The limits of the Russian–Iranian strategic alliance: its history and geopolitics, and the nuclear issue
2008; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 20; Issue: 1 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1080/10163270802006321
ISSN1941-4641
Autores Tópico(s)Nuclear Issues and Defense
ResumoAbstract The Russian and Iranian governments define their relations as “very close” and “strategic” in many areas. The frontiers of this cooperation, in geopolitical terms, include the south Caucasus, central Asia, Afghanistan, and the oil- and natural gas-rich Caspian basin, while, at the issue level, the cooperation includes the nuclear issue, disarmament, the struggle against terrorism, the Iraqi quagmire, the Palestinian problem, and the U.S. military expansion into Eurasia. The signs of cooperation in these areas are, among others, regular political dialogue and similar attitudes in refusing to include the Lebanese Hizballah on terrorist lists, pursuing political relations with Hamas, maintaining a pro-Arab position on the Arab–Israeli question, objecting to foreign military engagement in Eurasia, and having a common voice during the Israeli–Lebanese conflict in 2006. However, we need to discover the nature of these relations in order to decide whether the close Russian–Iranian relations can be described as a strategic alliance. What is the strategic depth of Russian–Iranian relations? Do the relations consist merely of the conjectural necessities of the post-Cold War period? What are the “red lines” in Russian–Iranian relations? This article analyzes the relations between these two countries from a broader perspective, to examine the meaning of the relations in bilateral, regional and international contexts. Notes 1. Fatih Ozbay, “Russian–Iranian Relations from the Past to Today in the Axis of Realpolitik, Pragmatism and the Nuclear Program” (in Turkish), in Iran in the Chessboard: Nuclear Program (in Turkish), ed. Kenan Dagci and Atilla Sandikli (Istanbul: TASAM, 2007), 151–218. 2. P.P. Busev, Diplomatic History of the Relations Between the Russian and Iranian States, 1586–1612 (Moscow, 1976). 3. See L.M. Kulagina, British Expansion to Iran in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries (in Russian) (Moscow, 1981). 4. L.I. Miroshnikov, British Expansion in Iran (1914–20) (in Russian) (Moscow, 1981), 11–13. 5. A.Y. Umnov, Iran: Views for Moscow (in Russian) (Moscow, 1996), 256. 6. Mehdi Sanai, “Irano–rossiyskie svyazi: problemi i perspektivi” [Iranian–Russian Relations: Problems and Perspectives] (in Russian), Rossiya v Globalnoy Politike 5, no. 2 (2007): 118–19. 7. V.K. Egorov, Russia and Turkey: Axis of Opposites (in Russian) (Moscow, 2000), 323. 8. V.I. Sajin, Turkey Between Asia and Europe: Results of Europeanization at the End of the Twentieth Century (in Russian) (Moscow, 2001), 413. 9. Materiali 2-oi konferentsii “kurglogo stola” po rossiysko–iranskim otnoscheniyam [Minutes of the Second Round Table on Russian–Iranian Relations] (in Russian) (Moscow, 1995), 13. 10. “Do Pan-Islamism and Islamic Fundamentalism Threaten Russia?” Editorial (in Russian), Aziya i Afrika Sevodnya 2 (1996): 3–6. 11. See “Russian Federation Foreign Policy Concept 1992” (in Russian), Diplomaticheskiy Vestnik 1–2 (1993): 3–23. 12. “Kontseptsiya Vneshney Politiki RF 1992,” in Foreign Policy and Security of Contemporary Russia: Documents 1991–2002 (in Russian), ed. T.A. Shakleina (Moscow, 2002), 41. 13. Bulent Aras, “Turkey and South Caucasus,” Global Dialogue 7, nos. 3–4 (2005): 112–19. 14. Gokhan Cetinsaya, “Views on Iranian Foreign Policy from Rafsanjani to Khatami” (in Turkish), Turkey's Neighbors (in Turkish), ed. Mustafa Turkes and Ilhan Uzgel (Istanbul: Imge, 2002): 306–7. 15. Elnur Soltan, “Khatami's Russian Visit” (in Russian), Stratejik Analiz 1, no. 12 (2001): 8. 16. “Russian Federation Foreign Policy Concept 2000” (in Russian), Diplomaticheskiy Vestnik 8 (2000): 3–11. 17. Izvestia, April 22, 2000. 18. I.S. Ivanov, “Russian Foreign Policy in the Contemporary Era” (in Russian), April 20, 2001, available at http://www.mid.ru. 19. “Russian Foreign Policy Concept: Is New a Forgotten Old?” (in Russian), Voprosi Bezoposnosti 4, no. 14 (2000): 3–4. 20. Hasan Selcuk, Turkish–Russian Economic Relations (in Turkish) (Istanbul: TASAM, 2005). 21. Viktor Timcenko, Putin and the New Russia (in Russian) (Rostov: Feniks, 2005), 215. 22. V.I. Sajin, “Iranian Military Power After 20 Years, 1979–99” (in Turkish), in Islamskaya revolyutsiya v Irane: Proschloe, nastoyaschee, buduschee [Iranian Islamic Revolution: Past, Present, and Future] (Moscow, 1999). 23. Although China decided to sell a nuclear reactor to Iran in 1992, Beijing declared that it had suspended and ended nuclear cooperation with Iran in October 1997; V.A. Orlov and N.N. Sokov, Preventing Nuclear Expansion: Coursebook for Universities (in Russian), vol. 1 (Moscow: PIR-Tsentr politiceskih issledovaniy, 2002), 182. 24. B.E. Novikov, “Position and Prospects for Iranian Missile and Nuclear Technologies” (in Russian), in Iran v Sovremennom Mire (Moscow: RISI, 2003), 125. 25. “Russia is Ready to Build Two more Blocks in Iran” (in Russian), available at www.iranatom.ru/news/iri/year06/may/saidi.htm. 26. V. Kuzar, “Is Iran Next?” (in Russian), Krasnaya Zvezda, August 3, 2004; Y. Agentsvo Sinhua, December 26, 2003. 27. A. Kornisheva, “They Do Not Allow Us into the Nuclear Market Yet” (in Russian), Kommersant, March 12, 2003. 28. I.S. Ivanov, Russia and the Contemporary World: Answers to the Challenges of Twenty-First Century (in Russian) (Moscow: OLMA Press, 2004), 20. 29. Vagif Guseynov, “Iran and the US Middle East Strategy” (in Russian), Vestnik Analitiki 1, no. 15 (Moscow: ISOA, 2004), 62, available at http://www.isoa.ru. 30. Ivanov, Rossiya v sovremennom mire, 237–38. 31. Interfax, December 26, 2005, 32. “Russian Foreign Minister Urges Iran to Return to Moratorium on Nuclear Research,” Interfax, January 13, 2006. 33. Yelena Suponina and Petr Iskenderov, “Russia is Tired of Defending Iranian President Ahmeninejad” (in Russian), Vremya Novostey, January 13, 2006. 34. Yelena Suponina and Petr Iskenderov, “Russia is Tired of Defending Iranian President Ahmeninejad” (in Russian), Vremya Novostey, January 13, 2006. 35. A.A. Rozov, “Russian Offer and Iranian Public Opinion” (in Russian), available at www.iimes.ru/rus/frame_stat.html; “Davari: Iranian Conservatives Are Not Happy with Russia” (in Russian), available at http://iranatom.ru/news/iri/year06/february/davari.htm. 36. “Falyahatpische: Talks with Moscow are Meaningless” (in Russian), available at http://iranatom.ru/news/iri/year06/february/falah.htm. 37. See www.regnum.ru. 38. BBC Turkish, “İran: Mekik diplomasisi yapacağiz,” June 5, 2006, available at www.bbc.co.uk/turkish/news/story/2006/06/060605_iran_talks.shtml. 39. “Lavrov: I hope Iran Will Start Negotiations,” IRNA, June 6, 2006 (in Russian), available at www.irna.ir/tr/news/view/line-6/0606064105120855.htm. 40. “Lavrov: Under No Conditions Will There Be Use of Force Against Iran,” IRNA, June 3, 2006 (in Russian), available at www.irna.ir/tr/news/view/line-6/0606036787113057.htm. 41. “Russian–Iranian Cooperation Chronology” (in Russian), available at www.pircenter.org/data/resources/07–05-14%20Chronology%20Iran%20Master%20Copy.pdf. 42. The text of the resolution is avaliable at www.pircenter.org/data/resources/Resolution_1737.pdf. 43. The text of the report is available at www.pircenter.org/data/resources/IAEA%20-%202007-02-22%20Report.pdf. 44. For the text of the resolution, see www.pircenter.org/data/resources/07.03.24_UN_SC_Resolution_1747.pdf. 45. V.I. Sajin, “Rossiya–Iran,” 214. 46. “Kontseptsiya Vneshney Politiki RF 2000.” 47. Sanai, 121. 48. Interview with Mohammed Hafezian, Professor of Political Science, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, December 17, 2007. 49. Rozov, “Rossiyskoe predlojenie.” 50. Khronologiya Rossiysko–Iranskovo, p. 29. 51. Sajin, 215. 52. ITAR-TASS, March 27, 2007. 53. V. Kruge Sveta, Radio Eho Moskvi, January 14, 2006, available at http://echo.msk.ru/programs/sorokina/41143/index.phtml. 54. www.kremlin.ru/text/appears/2007/02/118109.shtml. 55. www.kremlin.ru/text/appears/2007/02/118109.shtml. 56. www.kremlin.ru/text/appears/2007/02/118109.shtml. 57. “Iranian Ambassador in Dushanbe: Iran Is Not Sure That Russia Will Always Protect Iranian Interests” (in Farsi), IRNA, October 4, 2005. 58. Washington Post, December 4, 2007. 59. Alex Rodriguez, “Iran Gets Nuclear Fuel from Russia,” Chicago Tribune, December 18, 2007. 60. Interview with Iranian expert on nuclear issues, Rahman Ghahremanpour Bonap, in Istanbul, December 27, 2007. 61. Tehran Times, December 20, 2007.
Referência(s)