Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Towards a Comparative History of Communism: The British and German Communist Parties to 1933

2008; Routledge; Volume: 22; Issue: 2 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/13619460701189575

1743-7997

Norman LaPorte, Matthew Worley,

Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research

Abstract The Bolshevik Revolution of 1917 inspired the formation of communist parties across the world. These, in turn, affiliated to the Communist International founded by the Bolsheviks in 1919, through which the national parties adopted a uniform organization, policy and theory. This article seeks to survey the development of the German and British communist parties between 1918 and 1933, examining the extent to which their experiences can be compared and contrasted within the increasingly uniform paradigm established by the Communist International under pressure from Stalin's Soviet Union. By so doing, it rejects traditional monocausal arguments based exclusively on the machinations of Soviet power politics, suggesting instead that to understand the history of communism both nationally and internationally, it is necessary to consider a complex interaction of indigenous and external factors. Keywords: CommunismBritainGermanyCominternSocial Democracy Notes [1] On recent communist historiography, McDermott and Agnew McDermott, K. and Agnew, J. 1996. The Comintern: A History of International Communism from Lenin to Stalin, Basingstoke: Macmillan. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The Comintern; Rees and Thorpe Rees, T. and Thorpe, A., eds. 1998. International Communism and the Communist International, 1919–43, Manchester: Manchester University Press. [Google Scholar], eds, International Communism; Saarela and Rentola Saarela, T. and Rentola, K., eds. 1998. Communism: National and International, Helsinki: Finnish Literature Society. [Google Scholar], eds, Communism; Worley, ed. In Search of Revolution; , et al., eds. Agents of Revolution; LaPorte LaPorte, N., Morgan, K. and Worley, M., eds. 2008. Stalinisation and Beyond: Problems in Communist History, 1917–53, Basingstoke: Palgrave. (forthcoming) [Google Scholar], et al., eds. Stalinisation and Beyond (forthcoming). [2] For exceptions, Upton Upton, A. F. 1973. The Communist Parties of Scandinavia and Finland, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. [Google Scholar], The Communist Parties of Scandinavia and Finland; Caballero Caballero, M. 1986. Latin America and the Comintern, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar], Latin America and the Comintern; Weitz Weitz, E. D. 1992. Popular Communism: Political Strategies and Social Histories in the Formation of the German, French and Italian Communist Parties, 1919–48, New York: Cornell University Press. [Google Scholar], Popular Communism; Cerdas-Cruz Cerdas-Cruz, R. 1993. The Communist International in Central America, 1920–36, Basingstoke: Macmillan. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The Communist International; Wirsching Wirsching, A. 1999. Vom Weltkrieg zum Bürgerkrieg? Politischer Extremismus in Deutschland und Frankreich 1918–1933/39: Berlin und Paris im Vergleich, Munich: Oldenbourg. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Vom Weltkrieg zum Bürgerkrieg?; Morgan and Santana Morgan, K. and Santana, M. A. 1999. A Limit to Everything: Union Activists and “Bolshevik Discipline” in Britain and Brazil. Scottish Labour History, 34: 52–73. [Google Scholar], ‘A Limit to Everything’; van der Linden Linden, M. vander. 2002. “Communist Parties: The First Generation (1918–1923)”. In Transnational Labour History: Explorations, Edited by: van der Linden, M. Aldershot: Ashgate. [Google Scholar], ‘Communist Parties’, 85–94; Swain Swain, G. 2004. “Wreckage or Recovery: A Tale of Two Parties”. In In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period, Edited by: Worley, M. London: I.B. Tauris. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘Wreckage or Recovery’, 129–51; Manly Manley, J. 2005. Moscow Rules? “Red” Unionism and “Class Against Class” in Britain, Canada and the United States, 1928–35. Labour/Le Travail, 56: 9–50. [Google Scholar], ‘Moscow Rules?’; McIlroy and Campbell McIlroy, J. and Campbell, A. 2005. The British and French Representatives to the Communist International, 1920–39: A Comparative Study. International Review of Social History, 50(2): 203–40. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘The British and French Representatives’, 203–40. [3] Berger Berger, S. 2000. Guest Editorial. International and Comparative History: Socialist History, 17 [Google Scholar], ‘Guest Editorial’, 1. [4] ‘Theses on the Conditions of Admission to the Communist International’, in Adler Adler, A., ed. 1983. Theses, Resolutions and Manifestos of the First Four Congresses of the Third International, London: Pluto Press. [Google Scholar], ed. Theses, 92–7. [5] Point Eight of the ‘Statutes of the Communist International’ stated: ‘The work of the [ECCI] is performed mainly by the Party of that country where, by the decision of the World Congress, the [ECCI] is located. This Party has five representatives with full voting rights on the [ECCI]’. See Adler, ed. Theses, 125. [6] Satori Satori, G. 1991. Comparing and Miscomparing. Journal of Theoretical Politics, 3(3): 243–57. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘Comparing and Miscomparing’, 243–57. For an introduction to comparative methodology, see Berger Berger, S. 2003. “Comparative History”. In Writing History: Theory and Practice, Edited by: Berger, S., Feldner, H. and Passmore, K. London: Hodder Arnold. [Google Scholar], ‘Comparative History’, 161–79. [7] For one of the less vitriolic examples of such a reductionist approach, see McIlroy and Campbell McIlroy, J. and Campbell, A. 2003. Histories of the British Communist Party: A User's Guide. Labour History Review, 68(1): 33–60. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘Histories’, 33–60. [8] Morgan, Cohen and Flinn Morgan, K., Cohen, G. and Flinn, A. 2006. Communists in British Society, 1920–91, London: Rivers Oram. [Google Scholar], Communists; LaPorte LaPorte, N. 2003. The German Communist Party In Saxony, 1924–1933: Factionalism, Fratricide and Political Failure, Bern: Peter Lang. [Google Scholar], The German Communist Party; Worley Worley, M. 2002. Class Against Class: The Communist Party of Great Britain between the Wars, London: I.B. Tauris. [Google Scholar], Class Against Class; Weitz Weitz, E. D. 1997. Creating German Communism, 1890–1990: From Popular Protests to Socialist State, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Creating German Communism. [9] Weber Weber, H. 1969. Die Wandlung des deutschen Kommunismus: Die Stalinisierung der KPD in der Weimar republik, 2 Vols, Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanstalt. [Google Scholar], Die Wandlung. [10] Grew Grew, R. 1980. The Case for Comparing Histories. American Historical Review, 85: 763–78. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], ‘The Case for Comparing Histories’, 763–78. [11] Merson Merson, A. 1985. Communist Resistance in Nazi Germany, London: Lawrence & Wishart. [Google Scholar], Communist Resistance. [12] Berger Berger, S. 1994. The British Labour Party and German Social Democrats, 1900–31, Oxford: Clarendon Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The British Labour Party, 7. [13] Berger Berger, S. 1994. The British Labour Party and German Social Democrats, 1900–31, Oxford: Clarendon Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The British Labour Party, 7 248–55. [14] Wrigley Wrigley, C. 1993. “The State and the Challenge of Labour in Britain, 1917–20”. In Challenges of Labour: Central and Western Europe, 1917–20, Edited by: Wrigley, C. London: Routledge. [Google Scholar], ‘The State and the Challenge of Labour’, 62–89. [15] Wheeler Wheeler, R. 1976. Die USPD und Die Internationale: Sozialistischer Internationalismus in der Zeit der Revolution, Frankfurt: Ullstein. [Google Scholar], Die USPD; McKibben McKibben, D. 1992. Who were the German Independent Socialists? The Leipzig City Council Elections of 6 December 1917. Central European History, 25(4): 425–43. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], ‘Who were the German Independent Socialists?’, 425–43. [16] Macintyre Macintyre, S. 1980. A Proletarian Science: Marxism in Britain, 1917–33, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar], A Proletarian Science; McKibbin McKibbin, R. 1984. Why was there no Marxism in Britain?. English Historical Review, 99: 297–331. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], ‘Why was there no Marxism in Britain?’, 297–331; Callaghan Callaghan, J. 1990. Socialism in Britain since 1884, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Socialism in Britain. [17] Crick Crick, M. 1994. The History of the Social Democratic Federation, Keele: Keele University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The History of the Social Democratic Federation. [18] CPGB, Communist Unity Convention. [19] CPGB, Communist Unity Convention Kendall Kendall, W. 1969. The Revolutionary Movement in Britain, 1900–21: The Origins of British Communism, London: Weidenfield & Nicolson. [Google Scholar], The Revolutionary Movement. [20] These included Sylvia Pankhurst's fledgling Communist Party (British Section of the Third International). See Thorpe Thorpe, A. 2000. The British Communist Party and Moscow, 1920–43, Manchester: Manchester University Press. [Google Scholar], The British Communist Party. [21] Worley Worley, M. 2005. Labour Inside the Gate: A History of the British Labour Party between the Wars, London: I.B. Tauris. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Labour Inside the Gate, Chapter 1. [22] Thorpe, The British Communist Party, 284. [23] Koch-Baumgarten Koch-Baumgarten, S. 1986. “Einleitung”. In Die KPD in der Weimarer Repbublik, 3rd ed., Edited by: Flechtheim, O. K. Hamburg: Junius. [Google Scholar], ‘Einleitung’, 23. [24] Weber Weber, H. 1969. Der Gründungsparteitag der KPD: Protokolle und Materialien, Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanst. [Google Scholar], Der Gründungsparteitag, 310–45. [25] Winkler Winkler, H. A. 1984. Von der Revolution zur Stabilisierung: Arbeiter und Arbeiter bewegung in der Weimarer Republik 1918 bis 1924, Berlin: J.H.W. Dietz Nachf. [Google Scholar], Von der Revolution zur Stabilisierung, 500–504; Weber, Der Gründungsparteitag, 310ff. [26] Peukert Peukert, D. 1991. The Weimar Republic: The Crisis of Classical Modernity, London: Allen Lane. [Google Scholar], The Weimar Republic, 49–51. For the development on the political right, see Jones Jones, L. E. 1988. German Liberalism and the Dissolution of the Weiamr System, 1918–33, Chapel Hill. [Google Scholar], German Liberalism. [27] Mallmann Mallmann, K-L. 1995. Milieu, Radikalismus und lokale Gesellschaft. Zur Sozialgeschichte des Kommunismus in der Weimarer Republik. Geschichte und Gesellschaft, 21(1): 5–31. [Google Scholar], ‘Milieu, Radikalismus und lokale Gesellschaft’, 5–31. [28] Eley Eley, G. 2002. Forging Democracy: The History of the Left in Europe, 1850–2000, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Forging Democracy, 160–69; Oertzen Oertzen, P. von. 1999. “Exkurs 1”. In Der deutsche Kommunismus. Selbstverständnis und Realität, Edited by: Kinner, K. Berlin: Dietz. [Google Scholar], ‘Exkurs 1’, 27–32. [29] Wirsching, Vom Weltkrieg zum Bürgerkreig, 109–11. [30] Wheeler, Die USPD, 246–58. [31] Weitz, Creating German Communism. [32] Williams Williams, C. 1996. Democratic Rhondda: Politics and Society, 1885–1951, Cardiff: University of Wales Press. [Google Scholar], Democratic Rhondda; Beynon and Austrin Beynon, H. and Austrin, T. 1994. Masters and Servants: Class and Patronage in the Making of a Labour Organisation, London: Rivers Oram. [Google Scholar], Masters and Servants; Macintyre Macintyre, S. 1980. Little Moscows: Communism and Working Class Militancy in Inter War Britain, London: Lawrence & Wishart. [Google Scholar], Little Moscows. [33] McKibbin McKibbin, R. 1974. The Evolution of the Labour Party, 1910–24, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], The Evolution of the Labour Party. [34] Weber, Die Wandlung, 361–8; Wheeler Wheeler, R. 1982. “Zur Sozialenstruktur der Arbeiterbewegung am Anfang der Weimarer Republik”. In Industrielles System und politische Entwicklung in der Weimarer Republik, Edited by: Mommsen, H. Düsseldorf: Drost. [Google Scholar], ‘Zur Sozialenstruktur’, 179–89. [35] Thorpe Thorpe, A. 2000. The Membership of the Communist Party of Great Britain, 1920–45. The Historical Journal, 43(3): 777–800. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], ‘The Membership’, 777–800. [36] Labour Party 1939. Report of the Thirty-Eighth Annual Conference of the Labour Party, 1939 London [Google Scholar], Report of the Thirty-Eighth Annual Conference, 92. [37] Worley, Class Against Class, 277–80. [38] Weber, Die Wandlung, 286. [39] Morgan, Cohen and Flinn, Communists. [40] ‘Party Census’, January 1927. All CPGB primary sources are based in the Communist Archive, Manchester, unless stated. [41] Thorpe, ‘The Membership’, 790. [42] Weitz, Creating German Communism, 246–9; Falter Falter, J. 1991. Hitler's Wähler, Munich: Beck. [Google Scholar], Hitler's Wähler. [43] Kaas, ‘Die Sozialstruktur der KPD’, 1050–67; Fowkes Fowkes, B. 1984. Communism in Germany under the Weimar Republic, Basingstoke: Macmillan. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Communism, 172–83. [44] Meeting of the Political Secretariat of the ECCI, 11 July 1929. [45] Weber, Die Wandlung, 26–36; Biehl Biehl, K. H. Der Thälmann-Putsch in Hamburg und Umgebung. Norderstadt, 2000. [Google Scholar], Der Thälmann-Putsch. [46] Weitz Weitz, E. D. 1990. State Power, Class fragmentation and the Shaping of German Communist Politics. Journal of Modern History, 62: 253–97. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], ‘State Power, 290–1; Fowkes, Communism, 173. [47] Minutes of the Central Committee (CC), 18–20 September 1932; Thorpe, ‘The Membership’, 792–3. [48] Worley, Class Against Class, 37–44, 175–181 and 281–6; Croucher Croucher, R. 1987. We Refuse to Starve in Silence: A History of the National Unemployed Workers' Movement, 1920–46, London: Lawrence & Wishart. [Google Scholar], We Refuse to Starve. [49] Weitz, Creating German Communism, 160–87; Worley, Class Against Class, 37–44. [50] Heer-Kleinert Heer-Kleinert, L. 1983. Die Gewerkschaftspolitik der KPD in der Weimarer Republik, Frankfurt: Campus. [Google Scholar], Die Gewerkschaftspolitik, 282ff, 360 and 375ff; Wickham Wickham, J. 1979. Social Fascism and the Division of the Working Class Movement. Capital and Class, 7: 1–34. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘Social Fascism’, 1–34. For Pollitt, see Labour Monthly, August 1929; ‘Statement of the Impressions of Comrade Hardy regarding the Situation in the CPGB’, 25 November 1930, Russian State Archive of Socio-Political History (RGASPI) 495/100/68. Thanks to Kevin Morgan for providing this reference. CPGB, The Revolutionary Way Out. [51] Thorpe ThorpeA.‘Gender and Party Membership: A Comparison of the Labour and Communist Parties.’ unpublished paper, 2001. [Google Scholar], ‘Gender and Party Membership’. [52] Minutes of the St. Pancras Women's Committee, 7 September 1927. Pollard–Johnson Papers, Bodleian Library. [53] In addition to Rosa Luxemburg in 1918–19, Ruth Fischer was elected as party chairman in 1924 and again in 1925. [54] Mallmann Mallmann, K-L. 1996. Kommunisten in der Weimarer Republik: Sozialgeschichte einer Revolutionären Bewegung, Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. [Google Scholar], Kommunisten, 131–2; Weitz, Creating German Communism, 188. [55] Geary Geary, D. 1981. Labour Protest in Europe, 1848–1939, Basingstoke: Macmillan. [Google Scholar], Labour Protest; Geary Geary, D. 1991. European Labour Politics from 1900 to the Depression, Basingstoke: Macmillan. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], European Labour Politics. [56] Berger, The British Labour Party, 248–52. [57] Berger Berger, S. 2005. “The Formation of Party Milieux: Branch Life in the British Labour Party and the German Social Democratic Party in the Interwar Period”. In Labour's Grass Roots: Essay on the Activities of Local Labour Parties and Members, 1918–45, Edited by: Worley, M. Aldershot: Ashgate. [Google Scholar], ‘The Formation of Party Milieux’, 254. [58] Berger Berger, S. 2005. “The Formation of Party Milieux: Branch Life in the British Labour Party and the German Social Democratic Party in the Interwar Period”. In Labour's Grass Roots: Essay on the Activities of Local Labour Parties and Members, 1918–45, Edited by: Worley, M. Aldershot: Ashgate. [Google Scholar], ‘The Formation of Party Milieux’, 254, 251. [59] See Ramsay MacDonald's speech to conference, in Labour Party Labour Party. 1922. Report of the Twenty-Second Annual Conference of the Labour Party, 1922 London [Google Scholar], Report of the Twenty-Second Annual Conference, 199. [60] Heer-Kleinert, Die Gewerkschaftspolitik der KPD, 230ff. [61] Meeting of the Anglo-American Secretariat (AAS), 3 December 1931; Meeting of the CC, 19–21 July 1930. Also, Report of the Students Group, South Wales District June 1930. Working Class Movement Library, Salford. [62] David Proudfoot, in MacDougall MacDougall, I., ed. 1981. Militant Miners: Recollections of John McArthur, Buckhaven; and Letters, 1924–26, of David Proudfoot, Methil, to G. Allen Hutt, Edinburgh: Polygon Books. [Google Scholar], ed., Militant Miners, 141. [63] Weitz, Creating German Communism, 231; Hunt and Worley Hunt, H. and Worley, M. 2004. Rethinking British Communist Party Women in the 1920s. Twentieth Century British History, 15(1): 1–27. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘Rethinking British Communist Party Women’, 1–27. [64] For Weber Weber, H. 1983. Kommunismus in Deutschland, 1918–45, Bonn: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. [Google Scholar]'s ‘Stalinization’ thesis, see Wandlung des deutschen Kommunismus, 8–16. Aviva Aviva, A. 1978. The SPD and the KPD at the End of the Weimar Republic: Similarity within Contrast. Internationale Wissenschaftliche Korrespondenz zur Geschichte der Arbeiterbewegung, 14(2): 171–86. [Google Scholar], ‘The SPD and the KPD’, 171–86; Röpenack Röpenack, A. von. 2002. NSDAP und KPD im Propagandakampf der Weimarer Republik, Stuttgart: Ibidem Verlag. [Google Scholar], NSDAP und KPD, 20–23 and 100–104; Weber Weber, H. 1982. Hauptfeind Sozialdemokratie: Strategie und Taktik der KPD 1929–33 Düsseldorf [Google Scholar], Hauptfeind Sozialdemokratie; Kinner Kinner, K. 1999. Der Deutsche Kommunismus: Selbstverständniss und Realität, Berlin: Dietz. [Google Scholar], Der Deutsche Kommunismus, 97–110; Weitz, Creating German Communism, 234–43; Watlin Watlin, A. 1993. Die Komintern, 1919–29, Mainz: Historische Studien. [Google Scholar], Die Komintern; McDermott McDermott, K. 1995. Stalin and the Comintern during the “Third Period”, 1928–33. European History Quarterly, 25: 409–29. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], ‘Stalin and the Comintern’, 409–29; McDermott McDermott, K. 1998. “The History of the Comintern in the Light of New Documentation”. In International Communism and the Communist International, 1919–43, Edited by: Rees, T. and Thorpe, A. Manchester: Manchester University Press. [Google Scholar], ‘The History of the Comintern’, 31–40. [65] Rudloff Rudloff, M. 1994. Politische “Sauberungen” in der KPD der Weimarer Republik’. Leipziger Heft, 2: 4–23. [Google Scholar], ‘Politische “Sauberungen” in der KPD’, 4–23; Bahne Bahne, S. 1961. Zwischen “Luxemburgismus” und “Stalinismus. Vierteljahrsheft für Zeitgeschichte, 9(4): 359–83. [Google Scholar], ‘Zwischen “Luxemburgismus” und “Stalinismus”, 359–83. [66] Thorpe, Thorpe, The British Communist Party. For a classic example, see Meeting of the ECCI Presidium, 22 November 1927. For debate, see Meeting of the AAS, 19 November 1927; Meeting of the ECCI Political Secretariat, 11 July 1929; PB Minutes, 23 January 1931. [67] Letter to the PB of the CPGB, 30 October 1928; PB Minutes, 18 November 1928; Meeting of the ECCI Political Secretariat, 10 December 1928; PB Minutes, 27 March, 3 April, 5 May, 3 July and 17 July 1930; Meeting of the AAS, 11 August 1930. [68] Macfarlane Macfarlane, L. J. 1966. The British Communist Party: Its Origins and Development until 1929, London: MacGibbon & Kee. [Google Scholar], The British Communist Party, 204–10; Callaghan Callaghan, J. 1993. Rajani Palme Dutt: A Study in British Stalinism, London: Lawrence and Wishart. [Google Scholar], Rajani Palme Dutt, 121–5. [69] Retzlaw Retzlaw, K. 1972. Spartakus: Aufsteig und Niedergang: Erinnerungen eines Parteiarbeiter, Frankfurt: Campus. [Google Scholar], Spartakus, 294. The extent to which rank-and-file communists also maintained party discipline is the subject of debate, see Wirsching Wirsching, A. 1997. “Stalinisierung” oder Entideologisierte “Nichengesellschaft”. Vierteljahrsheft für Zeitgeschichte, 45: 449–66. [Google Scholar], ‘“Stalinisierung” oder Entideologisierte “Nichengesellschaft”’, 449–66; Mallmann Mallmann, K-L. 1999. Gehorsame Parteisoldaten oder Eigenzinnige Akteure. Vierteljahrsheft für Zeitgeschichte, 47: 401–15. [Google Scholar], ‘Gehorsame Parteisoldaten oder Eigenzinnige Akteure’, 401–15. Mallmann, Kommunisten, 77–81. [70] A similar point is made by Greame Gill in relation to the USSR. See Gill Gill, G. 1990. The Origins of the Stalinist Political System, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The Origins of the Stalinist Political System. [71] Campbell Campbell, A. 2001. “Miner Heroes: Three Communist Trade Union Leaders”. In Party People, Communist Lives: Explorations in Biography, Edited by: McIlroy, J., Morgan, K. and Campbell, A. London: Pluto Press. [Google Scholar], ‘Miner Heroes’, 143–68. [72] Cohen and Flinn, ‘In Search of the Typical British Communist’, 37–54. [73] Benson Benson, E. 1970–80. To Struggle is to Live: A Working Class Autobiography, Vols 1 and 2, Newcastle: People's Publications. [Google Scholar], To Struggle; Barker and Straker Barker, B. and Straker, L. 1989. Free But Not Easy, Matlock: Derbyshire County Council. [Google Scholar], Free But Not Easy; Docherty Docherty, M. 1992. A Miner's Lass, Preston: Lancashire Community Press. [Google Scholar], A Miner's Lass; Cohen and Flinn, ‘In Search of the Typical British Communist’, 37–54. [74] Mallmann, Kommunisten. [75] Weitz, Creating German Communism, Chapter 7. [76] Weitz, Creating German Communism; Rosenhaft Rosenhaft, E. 1983. Beating the Fascists? The German Communists and Political Violence, 1929–33, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Beating the Fascists?; Mallmann, Kommunisten; Worley, Class Against Class 37–44. [77] Weitz, Creating German Communism, 196. [78] Weitz Weitz, E. D. 2003. “Communism and the Public Spheres in Germany”. In Between Reform and Revolution: German Socialism and Communism from 1840 to 1990, Edited by: Weitz, E. D. and Barclay, E. New York: Berghahn Books. [Google Scholar], ‘Communism and the Public Spheres’, 275– 91. [79] Thurlow Thurlow, R. 1994. The Secret State: British Internal Security in the Twentieth Century, Oxford: Blackwells. [Google Scholar], The Secret State. [80] Worley, Class Against Class, Chapter 1. [81] Clegg Clegg, H. A. 1985. History of British Trade Unions since 1889. Vol. 2, 1911–33, Oxford: Clarendon Press. [Google Scholar], History of British Trade Unions; Martin Martin, R. 1969. Communism and the British Trade Unions, 1924–1933: A Study of the National Minority Movement, Oxford: Clarendon Press. [Google Scholar], Communism, 93–101; Macfarlane, The British Communist Party, 243–6. [82] Inprecorr, 4 November 1926 and 3 December 1926; Worley Worley, M. 2004. “Courting Disaster? The Comintern and the Third Period”. In In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period, Edited by: Worley, M. London: I.B. Tauris. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], ‘Courting Disaster?’, 1–17. [83] ECCI 1929. The World Situation and the Economic Struggle: These of the Tenth Plenum ECCI, London: Dorrit Press. [Google Scholar], The World Situation, 4–12. [84] Martin, Communism. [85] Campbell Campbell, A. 2000. The Scottish Miners, 1874–1939. Vol. 2, Trade Unions and Politics, Aldershot: Ashgate. [Google Scholar], The Scottish Miners; Lerner Lerner, S. W. 1961. Breakaway Unions and the Small Trade Union, London: George Allen & Unwin. [Google Scholar], Breakaway Unions. [86] PB Minutes, 17 September 1932; Daily Worker, 20 August 1932; Communist Review, September 1932. [87] Müller Müller, W. 1988. Lohnkampf, Massenstreik, Sowjetmacht: Ziele und Grenzen der RGO in Deutschland, Cologne: Bund. [Google Scholar], Lohnkampf, 72ff, 84, 94, 122ff and 199. [88] Politburo Meeting, 26 August 1926, Stiftung Archiv der Parteien und Massenorganisationen der DDR im Bundesarchiv (henceforth: SAPMO), RY I 2/3/6, Bl. 310–13. [89] Wirsching, Vom Weltkrieg zum Bürgerkrieg, 400–410; Weitz, Creating German Communism, 160–87. [90] Ehls Ehls, M-L. 1997. Protest und Propaganda: Demonstrationen in Berlin zur Zeit der Weimarer Republik, Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Protest und Propaganda, 229. [91] Meeting of the AAS, 30–31 July 1930; CC Minutes, 30–31 May 1931; Inprecorr, 4 and 17 August 1931. [92] Worley, Class Against Class, 175–81. [93] Davies Davies, S. 1992. The Membership of the National Unemployed Workers’ Movement. Labour History Review, 57(1): 29–35. [Google Scholar], ‘The Membership’. [94] Ehls, Protest and Propaganda, 113–18 and 227–82; Schüren Schüren, U. 1978. Der Volksentscheid zur Fürstenenteignung 1926. Die Vermögensauseinandersetzung mit den depossedierten Landesherren als Problem der deutschen Innenpolitik unter besonderen Berücksichtigung der Verhältnisse in Preussen, Düsseldorf: Droste. [Google Scholar], Der Volksentscheid zur Fürstenenteignung 1926. [95] Inprekorr, 19 April and 10 May 1927, 1024. Clashes with the Stahlhelm was a frequent topic of discussion at Politburo meetings. See, 21 April 1927, in SAPMO, RY 1/2/3/7. For a discussion of the militarization of political life, see Longerich Longerich, P. 1989. Die Braunen Bataillone: Geschichte der SA, Munich: Beck. [Google Scholar], Die Braunen Bataillone. [96] Rosenhaft, Beating the Fascists?; Weitz, Creating German Communism, 160–87; LaPorte, The German Communist Party, 319–29. [97] Anderson Anderson, G. D. 1983. Fascists, Communists and the National Government: Civil Liberties in Great Britain, 1931–37, Columbia: University of Missouri Press. [Google Scholar], Fascists. 147–9. [98] Ministry of Labour Gazette, Vols 37–40 (1929–32). [99] Williamson Williamson, P. 1992. National Crisis and National Government: British Politics, the Economy and Empire, 1926–32, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar], National Crisis. [100] Evans and Geary Evans, R. and Geary, D., eds. 1987. The German Unemployed: Experiences and Consequences of Mass Unemployment from the Weimar Republic to the Third Reich, London: Routledge. [Google Scholar], eds, The German Unemployed; Stachura Stachura, P. D., ed. 1986. Unemployment and the Great Depression in Weimar Germany, Basingstoke: Macmillan. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Unemployment. [101] Kolb Kolb, E. 1988. The Weimar Republic, London: Routledge. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], The Weimar Republic, 179ff. [102] Inprecorr, 17 July 1924. [103] Inprecorr, 25 September 1929. The comment was made by Manuilsky on behalf of the ECCI, in relation to the Stalin-inspired purge of the ‘right danger’ throughout the Comintern. [104] Wicks Wicks, H. 1992. Keeping My Head: Memoirs of a British Bolshevik London Socialist Platform [Google Scholar], Keeping My Head, 75; McCarthy McCarthy, M. 1953. Generation in Revolt, London: Heinemann. [Google Scholar], Generation, 139–49. [105] Daily Worker, 10 May 1930; Samuel, MacColl and Cosgrave Samuel, R., MacColl, E. and Cosgrove, S., eds. 1984. Theatres of the Left, 1880–1935: Workers' Theatre Movements in Britain and America, London: Routledge. [Google Scholar], eds, Theatres of the Left. [106] For several examples, see Morgan Morgan, K. 2006. Labour Legends and Russian Gold, London: Lawrence & Wishart. [Google Scholar], Labour, Chapter 6. [107] Worley, Class Against Class, Chapters 7 and 8. [108] Bayerlein Bayerlein, B. 2003. “Vom “Fall” zur “Parabel” des Stalinismus”. In Der Thälmann Skandal: Geheime Korrespondenzen mit Stalin, Edited by: Weber, H. and Eberlein, B. Berlin: Aufbau Verlag. [Google Scholar], ‘Vom “Fall” zur “Parabel” des Stalinismus’, 35–71. [109] Rosenhaft, Beating the Fascists?; 10–11; Weitz, Creating German Communism, 160–87. Additional informationNotes on contributorsMatthew WorleyNorman LaPorte is Fellow in History at the University of Glamorgan; Matthew Worley is Lecturer in History at the University of Reading.