Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

Indigenous Rights and the Environment: Evolving International Law

2003; RELX Group (Netherlands); Linguagem: Inglês

1556-5068

Cherie Metcalf,

Indigenous Peoples' Rights and Law

This paper explores the relationship between indigenous peoples' rights in international law and international environmental law. Two models underlie the protection of indigenous environmental rights. A model recognizes indigenous peoples' environmental rights as a corollary to the protection and preservation of indigenous culture. In the alternative 'self-determination model, indigenous peoples' environmental rights flow from their recognition as distinct communities with an inherent degree of autonomy and control over their own development. Both models have the potential to transform international environmental law. Recognition of indigenous peoples' rights allows principles of international environmental law to pierce the veil of state sovereignty The cultural integrity model offers the potential to broaden the legal framework of international environmental law through the inclusion of human rights instruments. The self-determination model may lead to indigenous peoples' independent participation in international agreements addressing environmental concerns. There is a crucial difference between the models. The cultural integrity model incorporates a connection between indigenous rights and sustainable environmental management while the self-determination model is based on indigenous peoples' right to choose their own environmental policy. There is no inherent relationship between recognition of indigenous rights and sustainable environmental management in the latter model. The implications for international environmental law are more uncertain.