Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Workers and Revolutionaries at the Twilight of Fordism: The Breakdown of Industrial Relations in the Automobile Plants of Detroit and Turin, 1967–1973

2004; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 45; Issue: 4 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/0023656042000292234

1469-9702

Nicola Pizzolato,

French Historical and Cultural Studies

Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image size Notes Correspondence to: Dipartimento Studi Storici, Universita´ di Palermo, Piazza Bologni 8‐90133 Palermo, Italy. Email: nico@mannotpixel.com Sugrue, The Origins of the Urban Crisis Sugrue Thomas The Origins of the Urban Crisis. Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit Princeton: Princeton University Press 1996 [Google Scholar]; Thompson, Whose Detroit? Thompson Heather, A Whose Detroit? Politics, Labor, and Race in a Modern American City Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press 2001 [Google Scholar] Coriat, L'atelier et le robot Coriat Benjamin L'ate´lier et le robot: essai sur le fordisme et la production de masse a` l'age de l'e´letronique Paris: Christian Bourgois 1990 [Google Scholar], 20. Robert Boyer and Yves Saillard defined a regime of accumulation as ‘the social and economic patterns that enable accumulation to occur in the long term between two structural crises’, in Boyer and Saillard, Re´gulation Theory Boyer R Saillard Y eds Re´gulation Theory. The State of Art London: Routledge 2002 [Google Scholar], 36. The re´gulation scholars have the merit of having elaborated an analysis of how Fordism has ‘regulated’ capitalism development in the twentieth century. The founding work of this school is Aglietta, A Theory of Capitalist Regulation Aglietta Michel A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US experience London: New Left Books 1979 [Google Scholar]; but since then there have been several contributions to this line of thought, in particular from French scholars: see Lipietz, ‘Reflection on a Tale.’ For a critical survey of this theory I direct the reader to Boyer, The Regulation School Boyer R The Regulation School: A Critical Introduction New York: Columbia University Press 1990 [Google Scholar]; Jessop, ‘Regulation Theories in Retrospect and Prospect;’ Jessop, Bob. 1990. ‘Regulation Theories in Retrospect and Prospect.’, Economy and Society, 19(no. 2): 153–216. [Google Scholar] Tickell and Peck, ‘Accumulation, Regulation and the Geographies of Post‐Fordism.’ Tickell, A and Peck, JA. 1992. ‘Accumulation, Regulation and the Geographies of Post‐Fordism: Missing Links in Regulationist Research.’, Progress in Human Geography, 16(no. 2): 190–218. [Google Scholar] I draw the terms ‘core’ and later ‘periphery’ from and use the concept of ‘world system’ with reference to Wallerstein's classic The Modern World‐System Wallerstein Immanuel The Modern World‐System: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World‐Economy in the Sixteenth Century New York: Academic Press 1974 [Google Scholar]. I believe that the world‐system model provides a useful framework to examine the relevance of metropolitan areas such as Detroit and Turin to the world economy and explain why they became poles of attraction for both capital and workers. However, by using these concepts I do not automatically subscribe to every aspects of that theory. A discussion on the limits of Wallerstein's world system, especially its mechanicist nature, is out of place here, but can be found in Van der Linden, ‘Global Labor History,’ Marcel, Van der Linden. 2001. ‘Global Labor History and the “Modern World System”: Thoughts at the Twenty‐Fifth Anniversary of the Fernard Braudel Center.’, International Review of Social History, 46: 423–59. [Google Scholar] 423–59. I borrow these terms from O'Connor, The Fiscal Crisis of the State O'Connor James, R The Fiscal Crisis of the State New York 1973 [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]. But this is also the case for the second‐generation southern migrants in Turin, according to two sociological studies of generational mobility: Ceravolo et al., ‘Migrazioni e integrazione sociale;’ Ceravolo F Eve M Meraviglia C ‘Migrazioni e integrazione sociale: un percorso a stadi.’ In L'Italia delle disuguaglianze edited by Bianco M Rome: Carocci 2001 [Google Scholar] Negri, ‘I nuovi torinesi.’ Negri Nicola ‘I nuovi torinesi: immigrazione, mobilita` e struttura sociale.’ In Progetto Torino 5. La citta` difficile edited by Martinetti Guido Milan: Franco Angeli 1982 [Google Scholar] The comparative method has long proved a rewarding tool for historians and social scientists who seek to gain insights into phenomena occurring in two or more social systems. In comparing Detroit and Turin I have in particular taken into account some key articles and books that appeared in the 1980s, such as Fredrickson, ‘Comparative History,’ Fredrickson George ‘Comparative History.’ In The Past before US: Contemporary Historical Writings in the US edited by Kammen M Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press 1980 [Google Scholar] 457–73; Kolchin, ‘Comparing American History,’ Kolchin, Peter. 1982. ‘Comparing American History.’, Reviews of American History, 10(no. 4): 64–81. [Google Scholar] 64–81. Grew, ‘The Case for Comparing Histories,’ Grew, Raymond. 1980. ‘The Case for Comparing Histories.’, American Historical Review, 85(no. 4): 87–101. [Google Scholar] 763–778; Fredrickson, White Supremacy —— White Supremacy: A Comparative Study in American and South African History New York: Oxford University Press 1981 [Google Scholar]; Kolchin, Unfree Labor —— Unfree labor: American Slavery and Russian Serfdom Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press 1987 [Google Scholar], as well as the well‐known theoretical framework provided by Skocpol and Somers, ‘The Uses of Comparative History in Macrosocial Inquiry,’ Skocpol, T and Somers, M. 1980. ‘The Uses of Comparative History in Macrosocial Inquiry.’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 22: 174–97. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar] 174–97. I also benefited from the debate on transnational history that appeared in the Journal of American History 86 (1999). Lago and Halpern, The American South and the Italian Mezzogiorno is a work of comparison between the two regions. Holley, The Second Great Emancipation Holley Donald The Second Great Emancipation: The Mechanical Cotton Picker, Black Migration and How They Shaped the Modern South Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press 2000 [Google Scholar]; Ford, The Southern Appalachian Region Ford Thomas, R ed The Southern Appalachian Region: A Survey Lexington: University of Kentucky Press 1967 [Google Scholar]; Wright, Old South, New South Wright Gavin Old South, New South New York: Basic Books 1986 [Google Scholar], 241–43. Eckaus, ‘Il divario nord–sud nei primi decenni dell'unita`;’ Eckaus Richard ‘Il divario nord–sud nei primi decenni dell'unita`.’ In La formazione dell'Italia Industriale edited by Caracciolo A Bari: Laterza 1972 35 63 [Google Scholar] Castronovo, Storia economica d'Italia Castronovo Valerio Storia Economica d'Italia Turin: Einaudi 1995 [Google Scholar], 1–105. Ginsborg, Storia d'Italia 1943 Ginsborg Paul Storia d'Italia 1943–1996 Torino: Einaudi 1998 [Google Scholar] –1996, 143; Braghin, Inchiesta sulla miseria in Italia Braghin Paolo ed Inchiesta sulla miseria in Italia (1951–52). Materiali della commissione parlamentare Turin: Einaudi 1978 [Google Scholar]; Castronovo, Storia economica d'Italia, 397. See Jones, The Dispossessed Jones Jacqueline The Dispossessed New York: Basic Books 1992 [Google Scholar], 224; Lemann, The Promised Land Lemann Nicholas The Promised Land: The Great Black Migration and How It Changed America New York: Knopfs 1991 [Google Scholar]; Johnson and Campbell, Black Migration in America Johnson DM Campbell RR Black Migration in America: A Social Demographic History Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press 1981 [Google Scholar]; on Italian migration see: Ascoli, Movimenti migratori in Italia Ascoli Ugo Movimenti migratori in Italia Bologna: Il Mulino 1979 [Google Scholar], 117–27; Reyneri, La catena migratoria Reyneri Emilio. La catena migratoria Bologna: Il Mulino 1980 [Google Scholar]; Pugliese ‘Gli squilibri del mercato del lavoro,’ Pugliese Enrico ‘Gli squilibri del mercato del lavoro.’ In Storia dell'Italia Repubblicana. La trasformazione dell'Italia. Sviluppo e squilibri 2 Turin: Einaudi 1995 [Google Scholar] 421–65. Sugrue, The Origins of the Urban Crisis. Sugrue Thomas The Origins of the Urban Crisis. Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit Princeton: Princeton University Press 1996 [Google Scholar] For the reception of southern migrants in northern Italy see: Batacchi, Meridionali e Settentrioni Batacchi Marco Meridionali e Settentrionali nella struttura del pregiudizio etnico in Italia Bologna: Il Mulino 1959 [Google Scholar]; Fofi, L' immigrazione meridionale a Torino Fofi Goffredo L'immigrazione meridionale a Torino Milan: Feltrinelli 1963 [Google Scholar]. Concerning the post‐war period see: Hirsch, Making the Second Ghetto Hirsch Arnold, R Making the Second Ghetto: Race and Housing in Chicago, 1940–1960 New York: Cambridge University Press 1983 [Google Scholar]; Jackson, Crabgrass Frontier Jackson Kenneth Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the United States New York: Oxford University Press 1985 [Google Scholar]; Newman et al., Protest, Politics, and Prosperity Newman Dorothy et al. Protest, Politics, and Prosperity: Black Americans, White Institutions, 1940–1975 New York: Pantheon 1978 [Google Scholar]; Trotter, ‘Blacks in the Urban North Trotter Joe William jr. ‘Blacks in the Urban North: The “Underclass Question” in Historical Perspective.’ In The ‘Underclass’ Debate. Views from History edited by Katz Michael, B Princeton: Princeton University Press 1993 [Google Scholar],’ 28–55; Sugrue, The Origins of the Urban Crisis Sugrue Thomas The Origins of the Urban Crisis. Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit Princeton: Princeton University Press 1996 [Google Scholar]. A point also made by Donna Gabaccia in relation to Italian migrants to the US in Italy's Many Diasporas. Barbano and Garelli, ‘Struttura e cultura nell'immigrazione;’ Barbano F Garelli F ‘Struttura e cultura nell'immigrazione. Il caso di Torino.’ In Strutture della trasformazione. Torino 1945–1975 Turin: Cassa di Risparmio, di Torino 1980 [Google Scholar] Paci, Mercato del lavoro e classi sociali in Italia —— Mercato del lavoro e classi sociali in Italia Bologna: Il mulino 1973 [Google Scholar]. Fofi, L' immigrazione meridionale a Torino Fofi Goffredo L'immigrazione meridionale a Torino Milan: Feltrinelli 1963 [Google Scholar], 91, 98; Anfossi, ‘Differenze socio‐culturali tra gruppi piemontesi e meridionali a Torino.’ Anfossi Anna ‘Differenze socio‐culturali tra gruppi piemontesi e meridionali a Torino.’ In Immigrazione e Industria edited by Anfossi A Milan: Edizioni di Comunita` 1962 [Google Scholar] IRES, Immigrazione di massa e struttura sociale in Piemonte IRES Immigrazione di massa e struttura sociale in Piemonte Turin 1965 [Google Scholar], 240–42 Philliber and Obermiller argued that there existed a segmented job market with three layers: the best jobs went to the dominant group; next came the white migrants. Whatever was left went to blacks. For a white Appalachian, however, possession of a college degree delivered the entrance into mainstream northern society. This was not the case for African‐Americans. Educated blacks were often offered work as janitors, although also in their case education could provide more chances to get a decent job. Philliber, ‘Appalachians in Midwestern Cities,’ —— In Too Few Tomorrows edited by P. J. Obermiller and W. W. Philliber, Boone, NC: Appalachian Consortium Press 1987 7 28 [Google Scholar] 21; see also Philliber, Appalachian Migrants in Urban America Philliber WW Appalachian Migrants in Urban America: Cultural Conflict or Ethnic Group Formation? New York: Praeger 1981 [Google Scholar]; Tucker Anderson, ‘Last Hired, First Fired,’ 82–97. For narratives of hillbillies' arrival in Detroit, see Hartigan, Racial Situations Hartigan John Racial Situations: Class Predicaments of Whiteness in Detroit Princeton: Princeton University Press 1999 [Google Scholar], 47. The survey of Kornhauser, Detroit as People See It Kornhauser Arthur Detroit as People See It: A Survey of Attitudes in an Industrial City Detroit: Wayne State University Press 1952 [Google Scholar], shows that Detroiters saw southerners, whatever their race, as a cultural ‘other.’ By reading Kornhauser one is left with the impression that Detroiters alternately directed their contempt at blacks or hillbillies depending upon what unpleasant encounters they had in their neighbourhood or workplace. For an anthropological study of the Briggs area, see Hartigan, Racial Situations. Hartigan John Racial Situations: Class Predicaments of Whiteness in Detroit Princeton: Princeton University Press 1999 [Google Scholar] Arrighi et al., Antisystemic Movements Arrighi G Hopkins T Wallerstein I Antisystemic Movements London: Verso 1989 [Google Scholar], 97. Fraser, 1968 Fraser Ronald ed 1968. A Student Generation in Revolt London: Chattus & Windus 1988 [Google Scholar] ; Ortoleva Katsiaficas George The Imagination of the New Left. A Global Analysis of 1968 Boston: South End Press 1987 [Google Scholar], Saggio sui movimenti del 1968 in Europa e in America; Katsiaficas, The Imagination of the New Left Katsiaficas George The Imagination of the New Left. A Global Analysis of 1968 Boston: South End Press 1987 [Google Scholar]; Marwick, The Sixties Marwick Arthur The Sixties: Cultural Revolution in Britain, France, Italy, and the U. S. 1958–1974 Oxford: Oxford University Press 1988 [Google Scholar]; Flores and De Bernardi, Il Sessantotto. For a sample of this literature see Harman, The Fire Last Time Harman Chris The Fire Last Time: 1968 and After London: Bookmarks 1998 [Google Scholar]; for the Canadian case see Palmer, Working‐Class Experience Palmer Bryan, D Working‐Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour Toronto: McClelland & Stewart 1992 [Google Scholar], 314–16; for Chile see Winn, Weavers of the Revolution Winn Peter Weavers of the Revolution: The Yarur Workers and Chile's Road to Socialism New York: Oxford University Press 1986 [Google Scholar]; for South Africa see Adler, ‘The Factory Belongs to All Who Work in It;’ Adler Glenn ‘The Factory Belongs to All Who Work in It: Race, Class, and Collective Action in the South African Motor Industry, 1967–1986.’ PhD diss., Columbia University 1994 [Google Scholar] for Brazil see Humphrey, Capitalist Control and Workers Struggle in the Brazilian Auto Industry Humphrey John Capitalist Control and Workers Struggle in the Brazilian Auto Industry Princeton: Princeton University Press 1982 [Google Scholar]. Arrighi et al., Antisystemic Movements Arrighi G Hopkins T Wallerstein I Antisystemic Movements London: Verso 1989 [Google Scholar], 1. Ginsborg, A History of Contemporary Italy Ginsborg Paul A History of Contemporary Italy. Society and Politics 1943–1988 London: Penguin 1990 [Google Scholar], 298; for an overview see also Tranfaglia, ‘Dall'avvento del Centro Sinistra al Delitto Moro;’ Tranfaglia Nicola ‘Dall'avvento del Centro Sinistra al Delitto Moro.’ In Lezioni Sull'Italia Repubblicana edited by Bevilaqua Piero et al., Rome: Donzelli 1994 [Google Scholar] a monograph on the subject is Tamburrano, Storia e Cronaca del Centro Sinistra Tamburrano Giuseppe Storia e Cronaca del Centro Sinistra Milan: Feltrinelli 1990 [Google Scholar]. Ginsborg, A History of Contemporary Italy Ginsborg Paul A History of Contemporary Italy. Society and Politics 1943–1988 London: Penguin 1990 [Google Scholar]; Lanaro, Storia dell'Italia Repubblicana Lanaro Silvio Storia dell'Italia Repubblicana. Dalla fine della Guerra agli anni novanta Venice: Marsilio 1992 [Google Scholar]; Revelli, ‘Movimenti Sociali e Spazio Politico,’ Revelli Marco ‘Movimenti Sociali e Spazio Politico.’ In Storia dell'Italia Repubblicana –La trasformazione dell'Italia: sviluppo e squilibri 2 Turin: Einaudi 1995 [Google Scholar] 399–436. This interpretation was initially sparked by the ‘Kerner’ report on the riot—see Report of The National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders Report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders New York: Bantam Books 1968 [Google Scholar] —and is reprised in a number of works. See, for instance, Patterson, Grand Expectations Patterson James, T Grand Expectations. The United States, 1945–1974 New York: Oxford University Press 1996 [Google Scholar], 562–92; Isserman and Kazin, America Divided Isserman M Kazin M America Divided. The Civil War of the 1960s New York: Oxford University Press 2000 [Google Scholar], 187–203; Chafe, The Unfinished Journey Chafe William, H The Unfinished Journey. America since World War II New York: Oxford University Press 1986 [Google Scholar], 302–42. Archivio Storico della FIOM Provinciale di Torino, Torino 1945 Archivio Storico della FIOM Provinciale di Torino Torino 1945–1983, Memoria FIOM Milan: Franco Angeli 1985 [Google Scholar] –1983; Trentin, Autunno Caldo Trentin Bruno Autunno Caldo. Il Secondo Biennio Rosso 1968–1969 Rome: Editori Riuniti 1999 [Google Scholar]. This view is also accepted by non‐Italian scholars; see Grisoni and Portelli, Le Lotte Operaie in Italia Grisoni D Portelli H Le Lotte Operaie in Italia dal 1960 al 1976 Milan: Rizzoli 1977 [Google Scholar]; Sabel, Work and Politics Sabel C Work and Politics: The Division of Labour in Industry Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1982 [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]. Pugno and Garavini, Gli anni duri alla Fiat Pugno E Garavini S Gli anni duri alla Fiat Turin: Einaudi 1975 [Google Scholar], 5; and Sapelli et al., Fiat e Stato Sapelli G Pugno E Gobbi R Trentin B Fiat e Stato Turin: Istituto Gramsci 1978 [Google Scholar], 33. Berta, Conflitto industriale e struttura d'impresa Berta Giuseppe Conflitto industriale e struttura d'impresa alla FIAT Bologna: Il Mulino 1998 [Google Scholar], 153 Scavino, ‘Un tentativo di interpretazione,’ 131. Geshwender, Class, Race, and Workers Insurgency Gershwender James Class, Race, and Workers Insurgency: The League of Revolutionary Black Workers Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1977 [Google Scholar]; Georgakas and Survin, Detroit Georgakas D Survin M Detroit: I Do Mind Dying Cambridge, Mass.: South End Press 1977 [Google Scholar]; Fujita, Black Worker's Struggles in Detroit's Auto Industry Fujita Kuniko Black Worker's Struggles in Detroit's Auto Industry, 1935–1975 Saratoga, Calif.: Century Twenty‐One 1980 [Google Scholar]; Jefferys, Management and the Managed Jefferys Steve Management and the Managed Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1984 [Google Scholar], 168–87; Widick, Detroit Widick BJ Detroit: City of Class and Race Violence Detroit: Wayne State University Press 1989 [Google Scholar], 196–200; Thompson, Whose Detroit?, Thompson Heather, A Whose Detroit? Politics, Labor, and Race in a Modern American City Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press 2001 [Google Scholar] 159–92. Brenner, ‘Rank‐and‐File Rebellion;’ Aaron Brenner ‘Rank‐and‐File Rebellion, 1966–1975.’ PhD diss., Columbia University 1996 [Google Scholar] Green, The World of the Worker Green James The World of the Worker: Labor in Twentieth‐Century America New York: Hill & Wang 1980 [Google Scholar]; Moody, An Injury to All Moody Kim An Injury to All: The Decline of American Unionism London: Verso 1988 [Google Scholar], chapters 1–3; Brecher, Strike!. Soskice, ‘Strike Waves and Wage Explosion.’ Soskice David ‘Strike Waves and Wage Explosion, 1968–1970: An Economic Interpretation.’ In The Resurgence of Class Conflict in Western Europe since 1968 edited by Pizzorno A Crouch Colin Vols 1 and 2 London: Macmillan 1978 [Google Scholar] This argument is developed in Huntington et al., The Crisis of Democracy Huntington S Crozier M Watanuki J The Crisis of Democracy: Report on the Governability of Democracy to the Trilateral Commission New York: New York University Press 1975 [Google Scholar]; Goldthorpe, ‘The Current Inflation,’ Goldthorpe JH ‘The Current Inflation: Towards a Sociological Approach.’ In The Political Economy of Inflation edited by Hirsch F Goldthorpe JH Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press 1978 [Google Scholar] 186–214. Piore and Sabel, The Second Industrial Divide Piore M Sabel C The Second Industrial Divide: Possibility for Prosperity New York: Basic Books 1984 [Google Scholar], 167–68. See also Sabel, Work and Politics Sabel C Work and Politics: The Division of Labour in Industry Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1982 [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]. Honneth, The Fragmented World of the Social Honneth Axel The Fragmented World of the Social edited by Wright CW Albany: State University of New York Press 1995 [Google Scholar], xiv. Ibid., The Struggle for Recognition. Ibid., 162. See Lanzardo, Personalita' operaia e coscienza di classe Lanzardo Liliana Personalita' operaia e coscienza di classe. Comunisti e cattolici nelle fabbriche torinesi del dopoguerra Milan: Franco Angeli 1987 [Google Scholar]; Passerini and Filippa, ‘Memorie di Mirafiori,’ Passerini L Filippa M ‘Memorie di Mirafiori.’ In Mirafiori. 1936–1962 edited by Olmo C Turin: Allemandi 1997 [Google Scholar] 341. Quoted in Giachetti and Scavino, La Fiat in mano agli operai Giachetti D Scavino M La Fiat in mano agli operai Pisa, Italy: BFS edizioni 1999 [Google Scholar], 38. Under the new leadership of Giovanni Agnelli after the death of Vittorio Valletta, who in the 1950s was the main person responsible for the reorganization of mass production under the American model. A point made by Berta, Piore and Sabel, The Second Industrial Divide Piore M Sabel C The Second Industrial Divide: Possibility for Prosperity New York: Basic Books 1984 [Google Scholar], 87. Archivio Storico FIAT, interview with Vincenzo Damiano, no. 2.10. Bruno, ‘The Industrial Reserve Army,’ Bruno, Sergio. 1979. ‘The Industrial Reserve Army. Segmentation and the Italian Labour Market.’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 3: 131–51. [Google Scholar] 131–51. Archivio Storico FIAT, interview with Armando Bianchi, no. 2.01. This an episode cited in La Classe, 21–28 June 1969, 8. Luciano Parlanti, in Polo, I Tamburi di Mirafiori Polo Gabriele I Tamburi di Mirafiori. Testimonianze operaie attorno all'autunno caldo alla Fiat Turin: CRIC 1989 [Google Scholar], 53. Mario Dalmaviva, in Giachetti, Oltre il Sessantotto Giachetti D ed Oltre il Sessantotto: prima, durante e dopo il movemento Pisa: BFS 1998 [Google Scholar]. Interview with Andrea Papaleo, in Polo, I Tamburi di Mirafiori Polo Gabriele I Tamburi di Mirafiori. Testimonianze operaie attorno all'autunno caldo alla Fiat Turin: CRIC 1989 [Google Scholar], 212. ‘La Fiat ricatta minacciando sospensioni,’ L'unita`, 2 June 1969. Radical protest also included occasions of social interaction with students that were important for the social integration of the migrant. Commented a migrant: ‘there were a lot of students who used to come outside the gates at Mirafiori. It was full of university students and we, ill‐mannered [cafoni] Meridionali, miserable wretched who never went to school, had the opportunity to meet such girls with furs,’ quoted in Borio et al., Futuro Anteriore Borio G Pozzi F Roggero G Futuro Anteriore Rome: DeriveApprodi 2002 [Google Scholar], 3. For worker Cesare Cosi, ‘An old worker who for years had felt almost like an inferior being, all of a sudden had a young woman [student] taking interest in his life, telling him he was the center of everything,’ quoted in Polo, I Tamburi di Mirafiori Polo Gabriele I Tamburi di Mirafiori. Testimonianze operaie attorno all'autunno caldo alla Fiat Turin: CRIC 1989 [Google Scholar], 152. Interview with Domenico Norcia, in Norcia, Io garantito Norcia Domenico Io garantito. Frammenti di vita e di pensieri di un operaio Fiat edited by Torora F Rome: Edizioni del lavoro 1981 [Google Scholar], 51–54. Ibid. Interview with Pasquale De Stefani, April 2001. Interview with General Baker, May 2002. I gathered information about the Socialist Workers' Party in Detroit thanks to interviews with Dan Georgakas, April 2002, and Martin Glaberman, June 2001. See also Le Blanc and Barret, Revolutionary Labor Socialist. Mkalimoto (former DRUM member), ‘Dying from the Inside,’ 81. League of Revolutionary Black Workers, ‘General Program (Here's Where We're Coming From).’ Widick, Detroit Widick BJ Detroit: City of Class and Race Violence Detroit: Wayne State University Press 1989 [Google Scholar], 193. This is from a 1968 draft of its programme in ALUA, DRM collection, box 1, folder 1. In this regard an interesting episode is related by UAW Local 3 President Ed Liska concerning an African‐American who had worked only nine days and ‘was ready to go to prison’ to have the initiation fee back. Ed Liska's diary, entry 7 July 1969, in ALUA, Liska collection, box 1, folder June 1969 to December 1969. Levy, The New Left and Labor in the 1960 Levy Peter, B The New Left and Labor in the 1960s Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press 1994 [Google Scholar] s; ALUA, DRM collection, folder 5, box 4, DRUM newsletter no. 3, May 1968. Interview with Eula Powell, June 2001. Asked what she meant by ‘smart’, Powell candidly added that a few of them had become supervisors within the company. Interview with Clifford Brookins, Jr, June 2001; Widick, Detroit Widick BJ Detroit: City of Class and Race Violence Detroit: Wayne State University Press 1989 [Google Scholar], 199. Interview with Clifford Brookins, Jr, June 2001. See correspondence between Dodge Main labor relations supervisor Kowalsky and UAW Local 3 President Pasica in ALUA, UAW Local 3 collection, box 11, folder 16–18. A Chrysler executive reported to the media, ‘one of every five assembly workers is on narcotics and one in three carry guns to work;’ this is related by Liska in his Diary, entry 24 June 1971, ALUA, Liska collection. Passerini, ‘Women's Personal Narratives,’ Passerini L ‘Women's Personal Narratives: Myths, Experience and Emotions.’ In Interpreting Women's Lives: Feminist Theory and Personal Narratives edited by Persona Narratives Group, Indiana University Press 1989 [Google Scholar] 191; interview with Clifford Brookins, Jr. Ibid. Honneth, The Struggle for Recognition —— The Struggle for Recognition Cambridge: Polity Press 1995 [Google Scholar], 161–62. I take encouragement here from Antonio Negri's reading of Marx in ‘John M. Keynes e la teoria capitalista dello stato nel '29.’ Faruk Tabak Tabak Faruk ‘The World Labor Force.’ In The Age of Transition: Trajectory of the World System, 1945–2025 London: Pluto Press 1996 87 116 [Google Scholar], ‘The World Labor Force.’ Lyotard, The Postmodern Condition.