Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

The Eco-Frontier Paradigm: Rethinking the Links between Space, Nature and Politics

2011; Taylor & Francis; Volume: 16; Issue: 3 Linguagem: Inglês

10.1080/14650045.2010.538878

1557-3028

Sylvain Guyot,

Environmental Philosophy and Ethics

Abstract There is a gap in the geographical/geopolitical literature about the process that motivates humans to conquer a boundless, timeless and invaluable wilderness in the name of plural ecologies to serve their own political interests in control and territory building by means of 'green gerrymandering'. The ecological frontier (or eco-frontier), a neologism produced by a contemporary greened civil society, can be considered a new paradigm that embraces the mental representations and spatial constructions of eco-conquest without restricting its temporal dimension to the present time. Indeed, the eco-frontier is a genealogical paradigm where new dynamics always revisit old processes. The creation and use of the eco-frontier can illuminate the history of the global territorialisation of nature in the last three centuries. From a spatial point of view, two main understandings of the eco-frontier exist. The first characterises virtual and mental imageries of natural spaces of eco-conquest that are strongly associated with Westernised representations of nature. The second considers eco-frontiers as geographical processes to understand the green dynamics of territorial appropriation and re-conquest. As a genealogical paradigm, the eco-frontier has a specific temporal dynamic that integrates the different historical contexts and political ideologies of nature. Three generations of eco-frontiers (Empire, Geopolitical and Global generations) began at different times and co-exist today, with superposition and percolation. This empirical study shows how contemporary environmentalists and green stakeholders produce specific discourses and representations on global eco-frontiers. The paper focuses on the current territorial domination carried out by contemporary eco-conquerors creating possible new geopolitics. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks to the referees for their stimulating and helpful comments. Notes 1. Definition in , accessed 8 Oct. 2010. 2. Juliet J. Fall, 'Artificial states? On the Enduring Geographical Myth of Natural Borders', Political Geography 29 (2010) 140–147; M.-C. Fourny, 'De la frontière naturelle à la nature comme lien transfrontalier. Du rôle et de la place de l'environnement et du milieu dans les coopérations transfrontalières', in C. Bouquet and H. Velasco (eds.), Tropisme des Frontières, Approche pluridisciplinaire (Paris: L'Harmattan 2005) pp. 97–117. 3. See World Resources Institute, , accessed 21 June 2010. 4. See , accessed 21 June 2010. 5. D. Bryant, D. Nielsen, and L. Tangley, The Last Frontier Forests: Ecosystems and Economies on the Edge, What Is the Status of the World's Remaining Large, Natural Forest Ecosystems? (Washington: World Resources Institute 1997). 6. Ibid., p. 6. 7. Ibid., p. 8. 8. Definition in , accessed 22 June 2010. 9. Definition, IUCN, see , accessed 22 June 2010. 10. The green gerrymandering is a process of territorial demarcation to control the nature and its planning. 11. S. Guyot, 'Fronts écologiques et éco-conquérants: définitions et typologies. L'exemple des >', Cybergeo article 471 (2009), available at ; S. Guyot and F. Richard., 'Les fronts écologiques, une clef de lecture socio-territoriale des enjeux environnementaux?', Espace Politique, introduction to the themed issue 9 (2009), available at ; S. Guyot and J. Dellier (eds.), Rethinking the Wild Coast (South Africa): Eco-Frontiers Versus Livelihoods in Pondoland (Saarbrücken: VDM Verlag 2009). 12. M. Redclift, Frontiers, Histories of Civil Society and Nature (London: MIT Press 2006) pp. viii. 13. W. Beinart and L. Hughes, Environment and Empire (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2007). 14. T. Griffiths and L. Robin, Ecology and Empire: Environmental History of Settler Societies (Pietermaritzburg: University of Natal Press 1997). 15. C. Lloyd, 'Australian and American Settler Capitalism: The Importance of a Comparison and its Curious Neglect', Australian Economic History Review 38/3 (1998) pp. 280–305. 16. D. G. Payne, Voices in the Wilderness, American Nature Writing and Environmental Politics (London: University Press of New England 1996); Y. Figueiredo, 'Aux sources du débat écologique contemporain: l'expérience américaine', Revue française d'études américaines 109 (2006) pp. 69–82. 17. Redclift (note 12) p. 4. 18. L. Buell, The Environmental Imagination: Thoreau, Nature Writing, and the Formation of American Culture (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1995). 19. Redclift (note 12) p. 41. 20. Redclift (note 12) p. 44; G. Waitt and L. Head, 'Postcards and Frontier Mythologies: Sustaining Views of the Kimberley as Timeless', Environment and Planning D 20 (2002) pp. 319–344. 21. Guyot, 'Fronts écologiques' (note 11). 22. Redclift (note 12) pp. 29–31. 23. E. Semple, 'Geographical Boundaries', Bulletin, American Geographical Society 39 (1907) pp. 385–397; 449–463. 24. S. Guyot, Zulu Shores, Green Disputes in Black and White (Saarbrücken: VDM Verlag 2008); Guyot and Dellier (note 11). 25. R. Neumann, Imposing Wilderness: Struggles over Livelihood and Nature Preservation in Africa (Berkeley: University of California Press 1998). 26. D. White, 'Hierarchy Domination Nature: Considering Bookchin's Critical Social Theory', Organization and Environment 16/1 (2003) pp. 34–64. 27. N. Castree, 'Commodifying What Nature?', Progress in Human Geography 27/3 (2003) pp. 273–297. 28. D. Nye, America as Second Creation: Technology and Narratives of New Beginnings (Cambridge: MIT Press 2003). 29. Redclift (note 12) p. 34. 30. R. Miniconi and S. Guyot, 'Conflicts and Cooperation in the Mountainous Mapuche Territory (Argentina)', Journal of Mountain Research 98/1 (2010), available at . 31. C. Ferradas, 'Environment, Security, and Terrorism in the Trinational Frontier of the Southern Cone', Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power 11 (2004) pp. 417–442. 32. T. Mels, 'Nature, Home, and Scenery: The Official Spatialities of Swedish National Parks, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 20 (2002) pp. 135–154. 33. S. Guyot, E. Salin, and D. Ramousse, 'Acteurs et territorialisations conflictuelles autour de la > de l'Alto Bermejo (Argentine-Bolivie)', Géocarrefour 82/4 (2007) pp. 255–263. 34. A. H. Westing, 'Protected Natural Areas and the Military', Environmental Conservation 19 (1992) pp. 343–348; S. Ellis., 'Of Elephants and Men: Politics and Nature Conservation in South Africa', Journal of Southern African Studies 20/1 (1994) pp. 53–69. 35. D. G. Havlick, 'Logics of Change for Military-to-Wildlife Conversions in the United States', GeoJournal 69 (2007) pp. 151–164; J. S. Davis, J. S. Hayes-Conroy, and V. M. Jones, 'Military Pollution and Natural Purity: Seeing Nature and Knowing Contamination in Vieques, Puerto Rico', Geojournal 69/3 (2007) pp. 165–179. 36. T. Kepe, 'Geopolitics of Conservation and the Making of an Environmental Discourse in a South African Countryside', paper presented at the International Conference on Eco-Frontiers, University of Limoges, France, 27–30 May 2009. 37. R. Neumann, 'Moral and Discursive Geographies in the War for Biodiversity in Africa', Political Geography 23/7 (2004) pp. 816–817. 38. D. Foreman, 'Take Back Conservation Movement', International Journal of Wilderness 12/4 (2006) pp. 4–31. 39. Ellis (note 34). 40. N. S. Paudel, P. Budhathoki, and U. R. Sharma, 'Buffer Zones: New Frontiers for Participatory Conservation?', Journal of Forest and Livelihood 6/2 (Sep. 2007) pp. 44–53; D. Correll, 'Principles of Planning and Establishment of Buffer Zones', Ecological Engineering 24/5 (30 May 2005) pp. 433–439; D. Martino, 'Buffer Zones Around Protected Areas: A Brief Literature Review', Electronic Green Journal 1/15 (2001), available at ; F. Götmark, H. Söderlundh, and M. Thorell, 'Buffer Zones For Forest Reserves: Opinions Of Land Owners and Conservation Value of Their Forest Around Nature Reserves in Southern Sweden', Biodiversity and Conservation 9/13 (2000) pp. 77–1390; K. Redford and S. Sanderson, 'Extracting Humans from Nature', Conservation Biology 14/5 (Oct. 2000) pp. 1362–1364; R. Schroeder, 'Geographies of Environmental Intervention in Africa', Progress in Human Geography 23/3 (1999) pp. 359–378; C. Shafer, 'US National Park Buffer Zones: Historical, Scientific, Social and Legal Aspects', Environmental Management 23/1 (1999) pp. 49–73; A. de Sherbinin and M. Freudenberger, 'Migration to Protected Areas and Buffer Zones: Can We Stem the Tide?', Parks 8/1 (Feb. 1998) pp. 38–53; R. P. Neumann, 'Primitive Ideas: Protected Area Buffer Zones and the Politics of Land in Africa', Development and Change 28 (1997) pp. 559–582; V. Burke and J. Gibbons, 'Terrestrial Buffer Zones and Wetland Conservation: A Case Study of Freshwater Turtles in a Carolina Bay', Conservation Biology 9/6 (Dec. 1995) pp. 1365–1369; R. H. G. Jongman and A. Y. Troumbis, 'The Wider Landscape For Nature Conservation: Ecological Corridors and Buffer Zones', MN2.7 Project Report (1995), 78 pp., submitted to the European Topic Centre for Nature Conservation in fulfillment of the 1995 Work Programme, European Centre for Nature Conservation, Tilburg; M. Wells and K. Brandon, 'The Principles and Practice of Buffer Zones and Local Participation in Biodiversity Conservation', Ambio Biodiversity: Ecology, Economics, Policy 22/2-3 (May 1993) pp. 157–162; R. Mwalyosi, 'Ecological Evaluation for Wildlife Corridors and Buffer Zones for Lake Manyara National Park, Tanzania, and its Immediate Environment, Biological Conservation Volume 57/2 (1991) pp. 171–186. 41. A.-L. Amilhat-Szary and S. Guyot, 'El turismo transfronterizo en los Andes centrales: prolegómenos sobre una geopolítica del turismo', Si Somos Americanos, Revista de Estudios Transfronterizos 9/2 (2007) pp. 58–93. 42. F. Giraut, S. Guyot, and M. Houssay-Holzschuch, 'Les aires protégées dans les recompositions territoriales africaines', L'Information Géographique 68 (Dec. 2004) pp. 340–368. 43. Amilhat-Szary and Guyot (note 41). 44. N. Castree, 'Neoliberalising Nature: Processes, Effects and Evaluations', Environment and Planning A 40 (2008) pp. 153–173. 45. Guyot, 'Fronts écologiques' (note 11); NGO "Conservation International": , accessed 23 June 2010. 46. NGO "Survival": , accessed 23 June 2010. 47. NGO "IUCN": , accessed 23 June 2010. 48. See the topic of the next BRIT Conference being held in Grenoble and Geneva in August 2011. 49. C. Chester, Conservation Across Borders: Biodiversity in an Interdependent World (Washington, Covelo, London: Island Press 2006); J. Fall, 'Planning Protected Areas Across Boundaries New Paradigms and Old Ghosts', Journal of Sustainable Forestry 17/1 (2003) pp. 81–102; J. Fall, 'Divide and Rule: Constructing Human Boundaries in 'Boundless Nature'', GeoJournal 58 (2002) pp. 243–251. 50. S. Guyot, 'Géopolitique des parcs (trans) frontaliers en Afrique Australe', Cahiers d'Outre Mer 234 (Spring 2006) pp. 215–232. 51. L. Pulido, 'Rethinking Environmental Racism: White Privilege and Urban Development in Southern California', Annals of the Association of American Geographers 90/1 (2000) pp. 12–40. 52. S. Cutter, 'Race, Class and Environmental Justice', Progress in Human Geography 19 (1995) pp. 107–118; F. Khan, 'The Roots of Environmental Racism and the Rise of Environmental Justice in the 1990s', in D. McDonald (ed.), Environmental Justice in South Africa (Athens/Cape Town: Ohio University Press/UCT Press 2002) pp. 15–48; R. Turner and D. Wu, Environmental Justice and Environmental Racism, an Annotated Bibliography and General Overview Focusing on US Literature, 1996–2002 (Berkeley: Institute of International Studies, University of California 2002); N. Ishiyama, 'Environmental Justice and American Indian Tribal Sovereignty: Case Study of a Land-Use Conflict in Skull Valley, Utah', Antipode 35/1 (2003) pp. 119–139. 53. T. W. Luke, 'Towards a Green Geopolitics: Politicising Ecology at the Worldwatch Institute', in K. Dodds and D. Atkinson, Geopolitical Traditions: A Century of Geopolitical Thought (London: Routledge 2000) pp. 353–371. 54. V. Shiva, 'The Greening of Global Reach', in G. Tuathail, S. Dalby, and P. Routledge (eds.), The Geopolitics Reader (London: Routledge 1998) pp. 231–236. 55. S. Kollin, Nature's State, Imagining Alaska as the last frontier (London: University of North Carolina Press 2001). 56. "ECO FRONTIER JN" is an environment-friendly, chromate-free functional coated steel sheet for electrical appliances, which was developed by JFE Steel in response to environmental needs. By developing an organic composite coating consisting of an original organic resin with a high barrier effect and inorganic inhibitors with a self-healing effect, JFE realised high corrosion resistance with a thin film for the first time in the world and succeeded in satisfying the mutually contradictory requirements of corrosion resistance and electrical conductivity. Because "JN" has excellent properties, including corrosion resistance, corrosion resistance after alkaline degreasing, electrical grounding, weldability, anti-fingerprint properties, and paint adhesion properties, application in the internal parts of OA/AV equipment and electrical appliances is increasing. As related products, JFE Steel has also developed and commercialised various other functional chromate-free steel sheets in the "ECO FRONTIER" series, which provide higher levels of corrosion resistance, formability, paint adhesion, lubricity, and other properties. , accessed 22 June 2010. 57. All these ten keywords, both in English and French (eco-frontiers/eco-frontier/front écologique/frontière environnementale, conservation frontier, eco-settlers, eco-conquerors/éco-conquérants and eco-warriors/éco-guerriers), have been searched in Google over the last ten years. We have selected the twelve most representative websites to justify our argument. 58. J. Aronson, A. F. Clewell, J. N. Blignaut, and S. J. Milton, 'Ecological Restoration: A New Frontier for Nature Conservation and Economics', Journal for Nature Conservation 4 (2006) pp. 135–139. 59. Ecocentrism, from Greek: οἶκος, oikos, "house", and κέντρον, kentron, "centre", is a term used in ecological political philosophy to denote a nature-centred, as opposed to human-centred, system of values. See R. Eckersley, Environmentalism and Political Theory: Toward an Ecocentric Approach (New York: State University of New York Press 1992). 60. "The goal of Dancing Star Foundation is to help sensitise people throughout the world to the critical importance of biodiversity and conservation; and to instil a respect for all life, which can be demonstrated by even the most modest gestures of kindness, compassion, and love in our everyday lives." , accessed 12 May 2009. 61. M. Tobias, , accessed 12 May 2009; M. Tobias, R. Gillespie, E. Hughes, and J. Gray (eds.), No Vacancy: Global Responses to the Human Population Explosion (Pasadena: Hope Publishing 2006). 62. Thoreau was deeply interested in the idea of survival in the face of hostile elements, historical change, and natural decay, at the same time imploring people to abandon waste and illusion in order to discover life's true essential needs. 63. M. Onfray, Théorie du Voyage (Paris: Essais Poche 2007). 64. Internet link to the "Beach Map", , accessed 8 Oct. 2010. 65. T. Forsyth, 'What Happened on The Beach? Social Movements and Governance of Tourism in Thailand', International Journal of Sustainable Development 5/3 (2002) pp. 326–337. 66. J. Lovelock, La Terre est un être vivant, l'hypothèse Gaïa (Paris: Flammarion, coll. > 1999). 67. , accessed 12 May 2009. 68. Guyot and Dellier (note 11). 69. The Biomass CHP CDM Project in Malaysia; source: , accessed 23 June 2010. 70. H. Collinson, Green Guerillas: Environmental Conflicts and Initiatives in Latin America and the Caribbean. (London: Latin America Bureau 1996); M. Honey, Ecotourism and Sustainable Development: Who Owns Paradise? (Washington: Island Press 1999); D. Compagnon and F. Constantin, Administrer l'environnement en Afrique (Paris and Nairobi: Karthala, IFRA 2000) ; S. Dovers, R. Edgecombe, and B. Guest, South Africa's Environmental History: Cases and Comparisons (Athens and Cape Town: Ohio University Press and David Philip Publishers 2002); G. Hilson, 'An Overview of Land Use Conflicts in Mining Communities', Land Use Policy 19 (2002) pp. 65–73; C. Fabricius, E. Koch, S. Turner, and H. Magoma, Rights, Resources and Rural Development: Community-Based Natural Resource Management in Southern Africa (Cape Town: Earthscan 2004); M. Ramutsindela, Parks and People in Postcolonial Societies: Experiences in Southern Africa (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004). 71. Guyot and Dellier (note 11). 72. Honey (note 70). 73. S. Dalby, "Green Geopolitics" in J. Agnew, K. Mitchell, and G. Ó Tuathail (eds.), A Companion Guide to Political Geography Oxford (Oxford: Blackwell 2003) pp. 440–454. 74. T. Kuehls, Beyond Sovereign Territory: The Space of Ecopolitics (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press 1996). 75. See note 46. 76. Environmental Justice Networking Forum. See , accessed 10 Dec. 2009. 77. See , accessed 11 May 2009.