Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Militarism, Realism, Just War, or Nonviolence? Critical Geopolitics and the Problem of Normativity

2008; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 13; Issue: 3 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/14650040802203703

1557-3028

Nick Megoran,

Global Security and Public Health

Abstract Despite illuminating multiple modalities by which armed conflict is discursively justified, critical geopolitics can be criticised for providing a weak normative engagement with the social institution and practices of warfare. This has limited the impact of this school of thought outside of geography and critical security studies at a time when the ethics of military intervention have been prominent in public debate. This article explores the moral discourse of critical geopolitics through an examination of Gerard Toal's writings on Iraq and Bosnia. This scholarship is reviewed in the light of Coates's typology of major traditions of moral reflection on war – militarism, realism, just war theory, and pacifism/nonviolence. This analysis interrogates Toal's narratives, in which American military intervention was advocated in the Former Yugoslavia and opposed in Iraq. This suggests that rather than a thoroughgoing commitment to pacifism/nonviolence, or a blanket cynicism about American foreign policy, Toal's thinking includes an underlying attachment to some form of just war reasoning. However, its implicit and partial appropriation leads to a certain incoherence and selectivity that calls for further reflection. This presents a challenge to critical geopolitics. If it chooses to engage more explicitly with just war theory, its insights into identity and militarism could in turn inform a reworking of aspects of the theory, thereby facilitating critical geopolitics' engagement with wider public anti-militaristic modes of discourse. However, as this risks blunting the political potential of the project and repeating the mistakes of twentieth-century geopolitical thought, the paper concludes with a call for a wholehearted commitment to nonviolence. Notes 1. L. Dowler and J. Sharp, 'A Feminist Geopolitics?', Space & Polity 5/3 (2001) pp. 165–176: 168–9. 2. P. Routledge, 'Critical Geopolitics and Terrains of Resistance', Political Geography 15/6–7 (1996) pp. 509–531. 3. S. Dalby, 'Geopolitics, the Bush Doctrine, and War on Iraq', The Arab World Geographer 6/1 (2003) pp. 7–18. 4. M. Heffernan, 'Balancing Visions: Comments on Gearóid Ó Tuathail's Critical Geopolitics', Political Geography 19/3 (2000) pp. 347–352: 351. 5. M. Polelle, Raising Cartographic Consciousness: The Social and Foreign Policy Vision of Geopolitics in the Twentieth Century (Oxford: Lexington 1999) p. 5. 6. K. Dodds, Global Geopolitics: A Critical Introduction (London: Pearson Education 2005) p. 228. 7. S. Dalby, 'Writing Critical Geopolitics: Campbell, Ó Tuathail, Reynolds and Dissident Skepticism', Political Geography 15/6–7 (1996) pp. 655–660: 655. 8. L. Dowler and J. Sharp, 'A Feminist Geopolitics?', Space & Polity 5/3 (2001) pp. 165–176: 167. 9. J. P. Sharp, 'Remasculinising Geo-Politics? Comments on Gearoid Ó Tuathail's Critical Geopolitics', Political Geography 19/3 (2000) pp. 361–364: 362. 10. A. Murphy, 'Review of "Geopolitical Traditions: A Century of Gepolitical Thought", by Klaus Dodds and David Atkinson', Annals of the Association of American Geographers 91/4 (2001) pp. 767–769: 769. 11. P. Kelly, 'A Critique of Critical Geopolitics', Geopolitics 11/1 (2006) pp. 24–53: 43. 12. Ibid., p. 48. 13. G. Ó Tuathail and S. Dalby, 'Introduction: Rethinking Geopolitics: Towards a Critical Geopolitics', in G. Ó Tuathail and S. Dalby (eds.), Rethinking Geopolitics (London: Routledge 1998) p. 14. 14. S. Dalby, 'Post-Cold War Security in the New Europe', in J. O'Loughlin and H. v. d. Wusten (eds.), The New Political Geography of Eastern Europe (London: Bellhaven 1993) pp. 71–85. 15. P. E. Gottfried, Multiculturalism and the Politics of Guilt: Towards a Secular Theocracy (London: University of Missouri Press 2002). 16. R. Bainton, Christian Attitudes Toward War and Peace: A Historical Survey and Critical Re-evaluation (London: Hodder and Stoughton 1961); for a discussion of this taxonomy, see D. Little, '"Holy War" Appeals and Western Christianity: A Reconsideration of Bainton's Approach', in J. Kelsay and J. T. Johnson (eds.), Just War and Jihad: Historical and Theoretical Perspectives on War and Peace in Western and Islamic Traditions (London: Greenwood 1991) pp. 121–139. 17. A. J. Coates, The Ethics of War (Manchester: Manchester University Press 1997). 18. Ibid., p. 41. 19. J. Bourke, An Intimate History of Killing: Face-to-Face Killing in Twentieth-Century Warfare (London: Granta 1999). 20. J. Riley-Smith, What Were The Crusades? (London: Macmillan 1992). 21. M. Mann, States, War and Capitalism: Studies in Political Sociology (Oxford: Basil Blackwell 1988) p. ix. 22. M. Zalewski and C. Enloe, 'Questions about Identity in International Relations', in K. Booth and S. Smith (eds.), International Relations Theory Today (Cambridge: Polity 1995) pp. 279–305: 294. 23. K. Waltz, 'International Politics Is Not Foreign Policy', Security Studies 6/1 (1996) pp. 54–57. 24. K. Waltz, Theory of International Politics (London: McGraw-Hill 1979) p. 107. 25. R. Schweller, 'Fantasy Theory', Review of International Studies 25/1 (1999) pp. 147–150: 150. 26. G. Ó Tuathail, 'The Patterned Mess of History and the Writing of Critical Geopolitics: A Reply to Dalby', Political Geography 15/6/7 (1996) pp. 661–665: 663. 27. J. Mearsheimer, 'Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq War: Realism Versus Neo-Conservatism', www.opendemocracy.net 19-05-2005 (2005). 28. R. Ashley, 'The Geopolitics of Geopolitical Space: Toward a Critical Social Theory of International Politics', Alternatives 12/4 (1987) pp. 403–434: 241. 29. T. Biersteker and C. Weber, 'The Social Construction of State Sovereignty', in T. Biersteker and C. Weber (eds.), State Sovereignty as Social Construct (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1996) pp. 4–5. 30. A. Wendt, 'Anarchy Is What States Make Of It: The Social Construction of Power Politics (1992)', in J. Der Derian (ed.), International Theory: Critical Investigations (London: Macmillan 1995) pp. 129–177: 132. 31. For more on war in the Hebrew Bible, see S. Nidditch, War in the Hebrew Bible: A Study in the Ethics of Violence (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1993). 32. See, inter alia, R. Musto, The Catholic Peace Tradition (New York: Orbis Books 1986); A. Kreider, Worship and Evangelism in Pre-Christendom (Cambridge: Grove 1995). 33. J. T. Johnson, 'Historical Roots and Sources of the Just War Tradition in Western Culture', in J. Kelsay and J. T. Johnson (eds.), Just War and Jihad: Historical and Theoretical Perspectives on War and Peace in Western and Islamic Traditions (London: Greenwood 1991) pp. 1–30. 34. Information in this and the following paragraph is distilled from N. Megoran, The War on Terror: How Should Christians Respond? (Nottingham: InterVarsity Press 2007) pp. 133–135. 35. The following discussion is necessarily simplified: much could be written on each of the criteria, and the relationship between them. For example, some theorists have posited the existence of a 'supreme emergency', a complicated situation whereby jus in bello could be set aside if jus ad bellum were satisfied. See B. Orend, 'Is There a Supreme Emergency Exemption?', in M. Evans (ed.), Just War Theory: A Reappraisal (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press 2005) pp. 134–153 and M. Walzer, Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations (New York: Basic Books 2000 [orig. 1977]), Chapter 16; against this, see O. O'Donovan, Just War Revisited (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2003) p. 10. 36. M. Evans, 'Moral Theory and the Idea of A Just War', in M. Evans (ed.), Just War Theory: A Reappraisal (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press 2005) pp. 1–21: 13. 37. O. O'Donovan, Just War Revisited (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2003) p. 13. 38. C. Reed, Just War? (London: SPCK 2004). 39. J. Welsh, (ed.), Humanitarian Intervention and International Relations (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2004). 40. J. Kelsay and J. T. Johnson, 'Just War and Jihad: Historical and Theoretical Perspectives on War and Peace in Western and Islamic Traditions' (London: Greenwood 1991). 41. M. Walzer, Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations (New York: Basic Books 2000 [orig. 1977]) p. xxi. 42. Ibid., p. xx. 43. M. Hayden, 'Security Beyond the State: Cosmopolitanism, Peace and the Role of Just War Theory', in M. Evans (ed.), Just War Theory: A Reappraisal (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press 2005) pp. 157–176: 157–158. 44. Witness the absurd position of many liberals in 2003, who held that an invasion of Iraq would be morally justified if the United Nations passed a 'second resolution', but not otherwise. 45. M. Walzer, Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations (New York: Basic Books 2000 [orig. 1977]) p. xxi. 46. R. Musto, The Catholic Peace Tradition (New York: Orbis Books 1986) p. 131. 47. J. T. Johnson, 'Just War Theory: Responding Morally to Global Terrorism', in C. W. J. Kegley (ed.), The New Global Terrorism: Characteristics, Causes, Controls (Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall 2003) pp. 223–238: 238. 48. M. Evans, 'In Humanity's Name: Democracy and the Right to Wage War', in M. Evans (ed.), Just War Theory: A Reappraisal (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press 2005) pp. 71–89: 71–72. 49. D. Cole, 'Just War, Penance, and the Church', Pro Ecclesia 11/3 (2002) pp. 313–328; J. Elshtain, Just War Against Terror: The Burden of American Power in a Violent World (New York: Basic Books 2003). 50. K. Lawton, 'Kim Lawton Interviews Jean Bethke Elshtain, March 24, 2006.', PBS Radio (2006), available at http://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/week930/interview.html, accessed April 2006. 51. L. Griffith, The War on Terrorism and the Terror of God (Cambridge: Eerdmans 2002) p. 20. 52. M. Evans, 'In Defence of Just War Theory', in M. Evans (ed.), Just War Theory: A Reappraisal (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press 2005) pp. 203–222: 214. 53. L. Griffith, The War on Terrorism and the Terror of God (Cambridge: Eerdmans 2002) p. 4. 54. S. Zunes et al., 'Introduction', in S. Zunes, L. Kurtz, and S. Asher (eds.), Nonviolent Social Movements: A Geographical Perspective (Oxford: Blackell 1999) pp. 1–5: 1. 55. R. Horsley, Jesus and the Spiral of Violence: Popular Jewish Resistance in Roman Palestine (Cambridge: Harper & Row 1987); R. Horsley, Jesus and Empire: The Kingdom of God and the New World Disorder (Minneapolis: Fortress Press 2003); R. Horsley (ed.), Paul and the Roman Imperial Order (London: Trinity Press 2004); B. Walsh and S. Keesmat, Colossians Remixed: Subverting the Empire (Milton Keynes: Paternoster Press 2004). 56. A. Kreider, Worship and Evangelism in Pre-Christendom (Cambridge: Grove 1995). 57. R. Musto, The Catholic Peace Tradition (New York: Orbis Books 1986). 58. G. Sharp, Power and Struggle (Boston: Porter Sargent 1973) pp. 75–78; S. Zunes et al. (eds.), Nonviolent Social Movements: A Geographical Perspective (Oxford: Blackell 1999). 59. L. Tolstoy, The Kingdom of God is Within You; Christianity and Patriotism (London: J. M. Dent and Co. 1905). 60. Sharp (note 58) p. 82. 61. R. Gregg, The Power of Non-Violence (London: George Routledge and Sons 1936). 62. M. Banerjee, The Pathan Unarmed: Opposition and Memory in the North West Frontier (Oxford: James Currey 2000); E. Easwaran, Nonviolent Soldier of Islam: Badshah Khan, A Man to Match His Mountains (Tomales, CA: Nilgiri Press 1984). 63. M. L. J. King, Strength to Love (Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1981). 64. G. Sharp, The Methods of Nonviolent Action (Boston: Porter Sargent 1973). 65. G. Sharp, The Dynamics of Nonviolent Action (Boston: Porter Sargent 1973); G. Sharp, Power and Struggle (Boston: Porter Sargent 1973). 66. Zunes et al., Nonviolent Social Movements (note 58). 67. Zunes et al., 'Introduction' (note 54) p. 1. 68. Ibid. 69. G. Ó Tuathail, 'The Effacement of Place? US Foreign Policy and the Spatiality of the Gulf Crisis', Antipode 25/1 (1993) pp. 4–31: 26. 70. Ibid., p. 5. 71. G. Ó Tuathail, '"Just out looking for a fight": American Affect and the Invasion of Iraq', Antipode (2003) pp. 857–80: 863. 72. G. Ó Tuathail, 'An Anti-Geopolitical Eye: Maggie O'Kane in Bosnia, 1992–3', Gender, Place and Culture 3/2 (1996) pp. 171–185: 171. 73. G. Ó Tuathail, Critical Geopolitics: The Politics of Writing Global Space (London: Routledge 1996) Chapter 6. 74. Ó Tuathail, 'An Anti-Geopolitical Eye' (note 72). 75. G. Ó Tuathail, 'The Ethnic Cleansing of a "Safe Area": The Fall of Srebrenica and the Ethics of UN-Governmentality', in J. Proctor and D. Smith (eds.), Geography and Ethics: Journeys in a Moral Terrain (London: Routledge 1999) pp. 120–131. 76. G. Ó Tuathail, 'Theorizing Practical Geopolitical Reasoning: The Case of the United States' Response to the War in Bosnia', Political Geography 21 (2002) pp. 602–628: 603. 77. G. Toal, 'Statement, to Bosnia and Herzegovina: Unfinished Business. Hearing before the Subcommittee on Europe and Emerging Threats of the Committee on International Relations, House of Representatives, 109th Congress, First Session, April 6 2005. Serial no. 109-22' (2005) pp. 11–18: 18. 78. Ó Tuathail, 'Theorizing Practical Geopolitical Reasoning' (note 76) p. 603. 79. G. Toal, 'British Acquiescence in the Destruction of Bosnia', Geopolitics 9/2 (2004) pp. 492–500: 500. 80. Ó Tuathail, 'The Ethnic Cleansing of a "Safe Area"' (note 75) p. 125. 81. G. Toal, 'British Acquiescence' (note 79) p. 500. 82. Ó Tuathail, 'The Effacement of Place?' (note 69) p. 17. 83. Ibid., p. 8. 84. N. Chomsky, The New Military Humanism: Lessons From Kosovo (London: Pluto 1999) pp. 75–78. 85. 'Statement of principles' 2005, Henry Jackson Society website, available at <http://zope06.v.servelocity.net/hjs, accessed May 2007. 86. G. Toal, 'British Acquiescence' (note 79) pp. 499–500. 87. Ó Tuathail, 'The Ethnic Cleansing of a "Safe Area"' (note 75) p. 131. 88. G. Toal, 'British Acquiescence' (note 79) p. 500. 89. M. Volf, Exclusion and Embrace: A Theological Exploration of Identity, Otherness, and Reconciliation (Nashville: Abingdon Press 1996) p. 306. 90. K. Booth, 'Beyond Critical Security Studies', in Critical Security Studies and World Politics (London: Lynne Rienner 2005) p. 273. 91. Ó Tuathail, Critical Geopolitics (note 73) p. 10. 92. E. J. Popke, 'Recasting Geopolitics: The Discursive Scripting of the International Monetary Fund', Political Geography 13/3 (1994) pp. 255–269: 225. 93. J. Agnew, Geopolitics: Re-Visioning World Politics (London: Routledge 2003). 94. K. Dodds, 'Geopolitics and Foreign Policy: Recent Developments in Anglo-American Political Geography and International Relations', Progress in Human Geography 18/2 (1994) pp. 186–208: 276. 95. S. Dalby, 'Codes, Vision, Knowledge: The Reasoning Practices of Critical Geopolitics', paper presented at the annual conference of Canadian Association of Geographers, Victoria, BC, 2003, p. 12. 96. See for example S. Dalby, 'Post-Cold War Security in the New Europe', in J. O'Loughlin and H. v. d. Wusten (eds.), The New Political Geography of Eastern Europe (London: Bellhaven 1993) pp. 71–85; M. Evangelista, Unarmed Forces: The Transnational Movement to End the Cold War (London: Cornell University Press 1999); M. McGwire, Perestroika and Soviet National Security (Washington: The Brookings Institution 1991); P. Ackerman and J. Duval, A Force More Powerful: A Century of Nonviolent Conflict (New York: St Martin's Press 2000). 97. See the modern classic study by the Mennonite J. H. Yoder, The Politics of Jesus: Vicit Agnus Noster (Carlisle: Paternoster Press 1994 [orig. 1972]); the work of Griffith, King, Kreider, and Tolstoy (cited above) would also fall into this category. For more on the author's adoption of this position, see N. Megoran, 'Christianity and Political Geography: On Faith And Geopolitical Imagination', Brandywine Review of Faith and International Affairs 2/2 (2004) pp. 40–46. 98. S. Dalby, 'Anthropocene Geopolitics: Globalisation, Empire, Environment and Critique', Geography Compass 1/1 (2007) pp. 103–118: 16. 99. M. Polelle, Raising Cartographic Consciousness: The Social and Foreign Policy Vision of Geopolitics in the Twentieth Century (Oxford: Lexington 1999) p. 145.