press, 2002. 79 hrw, Always on the Run; and International Crisis Group (icg), Eastern Congo: Why Stabilization Failed, Africa Briefing no 91, 4 October 2012, Kinshasa: icg. 80 csfm et al, Going Home or Staying Home?. 81 Geschiere, The Perils of Belonging, p 21. 82 Pottier, 'Displacement and ethnic reintegration in Ituri'. 83 Rema Minstries, 'Umenga Nturi Abaraundi': Rethinking Reintegration in Burundi, Burundi, May 2012. 84 unhcr, 'unhcr-sponsored village promotes reconciliation in Burundi', 2 October 2008, at http://www.unhcr.org, accessed 8 April 2010. 85 L Hovil et al, Resisting Repatriation: Burundian Refugees Struggling to Stay in Tanzania, report by International Refugee Rights Initiative and Rema Ministries, 2011, p 8. 86 csfm et al, Going Home or Staying Home?. 87 Ibid, p 36. 88 Rutinwa, Addressing Irregular Settlement in North West Tanzania. 89 Branch, 'Humanitarianism, violence, and the camp in Northern Uganda'.