Perpetrators of Homicide With Schizophrenia: A National Clinical Survey in England and Wales
2006; American Psychiatric Association; Volume: 57; Issue: 11 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1176/appi.ps.57.11.1648
ISSN1557-9700
AutoresJanet Meehan, Sandra Flynn, Isabelle M. Hunt, J. Franklin Robinson, Harriet Bickley, Rebecca J. Parsons, Tim Amos, Navneet Kapur, L Appleby, Jenny Shaw,
Tópico(s)Stalking, Cyberstalking, and Harassment
ResumoBack to table of contents Previous article Next article Brief ReportFull AccessPerpetrators of Homicide With Schizophrenia: A National Clinical Survey in England and WalesJanet Meehan M.R.C.Psych.Sandra Flynn M.A.Isabelle M. Hunt B.Sc.Jo Robinson M.Sc.Harriet Bickley B.A.Rebecca Parsons B.A.Tim Amos M.R.C.Psych.Nav Kapur M.R.C.Psych., M.D.Louis Appleby F.R.C.Psych., M.D.Jenny Shaw M.R.C.Psych., Ph.D.Janet Meehan M.R.C.Psych.Sandra Flynn M.A.Isabelle M. Hunt B.Sc.Jo Robinson M.Sc.Harriet Bickley B.A.Rebecca Parsons B.A.Tim Amos M.R.C.Psych.Nav Kapur M.R.C.Psych., M.D.Louis Appleby F.R.C.Psych., M.D.Jenny Shaw M.R.C.Psych., Ph.D.Published Online:1 Nov 2006AboutSectionsPDF/EPUB ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack Citations ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InEmail There is a weak but definite association between schizophrenia and violence ( 1 , 2 ). Few studies have examined rates of schizophrenia among persons convicted of homicide ( 3 , 4 ). There have, however, been a number of detailed inquiries into the care of individual patients with schizophrenia who have committed homicide ( 5 ). In some cases there has been a long-standing pattern of disrupted contact with mental health services, whereas in others the homicide appears to have occurred soon after illness onset, before the offender had been in contact with services. This is the first study to examine the clinical care of a large sample of homicide perpetrators with schizophrenia. The aim was to describe the social and clinical characteristics, mental state features, offense details, and outcome in court of a national sample of people with schizophrenia convicted of homicide in England and Wales.Methods The study was carried out as part of the National Confidential Inquiry Into Suicide and Homicide by People With Mental Illness ( 6 ), a survey that collects data on all homicides in the United Kingdom, particularly on perpetrators in contact with mental health services. Data collection had three stages. First, the names of persons convicted between April 1996 and April 1999 of homicide (murder, manslaughter, or infanticide) in England and Wales were given to the Confidential Inquiry survey by the Home Office, which routinely collects this information. Second, psychiatric reports were requested from the courts of trial, the prison service, the Crown Prosecution Service, health services, and other sources. Records of previous offenses were obtained from the Police National Computer. Third, names and identifying details of the perpetrator were submitted to the main hospital and community trust in the perpetrator's district of residence in order to check for past treatment. Neighboring trusts and hospitals cited in psychiatric reports were also contacted. If the perpetrator's address was not known, data were sent to all trusts within the police force area in which the perpetrator had been charged. If the trusts responded that the perpetrator had received treatment in the past, the case was labeled as an "inquiry case." For each inquiry case, the consultant psychiatrist was sent a questionnaire to complete relating to the care and treatment received by the patient. An assessment of the accuracy of hospital checks showed that 97 percent of patients in contact with services in the previous year were detected ( 7 ). The Confidential Inquiry survey has been granted exemption under Section 60 of the Health and Social Care Act 2001 from obtaining informed consent from patients. A primary diagnosis of schizophrenia or other delusional disorder (referred to as schizophrenia in this paper) was made either by the psychiatric report writer or by responses to the Confidential Inquiry survey from mental health services.In a small number of cases in which a discrepancy was found between the diagnosis made in the psychiatric report and that assigned by mental health services, both sources were individually examined by one of the authors (JM). A standardized procedure was used to make the diagnosis on the basis of duration of illness, degree of contact with mental health services, timing of the most recent service contact, identification of symptoms and strength of agreement between psychiatric report writers (in cases with more than one report). The validity of the diagnoses was established by a second author (JS), who independently examined the cases in which there was a discrepancy in the listed diagnosis. Agreement between the two authors was 100 percent. We rated delusions using a very stringent protocol devised for the study. Extracting data provided in court reports, the protocol rated whether any delusional beliefs made perpetrators frightened or anxious (emotional response to beliefs), whether they sought information to confirm or refute the belief, or whether they changed their conviction in the face of hypothetical contradiction (conviction). Such changes in quality of delusions had been shown in a previous study to relate to acting on delusions ( 8 ). The court reports in homicide cases are written by psychiatrists undertaking a comprehensive review of witness statements and all past medical records, so significant collaborative evidence for the information is often given in the report. Only when there was clear evidence in court reports of a change in the quality of the delusions were these recorded as present. In addition, interrater reliability checks were conducted for 20 percent of cases by two authors (JM and JS), on which there was 100 percent agreement. The main findings are presented as proportions with 95 percent confidence intervals. If an item of information was not known for a case, the case was removed from the analysis of that item; the denominator in all estimates is therefore the number of valid cases for each item. Subgroup analysis involved the use of chi square tests with statistical significance set at 5 percent.ResultsThe Confidential Inquiry survey was notified of 1,594 homicides tried by courts in England and Wales between April 1996 and April 1999. In 15 cases the defendant was found to be unfit to plead or was found to be not guilty by reason of insanity, giving 1,579 homicide convictions. We obtained one or more reports prepared for the court in 1,168 cases (73 percent); 1,155 resulted in convictions, and 13 were found unfit to plead or not guilty by reason of insanity. Of the 1,594 perpetrators of homicide tried by courts, 85 had schizophrenia—that is, 5 percent of all homicides in England and Wales during the three-year period. The main demographic, criminological, and clinical characteristics of the sample are shown in Table 1 . A majority were male (86 percent), and one-third (35 percent) were from an ethnic minority group. One-third (32 percent) had been previously convicted for violence. Twelve (14 percent) killed a stranger. More than half had been ill for less than 12 months (32 of 57 persons, or 56 percent). Two-thirds (68 percent) were ill at the time of the offense. Among the 57 persons who were experiencing delusions at the time of the offense, 32 (56 percent) had shown a change in the quality of delusions, including either conviction about or emotional response to their delusional beliefs in the month before the offense. Table 1 Characteristics of persons who committed homicide in England and Wales, 1996-1999, by presence of schizophrenia (N=1,594)Table 1 Characteristics of persons who committed homicide in England and Wales, 1996-1999, by presence of schizophrenia (N=1,594)Enlarge table Twenty-four perpetrators (28 percent) never had contact with mental health services. In this group the pattern of illness duration was different from that of the group that had been in contact with mental health services. A larger proportion of perpetrators in the group that never had contact had been ill for more than three years (six of 23 perpetrators, or 26 percent, compared with two of 37 perpetrators, or 5 percent; χ2 =5.84, df=1, p=.04). In the month before the offense, those with no previous service contact were more likely to have experienced an increase in the conviction with which their delusions were held (11 of 21 perpetrators, or 52 percent, compared with nine of 36 perpetrators, or 25 percent; χ2 =4.37, df=1, p=.04). Eighteen people (21 percent) had previous contact with mental health services that did not occur in the year before the offense. In six cases, mental health services made a diagnosis of schizophrenia—five of these individuals had lost contact with mental health services over time, and another one lost contact because of planned discharge. In the remaining 12 cases, mental health services had not given a diagnosis of schizophrenia, and it is not known whether typical symptoms were absent or undetected at the time of their service contact.Forty-three people (51 percent) had been in contact with services in the year before the offense; clinical data from questionnaires were available from persons who had been in contact with services in the year before the offense. Of these, only 24 of 40 (60 percent) were under "enhanced CPA" (that is, multidisciplinary community follow-up), 16 of 40 (40 percent) missed their last appointment, and 14 of 36 (39 percent) were noncompliant with treatment in the month before the offense. Twenty-three of 37 people (62 percent) had delusions at the time of the offense. Among those with delusions at the time of the offense, 11 of 18 (61 percent) had experienced a change in the quality of their delusions in the month before the offense. Five of the 11 were noncompliant with treatment, five were out of contact with services, five were not under enhanced CPA (categories were not mutually exclusive). Twenty-five of 43 (58 percent) had a history of violence toward another person that was documented in the case notes. At court, two-thirds (64 percent) of perpetrators received a diminished-responsibility verdict, the majority were given a hospital order with or without restrictions (81 percent), and 16 (19 percent) were sent to prison ( Table 1 ). Discussion and conclusions This is the first study to describe the clinical, service-related, sociodemographic, and criminological characteristics of a national sample of people with schizophrenia who commit homicide. England and Wales have a relatively low homicide rate at 1.8 per 100,000 population compared with the United States, which has a rate of 5.5 per 100,000 ( 9 ). Of the 1,594 people who committed homicide over a three-year period, 85 (5 percent) had schizophrenia. Therefore, the prevalence of schizophrenia among perpetrators convicted of homicide was higher than the prevalence of schizophrenia in the community (.3 to .9 per 1,000) ( 10 ). However, we do not feel that the overrepresentation of people given a diagnosis of schizophrenia and convicted of homicide is due to the low homicide rate. A quarter of those with schizophrenia had no previous contact with mental health services. Although many of these people had been ill for years, there was evidence of recent clinical deterioration, including a change in the conviction with which their delusional beliefs were held. Of those in recent contact with services, a significant minority were not receiving care under the "enhanced" guidelines provided under the policy titled Care Programme Approach, even when there was a history of violence. Clinical services should ensure that people with severe mental illness and previous convictions for violence receive comprehensive multidisciplinary care, particularly those in the early stage of illness and those who are noncompliant with treatment. Several main methodological limitations must be highlighted. First, diagnoses were taken from psychiatric reports and from questionnaires. Although consultant psychiatrists completing questionnaires were asked to give ICD-10 diagnoses ( 11 ), psychiatric report writers varied in this respect and therefore there was no standardized method of establishing diagnosis and symptoms. However, in our view, psychiatric reports prepared for court are sufficiently detailed both to make judgments about the presence of symptoms and ICD-10 diagnoses. Second, psychiatric reports were available in only about three-quarters of cases. It is likely that the sample with these reports was biased toward those with serious mental health problems. However, it is also likely that the sample without these reports contained few or no people with schizophrenia. Third, the clinicians providing information may have been biased by awareness of outcome. Fourth, the size of the sample with no previous service contact was too small to allow detailed analysis. Fifth, people with schizophrenia and delusional disorder were categorized together and therefore we were unable to distinguish between them in the analyses. Finally, our ratings of delusions were not based on any standardized assessments. However, they were based on independent reports prepared for the courts, a review of case notes, and witness statements, with a high threshold for inclusion on the basis of clear evidence. We believe that our findings are more likely to represent an underestimate of changes in the quality of delusions. Delusions are a common symptom present at some stage among about 90 percent of persons with schizophrenia ( 12 ). In a previous study of prisoners awaiting trial ( 13 ), 10 percent were psychotic and 93 percent of these were experiencing delusions at the time of the offense. A direct correlation of experiencing delusions before committing an offense was found in 38 percent of these cases, and furthermore, experiencing delusions was more likely to be linked to violent offenses ( 14 ). In our study, 50 (59 percent) had delusions at the time of the offense and 32 (56 percent) reported a change in the quality of their delusions in the month before the offense. These findings highlight the need for regular assessment of the quality of delusions, with careful monitoring of persons among whom the quality of delusions is changing. Methodologies such as a case-control study could clarify the effectiveness of these interventions. AcknowledgmentsThe National Confidential Inquiry Into Suicide and Homicide by People With Mental Illness is funded by the National Patient Safety Agency. The authors acknowledge the help of health authorities, trust and Crown Court contacts, and consultant psychiatrists for completing the questionnaires.The authors are affiliated with the Department of Psychiatry, University of Manchester, Lancashire, United Kingdom. Professor Appleby is the National Director of Mental Health for England. Send correspondence to Professor Shaw at the Department of Psychiatry, University of Manchester, Williamson Building, Oxford Road, Manchester, Lancashire, United Kingdom M13 9PL (e-mail: [email protected]).References1. Brennan PA, Grekin ER, Vanman EJ: Major mental disorders and crime in the community, in Violence Among the Mentally Ill. Edited by Hodgins S. Dordrecht, Kluwer, 2000Google Scholar2. Arsenault L, Caspi A, Moffitt TE, et al: Mental disorders and violence in a total birth cohort. Archives of General Psychiatry 57:979-986, 2000Google Scholar3. Eronen M, Tiihonen J, Hakola P: Schizophrenia and homicidal behavior. Schizophrenia Bulletin 22:83-89, 1996Google Scholar4. Schanda H, Knecht G, Schreinzer D, et al: Homicide and major mental disorders: a 25 year study. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 110:98-107, 2004Google Scholar5. Ritchie JH, Dick D, Lingham R: The report of the Inquiry Into the Care and Treatment of Christopher Clunis: North East Thames and South East Thames Regional Health Authorities. London, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, 1994Google Scholar6. Appleby L, Shaw J, Amos T, et al: Safer Services: Report of the National Confidential Inquiry Into Suicide and Homicide by People With Mental Illness. London, UK Department of Health, 1999Google Scholar7. Appleby L, Shaw J, Amos T, et al: Suicide within 12 months of contact with mental health services: national clinical survey. British Medical Journal 318:1235-1239, 1999Google Scholar8. Buchanan A, Reed A, Wessely S, et al: Acting on delusions. II: the phenomenological correlates of acting on delusions. British Journal of Psychiatry 163:77-82, 1993Google Scholar9. Scottish Executive: Homicide in Scotland 2004/2005. Edinburgh, Statistical Bulletin Criminal Justice Series, 2005Google Scholar10. Torrey E: Epidemiological comparison of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Schizophrenia Research 39:101-106, 1999Google Scholar11. The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1992Google Scholar12. Taylor P: Schizophrenia and violence in abnormal offenders, in Delinquency and the Criminal Justice System. Editors Gunn J, Farrington D. Chichester, United Kingdom, Wiley, 1982Google Scholar13. Taylor PJ, Gunn J: Violence and psychosis. I: risk of violence among psychotic men. British Medical Journal 288:1945-1949, 1984Google Scholar14. Taylor PJ: Motives for offending among violent and psychotic men. British Journal of Psychiatry 147:491-498, 1985Google Scholar FiguresReferencesCited byDetailsCited byExploring Characteristics of Homicide Offenders With Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders Via Machine Learning22 June 2022 | International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, Vol. 68, No. 6-7Substance use and self-poisoning in schizophrenia: 11-year findings from a national clinical survey of suicide in mental health patients in the UKSchizophrenia Research, Vol. 267Étude nationale française du profil des patients hospitalisés en unité pour malades difficilesAnnales Médico-psychologiques, revue psychiatrique, Vol. 182, No. 2Forensic psychiatry evaluation of criminal law cases at a university hospital in Eastern Turkey25 September 2023 | The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology, Vol. 34, No. 5-6Homicide in the context of psychosis: analysis of prior service utilisation and age at onset of illness and violence19 September 2023 | BJPsych Open, Vol. 9, No. 5Matricide and schizophrenia- psychopathological, psychodynamic, and forensic aspects: a case report29 August 2023 | Frontiers in Psychiatry, Vol. 14Court-Ordered forensic psychiatric evaluations for offenders with schizophrenia with homicide charges in TaiwanJournal of Medical Sciences, Vol. 43, No. 1Research on interpersonal violence in schizophrenia: based on different victim types8 March 2022 | BMC Psychiatry, Vol. 22, No. 1Caractéristiques et particularités des homicides commis par des schizophrènesAnnales Médico-psychologiques, revue psychiatrique, Vol. 180, No. 6Homicide and Mental Disorder1 January 2022Psychosis and the Risk of Stranger Homicides22 February 2022 | Schizophrenia Bulletin Open, Vol. 3, No. 1Homicides committed by delusional patients in the early 20th and 21st centuries: A study conducted in a French secure unit11 October 2021 | Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 67, No. 1Matricide, parricide, and filicide: Are major mental disorders or personality disorders involved? Assessment of criminal responsibility in Brazilian cases7 May 2021 | Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 66, No. 5Research findings on Greek forensic patients found not guilty by reason of insanity. A juxtaposition of patients who committed a criminal offense during their first psychotic episode with those who did so later in the course of their illnessInternational Journal of Law and Psychiatry, Vol. 75Violent behavior by involuntarily committed female offenders with mental disorders: A population‐based case series30 November 2020 | Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 66, No. 2Homicide by men diagnosed with schizophrenia: national case–control study16 November 2020 | BJPsych Open, Vol. 6, No. 6Le passage à l'acte homicidaire inaugural : mythe ou réalité clinique ?L'Évolution Psychiatrique, Vol. 85, No. 2The last taboo: The experience of violence in first‐episode psychosis caregiving relationships5 February 2018 | Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, Vol. 92, No. 1International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, Vol. 66Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 73, No. 8The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology, Vol. 30, No. 3Journal of Criminological Research, Policy and Practice, Vol. 5, No. 3The patterns of homicide offence characteristics and their associations with offender psychopathology30 September 2018 | Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, Vol. 15, No. 3International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, Vol. 60The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology, Vol. 29, No. 4Frontiers in Psychology, Vol. 9Socio-demographic, psychiatric and legal characterisation of Colombian unimputable patients, 2000–2013Revista Colombiana de Psiquiatría (English ed.), Vol. 46, No. 2Aggression and Violent Behavior, Vol. 37Revista Colombiana de Psiquiatría, Vol. 46, No. 2Prevalence and Correlates of Aggression and Hostility in Hospitalized Schizophrenic Patients11 July 2016 | Journal of Interpersonal Violence, Vol. 32, No. 2References11 December 2015Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, Vol. 39The relationship of perceived family criticism and other risk factors to violence among patients with schizophreniaMiddle East Current Psychiatry, Vol. 22, No. 2Schizophrenia Research, Vol. 166, No. 1-3The World Journal of Biological Psychiatry, Vol. 16, No. 4Vurdering av årsakssammenheng mellom sykdom og kriminell handling hos utilregneligeTidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, Vol. 135, No. 4Systematic review and meta-analysis of homicide recidivism and Schizophrenia18 February 2014 | BMC Psychiatry, Vol. 14, No. 1Caregiver Reports of Patient-Initiated Violence in Psychosis1 July 2014 | The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 59, No. 7Serious Violence by People With Mental Illness5 December 2013 | Journal of Interpersonal Violence, Vol. 29, No. 8An investigation of duration of untreated psychosis and the affecting factors16 April 2013 | Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, Vol. 21, No. 1Mania, homicide and severe violence5 January 2012 | Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 46, No. 4The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology, Vol. 23, No. 1Comparison of First-Episode and Previously Treated Persons With Psychosis Found NGMI for a Violent OffenseOlav B. Nielssen, M.B.B.S., Ph.D., Natalia Lin Yee, B.Sc., M. Forensic Psych., Michael M. Millard, M.B.B.S., and Matthew M. Large, B.Sc.(Med.), M.B.B.S.1 July 2011 | Psychiatric Services, Vol. 62, No. 7Severe Non-Lethal Violence During Psychotic Illness1 June 2011 | Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 45, No. 6Prevalence of Delusional Jealousy in Psychiatric Disorders*25 January 2011 | Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 56, No. 2Filicide, Attempted Filicide, and Psychotic Disorders*6 January 2011 | Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 56, No. 2A population‐based study of juvenile perpetrators of homicide in England and Wales10 April 2010 | Journal of Adolescence, Vol. 34, No. 1Schizophrenia Research, Vol. 133, No. 1-3Revista Latinoamericana de Psicopatologia Fundamental, Vol. 14, No. 4Psychological Treatment of Psychosis8 March 2011La crise homicidaire : pendant de la crise suicidaire ? Particularités chez le sujet schizophrèneAnnales Médico-psychologiques, revue psychiatrique, Vol. 168, No. 1Revista Latinoamericana de Psicopatologia Fundamental, Vol. 13, No. 2Clinical and Cognitive Associations with Aggression in the First Episode of Psychosis1 January 2010 | Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 44, No. 1Caractérisation sociodémographique, clinique et criminologique d'une population de 210 meurtriersAnnales Médico-psychologiques, revue psychiatrique, Vol. 167, No. 8Homicide et schizophrénie : à propos de 14 cas de schizophrénie issus d'une série de 210 dossiers d'expertises psychiatriques pénales pour homicideAnnales Médico-psychologiques, revue psychiatrique, Vol. 167, No. 8Untreated psychotic illness in the survivors of violent suicide attempts14 May 2009 | Early Intervention in Psychiatry, Vol. 3, No. 2Schizophrenia Research, Vol. 112, No. 1-3Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 63, No. 2British Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 194, No. 2PLoS Medicine, Vol. 6, No. 10Self-Inflicted Eye Injuries in First-Episode and Previously Treated Psychosis1 January 2008 | Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 42, No. 3Guns, Adolescents, and Mental IllnessNora K. McNamara, M.D.Robert L. Findling, M.D.1 February 2008 | American Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 165, No. 2Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, Vol. 43, No. 1British Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 193, No. 2Jornal Brasileiro de Psiquiatria, Vol. 57, No. 4Schizophrenia Research, Vol. 92, No. 1-3Medical Journal of Australia, Vol. 186, No. 6 Volume 57Issue 11 November, 2006Pages 1648-1651PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES November 2006 Volume 57 Number 11 Metrics PDF download History Published online 1 November 2006 Published in print 1 November 2006
Referência(s)