Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Beyond and Below the Polis: Networks, Associations, and the Writing of Greek History

2007; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 22; Issue: 1 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/09518960701538507

1743-940X

Kōstas Vlassopoulos,

Classical Antiquity Studies

Abstract This article looks at the ways we can use networks in the study of the history of Greece. At the level below the polis, networks take the form of associations (koinoniai) that bring together people of various statuses and backgrounds. Studying these koinoniai allows us to move beyond structuralist approaches into the study of real social interactions. When looking at the level below the polis, we have to adopt a world-system perspective, and study the networks that move people, goods and ideas/technologies, and the world centres that organize these networks. This approach allows us to move beyond Hellenocentric and Athenocentric approaches, and insert the Greek world into the wider Mediterranean and Near Eastern world-system. Keywords: Koinonia AssociationWorld-systemMeticsAristotle Notes [1] For the role of these polarities in Greek historians, see Cartledge Cartledge, Paul. 2002. The Greeks. A Portrait of Self and Others, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], The Greeks. [2] See the critical attitudes to structuralism in Hunter, Policing Athens; Loraux Loraux, Nicole. 1995. The Experiences of Tiresias: The Feminine and the Greek Man, Princeton: Princeton University Press. Translated by Paula Wissing [Google Scholar], Experiences of Tiresias; Cohen Cohen, Edward. 2000. The Athenian Nation, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Athenian Nation. [3] See Whitley Whitley, James. 1991. Style and Society in Dark Age Greece, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar], Style and Society, 194. [4] The concept of 'city-state culture', adopted by Hansen Hansen, Mogens H. 2000. "Introduction. The Concepts of City-state and City-state Culture". In A Comparative Study of Thirty City-state Cultures, Edited by: Hansen, M. H. Copenhagen: Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab. [Google Scholar] in the more recent publications of the Copenhagen Polis Centre, is though a positive step forward; see Hansen, 'Introduction'. [5] Among recent protests for such attitudes, see Dougherty and Kurke Dougherty, Carol and Kurke, Leslie, eds. 2003. The Cultures within Ancient Greek Culture: Contact, Conflict, Collaboration, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar], Cultures within Greek Culture. [6] For a similar plea, see Malkin Malkin, Irad. 2003. Networks and the Emergence of Greek Identity. Mediterranean Historical Review, 18: 56–74. [Taylor & Francis Online] , [Google Scholar], 'Networks'. [7] See Sakellariou Sakellariou, Michaïl B. 1989. The Polis-State: Definition and Origin, Athens: De Boccard. [Google Scholar], Polis-State, 214–82. [8] Nicomachean Ethics 1160a.4–6. [9] For exceptions, see Murray Murray, Oswyn. 1993. "Polis and Politeia in Aristotle". In The Ancient Greek City-state, Edited by: Hansen, M. H. Copenhagen: Munksgaard. [Google Scholar], 'Polis and Politeia'; Ober Ober, Josiah. 1993. "The Polis as a Society: Aristotle, John Rawls, and the Athenian Social Contract". In The Ancient Greek City-state, Edited by: Hansen, M. H. Copenhagen: Munksgaard. [Google Scholar], 'Polis as Society'. [10] Aristotle's great discovery was indeed diversity and multiplicity, where other Greek thinkers were trying to see the underlying unity behind the apparent diversity; at the same time he used the concept of hierarchy to subordinate diversity to his normative ideas; see Saxonhouse Saxonhouse, Arlene. 1992. Fear of Diversity. The Birth of Political Science in Ancient Greek Thought, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [Google Scholar], Fear of Diversity, 189–95. We can keep his explorations of diversity, without therefore accepting his concept of hierarchy. [11] See for example Hall Hall, Edith. 1989. Inventing the Barbarian: Greek Self-definition through Tragedy, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Inventing the Barbarian; Hartog Hartog, François. 1988. The Mirror of Herodotus: The Representation of the Other in the Writing of History, Berkeley: University of California Press. Translated by Janet Lloyd [Google Scholar], The Mirror of Herodotus. Cartledge, The Greeks, 51–77, offers a well-articulated presentation of such arguments. [12] For the fundamental importance of actual experience for any historical account and supposition, see the classic Thompson Thompson, Edward Palmer. 1978. The Poverty of Theory: Or an Orrery of Errors, London: Merlin Press. [Google Scholar], Poverty of Theory. [13] IG, II2, 141.2.30–6. [14] See the interpretation of Culasso Gastaldi Culasso Gastaldi, Enrica. 2004. Le prossenie ateniesi del IV secolo a.C. Alessandria [Google Scholar], Le prossenie ateniesi, 113–14. [15] Oeconomicus 8.11–6. [16] Hypereides, Against Athenogenes. [17] For the law mentioned by Hypereides, see Adak Adak, Mustafa. 2003. Metöken als Wohltäter Athens: Untersuchungen zum sozialen Austausch zwischen ortsansässigen Fremden und der Burgergemeinde in klassischer und hellenistischer Zeit (ca. 500–150 v. Chr.), Munich: Tuduv. [Google Scholar], Metöken als Wohltäter Athens, 67–72, whose interpretation I accept. [18] See Whitehead Whitehead, David. 2000. Hypereides: The Forensic Speeches, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Hypereides, 287–88, 339–41. [19] Our colleagues studying the Bronze Age Aegean have been more open-minded in this respect: see Knapp Knapp, Bernard A. 1993. Thalassocracies in Bronze Age Eastern Mediterranean Trade: Making and Breaking a Myth. World Archaeology, 24: 332–47. [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], 'Thalassocracies'; Cline Cline, Eric H. 1995. "Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Sailor: Minoans and Mycenaeans Abroad". In Politeia: Society and State in the Aegean Bronze Age, Edited by: Laffineur, R. and Niemeier, W. D. Liege and Austin, TX: Program in Aegean Scripts and Prehistory. [Google Scholar], 'Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Sailor'. [20] IG, I3 1361. Of course, predictably the interest of the few ancient historians who have dealt with this inscription has focused on dating, topography, and the language and oral features of the epigram. No wonder the political and social implications of this document have never been seriously addressed. But see now the commentary in Bäbler Bäbler, Balbina. 1998. Fleißige Thrakerinnen und wehrhafte Skythen: Nichtgriechen im klassischen Athen und ihre archäologische Hinterlassenschaft, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Fleissige Thrakerinnen, 159–63. [21] Adak, Metöken als Wohltäter Athens, 67–72. [22] For the following, see Hagemajer Hagemajer, Allen, K. 2003. "Becoming the "Other": Attitudes and Practices at the Attic Cemeteries". In The Cultures within Ancient Greek Culture: Contact, Conflict, Collaboration, Edited by: Dougherty, C. and Kurke, L. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar] Allen, 'Becoming the Other' [23] Cassola Cassola, Filippo. 1996. "Chi erano i Greci?". In I Greci. Storia, cultura, arte, societa. Vol. II: Una storia greca. I. Formazione, Edited by: Settis, S. Turin: Einaudi. [Google Scholar], 'Chi erano i Greci', 10. [24] Cf. Shipley Shipley, Graham. 1993. "Distance, Development, Decline? World-systems Analysis and the "Hellenistic" Word'.". In Centre and Periphery in the Hellenistic World, Edited by: Bilde, P., Engberg-Pedersen, T., Hannestad, L., Zahle, J. and Randsborg, K. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press. [Google Scholar], 'Distance, Development, Decline'. [25] Abu-Lughod Abu-Lughod, Janet L. 1989. Before European Hegemony. The World-system AD 1250–1350, New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Before European Hegemony. [26] An example of this attitude can be seen in Finley Finley, Moses I. 1985. The Ancient Economy, Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. [Google Scholar], Ancient Economy, 177–78. [27] Herodotus 3.125–38. [28] Wallerstein Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1974. The Modern World-system. I: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World Economy in the Sixteenth Century, New York: Academic Press. [Google Scholar], Modern World-system, 15. [29] Wallerstein Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1991. Unthinking Social Science: The Limits of Nineteenth-century Paradigms, Oxford: Blackwell. [Google Scholar], Unthinking Social Science. [30] See Vlassopoulos Vlassopoulos, Kostas. 2007. Between East and West: The Greek Poleis as Part of a World-System. Ancient West and East, 6: 91–111. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], 'Between East and West'. [31] See Charpin and Joannès Charpin, D. and Joannès, F., eds. 1992. La circulation des biens, des personnes et des idées dans le proche orient ancien: actes de la XXXVIIIe rencontre Assyriologique internationale, Paris: Editions Recherche sur les Civilisations. [Google Scholar], La circulation des biens, for a similar perspective on the Near East. [32] On their emergence, see Morgan Morgan, Catherine. 1990. Athletes and Oracles: The Transformation of Olympia and Delphi in the Eighth Century BC, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar], Athletes and Oracles; see also Rougemont Rougemont, Georges. 1992. "Delphes et les cités grecques d'Italie du sud et de Sicile". In La Magna Grecia e i grandi santuari della madrepatria: atti del trentunesimo Convegno di studi sulla Magna Grecia, Taranto: Istituto per la storia e l'archeologia della Magna Grecia. [Google Scholar], 'Delphes et les cités grecques'; Sanchez Sanchez, Pierre. 2001. L'Amphictionie des Pyles et de Delphes: recherches sur son rôle historique, des origines au IIe siècle de notre ère, Stuttgart: Franz Steiner. [Google Scholar], L'Amphictionie des Pyles. [33] Bresson and Rouillard Bresson, Alain and Rouillard, Pierre, eds. 1993. L'Emporion, Paris: Publications du Centre Pierre Paris. [Google Scholar], L'emporion. [34] Dunbabin Dunbabin, Thomas J. 1948. The Western Greeks, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Western Greeks, 298–99. [35] Hornblower Hornblower, Simon. 1982. Mausolus, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], Mausolus. [36] Ostwald and Lynch Ostwald, M. and Lynch, J. P. 1994. "The Growth of Schools and the Advance of Knowledge". In Cambridge Ancient History, VI: The Fourth Century BC, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], 'Growth of Schools'. [37] Sherwin-White Sherwin-White, Susan M. 1978. Ancient Cos. An Historical Study from the Dorian Settlement to the Imperial Period, Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], Ancient Cos, 256–89. [38] Gabrielsen Gabrielsen, Vincent. 1997. The Naval Aristocracy of Hellenistic Rhodes, Aarhus: Aarhus University Press. [Google Scholar], Naval Aristocracy. [39] See the articles in Nicolet Nicolet, Claude, ed. 2000. Mégapoles méditerranéennes. Géographie urbaine retrospective, Paris: Maisonneuve. [Google Scholar], Mégapoles méditerranéennes. [40] Gilpin Gilpin, Robert. 1981. War and Change in World Politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar], War and Change, 39–40; in my essay I have changed his terms to make them more comprehensible. [41] See the case of Lokrians and Phokians in the 390s and the eruption of the Corinthian War; Hellenica Oxyrhynchia 13.3–4. [42] A classic treatment is Mossé Mossé, Claude. 1962. La fin de la démocratie athénienne: Aspects sociaux et politiques du déclin de la cité grecque au IVe siècle avant J.C, Paris: Presses Universitaires Francais. [Google Scholar], La fin. See the critique of Davies Davies, John K. 1995. "The Fourth Century Crisis: What Crisis?". In Die athenische Demokratie im 4. Jahrhundert v. Chr. Vollendung oder Verfall einer Verfassungsform?, Edited by: Eder, W. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner. [Google Scholar], 'The Fourth Century Crisis'. [43] See Gauthier Gauthier, Phillipe. 1987/89. Grandes et petites cités: hégémonie et autarcie. Opus, : 187–202. [Google Scholar], 'Grandes et petites cités'.