“They Don't Know, Don't Show, or Don't Care”: Autism's White Privilege Problem
2020; Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.; Volume: 2; Issue: 4 Linguagem: Inglês
10.1089/aut.2020.0077
ISSN2573-959X
Autores Tópico(s)Child Development and Digital Technology
ResumoAutism in AdulthoodVol. 2, No. 4 Guest EditorialOpen AccessCreative Commons license"They Don't Know, Don't Show, or Don't Care": Autism's White Privilege ProblemMorénike Giwa OnaiwuMorénike Giwa OnaiwuAddress correspondence to: Morénike Giwa Onaiwu, BA, MA, Center for the Study for Women, Gender, and Sexuality, Rice University, 6100 Main Street, MS 38, Houston, TX 77005, USA E-mail Address: MorenikeGO@rice.eduhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-5889-8971Center for the Study for Women, Gender, and Sexuality, Rice University, Houston, Texas, USA.Foundations for Divergent Minds, Plano, Texas, USA.Search for more papers by this authorPublished Online:11 Dec 2020https://doi.org/10.1089/aut.2020.0077AboutSectionsPDF/EPUB Permissions & CitationsPermissionsDownload CitationsTrack CitationsAdd to favorites Back To Publication ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmail When I—as a black person, as a woman, as an autistic adult, as the mother of black autistic children, as an advocate—think about the world of autism research and practice, the words of Doughboy come to mind. In a poignant ending scene from the late African American director John Singleton's iconic debut film, Boyz n the Hood, Doughboy sadly remarks, "Either they don't know, don't show…or don't care about what's going on in the hood.1" Similarly, when it comes to autism, either they—or should I say you all—do not know, do not show, or do not care about black, indigenous, people of color (BIPoC) very much.Perhaps "they"—society at large, particularly those who are more privileged—are uninformed of the realities of those whose lives are more laden with oppression than theirs ("they don't know"). The typical "face" of autism tends to be that of a little white boy, regardless of autism's actual prevalence in all racial, age, and gender groups. Moreover, autism continues to be widely depicted and perceived as a tragic childhood condition that devastates families and burdens communities and, therefore, requires urgent intervention.A Google image search for the word "autism" yields a plethora of (mostly white) children, puzzle pieces, and colorful infographics bearing lists of symptoms, warning signs, graphs, and statistics. Like these images, the majority of autistic characters in popular media (e.g., Atypical's Sam, Parenthood's Max, The Good Doctor's Shaun, and Big Bang Theory's Sheldon) tend to be white and male. They bear little resemblance to Arnaldo Rios, Reginald "Levi" Latson, JT Torres, Kayleb Moon-Robinson, or David Ramos—all autistic individuals of color who were unjustly (and in most instances, violently) mistreated by U.S. police officers.2In all of these cases, the intervening officers perceived these individuals' mannerisms as aggression rather than characteristics of autism and responded with excessive force. Although the officers' actions are clearly reprehensible, it begs the question: with such little recognition that autistic people of color even exist, should we truly be shocked by any of these incidents? Or by the recent deaths of Eyad Hallaq of Jerusalem or Elijah McCain of Colorado, both young men of color who displayed autistic characteristics and were killed by the police?3,4In contrast to the limited perspective on autism shared by the general public, there are a significant number of individuals (and their respective organizations/institutions) who actually possess an understanding that grave inequities exist in communities of color with regard to autism.5 Although the layperson might be largely uninformed, autism professionals and experts, including clinicians, investigators, service providers, and others who are privy to more in-depth information, cannot feign such ignorance; they "know" about it.However, what they know is rarely, if ever, applied in a manner that could result in meaningful change to the disparities faced by people of color in the autism community. If knowledge is "power," in this case that power is rendered dormant. These are the individuals and institutions within the autism community who "don't show." They do not adequately show what is going on with regard to the diagnostic, access, outcome, educational, psychosocial, economic, and other gaps between races.This failure to call attention to and/or take action to right these imbalances is not necessarily malicious. Usually, it is not intentionally racist; in fact, most likely it seldom is. What it is, however, is self-serving. It is comfortable; it is familiar. It is lazy. And it is cowardly. For it is a lot safer to maintain the status quo, to "go with the flow" and to pretend not to notice. It takes courage and integrity to have to initiate difficult conversations. It takes time, and energy, and resources to make the efforts required to transform our spaces, our policies, and our practices to make them more inclusive. It takes self-awareness and strength to yield one's privilege: to ask hard questions, to make space for others, to work toward restoration, and to unlearn and re-educate ourselves. Sadly, despite awareness of the plight of people of color in the autism community, many would rather not inconvenience themselves.In addition to those who "don't know" and those who know, but "don't show," there is, according to a more pessimistic hypothesis, a third possibility: those who simply "don't care." Like those who "don't show," those in society who "don't care" are indeed aware of these issues. However, since personally they are not very impacted by these marginalizations, they largely disregard them. These very real discrepancies remain intentionally unaddressed because it is of little interest to them and because they see little to no benefit in getting involved. Essentially, "don't show" and "don't care" reside on a continuum. If you spend enough time as one who does not show, you will eventually evolve into someone who does not care.Having read this, how are you feeling right now? Pretty crappy, I would assume. When racism within the autism community is brought up, it evokes a sense of discomfort so thick it is nearly tangible. White people seem to feel especially awkward about this topic. And I get that it is not exactly pleasant to think or talk about it. However, can you imagine what living it is like? I can, because unlike many of you, I do not have a choice.6It is uncomfortable for me too. Sometimes (often) I feel as reluctant as Doughboy did to have to face that hurtful and ugly reality. I desperately want to believe that the structural racism within the collective world of autism, in both its subtle and more blatant manifestations, is merely a figment of my imagination (an imagination some would allege is essentially "nonexistent" since I am autistic). I would like nothing more than to feel assured that BIPoC autistic peers are valued as much as we seem to be in all of the rhapsodic and carefully curated "solidarity" and "Black Lives Matter" statements that have been issued in recent months. I wish the amalgamation of both the subjective (observations, personal experiences, and anecdotes from autistic BIPoC peers) and objective ("evidence-informed") data did not collectively paint the same dismal picture of inequity. But wishing something does not make it true.In Boyz in the Hood, neither Doughboy nor his brother Ricky lived long enough to have a fighting chance to change their circumstances. Their opportunity to experience better in this life ceased the moment their hearts ceased to beat. But if you are reading this, your heart, like mine, beats on. That means that we still have a chance to transform even this chaotic mess into something new that we can build together. It might seem amorphous, intimidating, maybe even impossible, but we must push past fear, doubt, ignorance, apathy, or whatever the obstacle is and seize the opportunity.The problem is an enormous one; I am not going to lie to you nor myself about its scope. But present circumstances do not have to determine the final outcome. I believe that gradual progress is the ancestor of monumental change, and it starts with you and me. It starts today. I ask you, allies, families, fellow autistic people, etc. of all ages, genders, races, and backgrounds, to pledge to take the following steps toward a world where when it comes to autism and race: You will commit to doing the work to know what is happening. You will make concerted efforts to show these important concepts to others so they can be more informed. And, last but not least, through practical and consistent action, you will show that you do, indeed, care.First, strive to continuously increase your knowledge of matters relevant to autism and race. A great way to start is by reading the intriguing roundtable discussion, moderated by a black autism researcher, in this issue of Autism in Adulthood. The discussion features several autistic and nonautistic panelists with diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds (Latinx, black, indigenous, and Pacific Islander) who create a thought-provoking dialogue about structural racism in autism research and practice.7 In addition, you can follow BIPoC autism activists on social media; read the landmark autism and race anthology, All the Weight of Our Dreams: On Living Racialized Autism8; or support efforts such as the grassroots Autistic People of Color Fund,* which provides material support in the form of microgrants for those in need.Second, plant seeds of change. Are you a clinician, researcher, or a service provider seeking to serve a more diverse population? First, assess yourself, is your environment one that would be welcoming to and inclusive of such individuals? Your board? Your staff? If not, fix that first. Then seek out some strategic partnerships with minority serving institutions, professional and community organizations, multicultural fraternities and sororities (the Divine Nine, the National Association of Latino Fraternal Organizations [NALFO], etc.), faith-based institutions, and so on.Mentoring others is another way to plant seeds of change. There is a critical need for greater racial diversity in autism research and practice; one way to help facilitate this is to increase the amount of BIPoC researchers and providers. To do so, we must ensure that we diversify our student population. One notable example, LoneStar Leadership Education In Autism and Neurodevelopmental Disabilities (LEND), places strong emphasis on the inclusion of racial and ethnic diversity as well as individuals with disabilities, including autism, among both its faculty and trainees; typically 50% or more of their annual fellows are people of color. By doing so, this interdisciplinary autism and neurodevelopmental training program in Texas is making tremendous progress toward its mission to develop and equip leaders to serve under-represented groups.Third, use your privilege for good. All human beings have different identities, some that are more privileged in specific circumstances and some that are more marginalized. Do not get defensive about having privilege. Instead, flip it! If you have some influence in a certain sphere, take advantage of it. Use your position to share the ideologies and perspectives of those who are not as likely to have such a platform. Or share the platform. Or yield it to someone else! Do you really need to be the one to give that address or that interview, just because you were the one who was invited? And if so, who can you bring along who might be able to benefit from being present? Is there a person of color, or even better—an autistic person of color—with whom you can collaborate?Fourth, do "what is right, not what is easy" with regard to autism research and practice. If you are a practitioner, perhaps you can find ways to accept new types of payment (e.g., other types of insurance, payment plans, and sliding scale fees)? Maybe you need to hire additional staff who are multilingual? Offer nontraditional hours of operation (some nights, some weekends, etc.)? If you are in research, perhaps you can also establish quotas to ensure your studies include participants of color. That might mean that it takes more time and effort to recruit, enroll, and retain study participants, but it will be worth the effort. Consider advocating for more diverse data sets. There is no rule that says you must use that same old tired sample wherein the vast majority of participants are white—even if that sample is "normed" or affiliated with some impressive entity.9Lastly, not only "bloom where you're planted," but try to blaze a trail! A positive example is Autism in Adulthood. Rather than follow a "tried and true" template, this journal has taken quite a number of risks to remain true to its vision. And though, like everything in life, it is imperfect, I believe it has purposefully positioned itself to be an effective tool in our collaborative quest for racial equity in autism research and practice. From its carefully selected leadership team of autistic and nonautistic editors, its stance on the use of respectful nonstigmatizing language, its requirement for substantive plain language lay summaries, its use of traditional and community reviewers, and the purposeful composition of its editorial board (of which I am a proud member), Autism in Adulthoods's commitment to meaningful inclusion is far from lip service.* Believing diversity is not something that should be relegated to a "special interest" or ad-hoc group, our eclectic editorial board, consisting of advocates, researchers, clinicians, and community leaders, represents a diverse range of neurotypes, races, gender identities, nationalities, disciplines, ages, and organizations. We engage in open honest dialogue with one another, even when it is hard. In doing so, we continuously learn from one another, foster a sense of mutual respect and understanding, stimulate ideas for future research and exploration, and help build a forum for deep meaningful discussions on the issues that matter most to autistic adults.Whoever you are and whatever you do, you can affect change right where you are. You can know, you can show, and you can care. It will require some innovation and some patience on your part, but it can be done. Seek opportunities to make progress, even if seemingly small or unconventional. There are so many possibilities!References1. Durling R. Boyz n the Hood. Santa Barbara International Film Festival. https://sbiff.org/boyz-n-the-hood/ (accessed October 1, 2020). Google Scholar2. Autistic Self Advocacy Network. Research Overview on Autism and Safety. Autism and Safety Toolkit. https://autisticadvocacy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Autism-and-safety-pt-1.pdf Google Scholar3. Agarwal R. Elijah McCain: Death By Injection. California Society of Anesthesiologists. July 15, 2020. http://csahq.org/news/blog/csa-online-first/2020/07/15/elijah-mcclain-death-by-injectionwed (accessed November 11, 2020). Google Scholar4. Goldenberg T. Israel: Prime Minister: Killing of Palestinian with Autism a 'Tragedy'. Associated Press. June 7, 2020. https://apnews.com/article/75104c37fadeb37b993400c3b7182b3e (accessed November 12, 2020). Google Scholar5. Durkin MS, Maenner MJ, Baio J, et al. Autism spectrum disorder among US children: socioeconomic, racial, and ethnic disparities. Am J Public Health. 2017;107:1818–1826. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar6. Bor J, Venkataramani AS, Williams DR, Tsai AC. Police killings and their spillover effects on the mental health of black Americans: a population-based, quasi-experimental study. Lancet. 2018;392:302–310. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar7. Ellwood LJ, Garcia A, Johnson KR, et al. An expert discussion on structural racism in autism research and practice. Jones DR, Nicolaidis C, eds. Autism Adulthood. 2020;2(4):273–341. Link, Google Scholar8. Brown LXZ, Ashkenazi E, Giwa Onaiwu M. All the Weight of Our Dreams: On Living Racialized Autism. Lincoln, NE: DragonBee Press; 2017. Google Scholar9. West EA, Travers JC, Kempner TD, et al. Racial & ethnic diversity of participants in research supporting evidence-based practices for learners with autism spectrum disorder. J Spec Educ. 2016;50(3):151–163. Crossref, Google Scholar* https://autismandrace.com/autistic-people-of-color-fund* Autism in Adulthood. Aims & Scope. New Rochelle, NY: Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. Publishers. https://home.liebertpub.com/publications/autism-in-adulthood/646/overview#aimsFiguresReferencesRelatedDetailsCited byA longitudinal study on cognitive aging in autismPsychiatry Research, Vol. 321An Interactive and Neurodiversity-Affirming Approach to Communication Supports for Autistic Students Through VideogamingLanguage, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, Vol. 54, No. 1How to Minimize the Impact of Experts' Non-rational Beliefs on Their Judgments on Autism3 December 2022 | Community Mental Health Journal, Vol. 19The Scholarly Neglect of Black Autistic Adults in Autism Research Kayla M. Malone, Jamie N. Pearson, Kayla N. Palazzo, Lonnie D. Manns, Amelia Q. Rivera, and DeVoshia L. Mason Martin13 December 2022 | Autism in Adulthood, Vol. 4, No. 4Sexual Minority Identities in Autistic Adults: Diversity and Associations with Mental Health Symptoms and Subjective Quality of Life Goldie A. McQuaid, Justine Gendy, Nancy Raitano Lee, and Gregory L. Wallace17 November 2022 | Autism in Adulthood, Vol. 0, No. 0Beyond 'bad' behaviors: A call for occupational scientists to rethink autism11 November 2022 | Journal of Occupational Science, Vol. 77Brief Report: Does Autistic Community Connectedness Moderate the Relationship Between Masking and Wellbeing? Eilidh Cage, Rebekah Cranney, and Monique Botha31 August 2022 | Autism in Adulthood, Vol. 4, No. 3Interpretation and Use of Standardized Language Assessments for Diverse School-Age IndividualsPerspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups, Vol. 7, No. 4Increased perceived stress is negatively associated with activities of daily living and subjective quality of life in younger, middle, and older autistic adults5 July 2022 | Autism Research, Vol. 15, No. 8Inequity in Peer Review in Communication Sciences and DisordersAmerican Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, Vol. 31, No. 4Autistic Adult Perspectives on Occupational Therapy for Autistic Children and Youth17 June 2022 | OTJR: Occupation, Participation and Health"This Was Just How This Friendship Worked": Experiences of Interpersonal Victimization Among Autistic Adults Amy Pearson, Jon Rees, and Samantha Forster9 June 2022 | Autism in Adulthood, Vol. 4, No. 2Cultural Humility, a Path to Equity2 June 2022'Connected to the Soul': Autoethnography, Neurodiversity and Literacies in Times of Ongoing Change5 March 2022Greater Social Interest Between Autistic and Non-autistic Conversation Partners Following Autism Acceptance Training for Non-autistic People22 September 2021 | Frontiers in Psychology, Vol. 12 Volume 2Issue 4Dec 2020 Information© Morénike Giwa Onaiwu, 2020; Published by Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.To cite this article:Morénike Giwa Onaiwu."They Don't Know, Don't Show, or Don't Care": Autism's White Privilege Problem.Autism in Adulthood.Dec 2020.270-272.http://doi.org/10.1089/aut.2020.0077creative commons licensePublished in Volume: 2 Issue 4: December 11, 2020Online Ahead of Print:November 17, 2020Open accessThis Open Access article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are cited.PDF download
Referência(s)