Questionable cancer practices in Tijuana and other Mexican border clinics
1991; Wiley; Volume: 41; Issue: 5 Linguagem: Inglês
10.3322/canjclin.41.5.310
ISSN1542-4863
Tópico(s)Cancer Diagnosis and Treatment
ResumoCA: A Cancer Journal for CliniciansVolume 41, Issue 5 p. 310-319 ArticleFree Access Questionable cancer practices in tijuana and other mexican borderclinics First published: September/October 1991 https://doi.org/10.3322/canjclin.41.5.310Citations: 6AboutPDF ToolsRequest permissionExport citationAdd to favoritesTrack citation ShareShare Give accessShare full text accessShare full-text accessPlease review our Terms and Conditions of Use and check box below to share full-text version of article.I have read and accept the Wiley Online Library Terms and Conditions of UseShareable LinkUse the link below to share a full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Learn more.Copy URL Abstract Tijuana, Mexico, has become a refuge for cancer patients who have beenconvinced that they may be cured of their terminal illness byunconventional, unproved, and disproved methods offered in the borderclinics. About a dozen United States promoters have joined with Mexicancolleagues to offer a variety of treatments. Some patients are diagnosedusing standard methods prior to arrival at the clinics, but many healthyindividuals are misdiagnosed as having cancer or “precancer” and are thentreated there. Others are told they have been cured or are improving eventhough they still have active disease. The modalities and regimens used areoften referred to as “metabolic therapy” and, for the most part, are eithernot based on sound scientific principles or have been shown in controlledclinical trials to be useless or even dangerous. A basic metabolic regimenconsists of three phases: detoxification with fasting and bowel cleansing, strengthening the immune system with numerous “supplements,” and attackingcancer with “natural and non-toxic” chemicals. Popular treatments includeinjections of hydrogen peroxide, large quantities of pressed liver andcarrot juice, coffee enemas, infusions of Laetrile mixed with massive dosesof vitamins and dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), special diets, and a host ofother pseudoscientific regimens. Unfortunately, no evidence exists that anyof these modalities is more effective than no treatment at all. Patientstraveling to the Mexican border clinics for metabolic therapy aresubjecting themselves to costly and hazardous regimens, especially if theyforgo responsible medical care in the process. The American Cancer Society, therefore, strongly urges individuals with cancer not to seek treatmentwith metabolic therapies in the Mexican border clinics. References 1 Miller NJ, Howard-Ruben J: Unproven methods of cancer management part 1: Background and historical perspectives. Oncol Nurs Forum 10 (4): 46– 52, 1983. 2 Lowell J: The Gerson clinic. Nutrition Forum 3: 9– 12, 1986. 3 Gerson Institute, Advertisement: Health Freedom News 9 (1): 45, 1990. 4 Kelley WD: One Answer to Cancer. The Kelley Foundation, 1974, distributed by The International Association of Cancer Victims and Friends, Beverly Hills, Calif. 5 Chowka PB: Steve McQueen: Legacy of a medical outlaw. New Age, January 1981, pp 29– 36. 6 American Biologics-Mexico: North America's Most Advanced Holistic Medical Center (advertisement). Tijuana, Mexico, American Biologics, 1989. 7 A classically trained doctor who uses nutritionally based cancer treatments. Health Facts, March 1990, pp 4– 5. 8 Unproven methods of cancer management: Contreras methods. CA 21: 317– 321, 1971. 9 Contreras E Jr: Cancer: Overview, treatment and care. An Oasis of Hope Update, Hospital Ernesto Contreras R 1 (2): 4– 5, 1987. 10 Cancer hospital has new name and facilities. An Oasis of Hope Update, Hospital Ernesto Contreras R 1 (2): 1, 1987. 11 Manner HW: Facts About Metabolic Therapy. San Ysidro, Calif, Metabolic Research Foundation, undated. 12 Manner HW: The metabolic therapy for cancer. Metabolic Research Foundation Monthly Newsletter 6 (14): 1, 1985. 13 Donsbach KW, Walker M: Metabolic Cancer Therapies. Huntington Beach, Calif, International Institute of Natural Health Sciences, Inc, 1981. 14 Warburg O: The Prime Cause and Prevention of Cancer. Würzburg, Germany, Konrad Triltsch, 1969. 15 Gerson M: The cure of advanced cancer by diet therapy: A summary of 30 years of clinical experimentation. Physiological Chemistry and Physics 10: 449– 464, 1978. 16 Marks R: Metabolic cancer therapy. Cancer News Journal 18 (2): 20– 22, 1983. 17 Fritz N: On natural living, health and disease, healing, and the Gerson therapy. Healing Incurables 1: 5, 9, 10, 1981. 18 Wolper S: Leukemia and Metabolic Therapy. La Mirada, Calif, Wolper Publications, 1987. 19 Wolper S: Alternative Cancer Therapies: Tijuana Clinics, 4th revision. La Mirada, Calif, Wolper Publications, 1987. 20 Rosarita Beach Clinic: Health and Life (advertisement). Tijuana, Mexico, Rosarita Beach Clinic, undated. 21 Shils ME, Hermann MG: Unproved dietary claims in the treatment of patients with cancer. Bull NY Acad Med 58: 323– 340, 1982. 22 Hesse CC: The Gerson Primer. Bonita, Calif, Gerson Institute, 1982. 23 Jensen B, Bell S: Tissue Cleansing through Bowel Management. Escondito, Calif, Bernard Jensen, 1981. 24 Donsbach D: Hospital Santa Monica (advertisement), undated. 25 Gerson M: Cancer Therapy: Results of Fifty Cases, 3rd ed. Del Mar, Calif, Ashland, Oreg, World Wide Publishing, 1977. 26 Manner HW: The metabolic therapy for cancer, part 3. Metabolic Research Foundation Newsletter May 1985, p 1. 27 Griffin FK: Food Can Kill… or Food Can Cure. Carefree, Ariz, Kirkwood Press, 1979. 28 Lowell JA: Metabolic therapy is dubious treatment, in Health Hoaxes and Hazards. Tucson, Ariz, Nutrition Information Center, 1987. 29 American Biologics: Choice Metabolics Retail Price List. Chula Vista, Calif, American Biologics, March 1987. 30 Salaman MK: Nutrition: The Cancer Answer. Menlo Park, Calif, Statford Publishing, 1984. 31 Passwater RA: Cancer and Its Nutritional Therapies. New Canaan, Conn, Keats Publishing, 1983. 32 Livingston-Wheeler V, Addeo EG: The Conquest of Cancer: Vaccines and Diet. New York, Franklin Watts, 1984. 33 Fink JM: Third Opinion: An International Guide to Alternative Therapy Centers for the Treatment and Prevention of Cancer. Garden City Park, NY, Avery Publishing Group Inc, 1988. 34 W Westover (ed): Physician's Handbook of Vitamin B-17 Therapy. Sausalito, Calif, Science Press International, 1973. 35 Pharmaceuticals International, catalog, Fall 1989. 36 Donsbach KW: Wholistic Cancer Therapy. Rosarito Beach, Mexico, Wholistic Publishers, 1988. 37 Lowell JA: Metabolic cures, in S Barrett, B Cassileth (eds): Dubious Cancer Treatments. Tampa, Fla, American Cancer Society, 1991. 38 Lowell JA: Hoxsey treatment still available. Nutrition Forum 4: 89– 91, 1987. 39 Meister KA: Are preservatives good for you? ACSH (American Council on Science and Health) News & Views 8 (2): 3– 4, 10, 1987. 40 Jones P: The evolution of the concept of carcinogenicity: An interview with Dr. Bruce Ames. ACSH (American Council on Science and Health) News & Views 9 (1): 3– 5, 1988. 41 Willett WC, MacMahon B: Diet and cancer: An overview. N Engl J Med 310: 633– 638, 1984. 42 Hall EJ: Radiobiology for the Radiologist, 3rd ed. Philadelphia, JB Lippincott Company, 1987. 43 Grim PS, Gottlieb LJ, Boddie A, Batson E: Hyperbaric oxygen therapy. JAMA 263: 2216– 2220, 1990. 44 South J: The Manner seminar. Nutrition Forum 5: 61– 67, 1988. 45 Willey FG: Personal communications to James A. Lowell, October 1, 1987, November 25, 1989. 46 Kaplan LA, Pesce AJ: Clinical Chemistry: Theory, Analysis, and Correlation. St. Louis, CV Mosby Company, 1984. 47 Lowell JA, Kenney JJ, Rasmussen AL: Nutrition Assessment: Separating Fact, Fiction and Fraud. Tucson, Ariz, Nutrition Information Center, 1987. 48 Barrett S: Commercial hair analysis: Science or scam? JAMA 254: 1041– 1045, 1985. 49 Worrall RS: Iridology: Diagnosis or delusion. Skeptical Inquirer 7 (3): 23– 35, 1983. 50 Lowell JA: Live cell analysis: High-tech hokum. Nutrition Forum 3: 81– 85, 1986. 51 Barrett S: The Health Robbers, 2nd ed. Philadelphia, George F Stickley Company, 1980. 52 American Cancer Society: ACS Statement on the Contreras Method. Unproven Methods Statement, Atlanta, CL# MA-25, May 8, 1987. 53 Lowell JA: The enema enigma, in Health Hoaxes and Hazards. Tucson, Ariz, Nutrition Information Center, 1987. 54 Centers for Disease Control: Campylobacter sepsis associated with “nutritional therapy”—California. MMWR 30: 294– 295, 1981. 55 Eisele JW, Reay DT: Deaths related to coffee enemas. JAMA 244: 1608– 1609, 1980. 56 Kirchner SG, Buckspan GS, O'Neill JA, et al: Detergent enema: A cause of caustic colitis. Pediat Radiol 6: 141– 146, 1977. 57 Istre GR, Kreiss K, Hopkins RS, et al: An outbreak of amebiasis spread by colonic irrigation at a chiropractic clinic. N Engl J Med 307: 339– 342, 1982. 58 Foley J: Probe of starvation deaths reopened. Mercury News (San Jose), section B, February 24, 1987. 59 Herbert V: Unproven (questionable) dietary and nutritional methods in cancer prevention and treatment. Cancer 58 (suppl 8): 1930– 1941, 1986. 60 National Dairy Council: Nutrition Misinformation. Dairy Council Digest 52 (4): 19– 24, 1981. 61 Bolton JC: Health risks of raw milk. FDA Consumer 20 (7): 7, 1986. 62 Centers for Disease Control: Campylobacter outbreak associated with certified raw milk products—California. MMWR 33: 562, 1984. 63 Bolton J: Testimony before the Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration, on Whether Milk and Milk Products Sold for Human Consumption Should Be Pasteurized. October 11, 1984. 64 “Resort to Health” Workshop (advertisement). Dallas, The Nutritional Counseling Service, undated, pp 6– 8. 65 Marshall CW: Vitamins and Minerals: Help or Harm? Philadelphia, George F Stickley Company, 1983. 66 Barrett S: Vitamin victims sue Harold Manner. Nutrition Forum 1: 9– 10, 1984. 67 Foods, Drugs, or Frauds. Consumer Reports 50: 275– 283, 1985. 68 Lowell JA: Organic germanium: Another health food store junk food. Nutrition Forum 5: 53– 58, 1988. 69 Moertel CG, Fleming TR, Rubin J, et al: A clinical trial of amygdalin (Laetrile) in the treatment of human cancer. N Engl J Med 306: 201– 206, 1982. 70 Jarvis W (ed): Toxicity of hydrogen peroxide. NCAHF (National Committee against Health Fraud) Newsletter 12 (3): 5, 1989. 71 Jarvis W (ed): Hydrogen peroxide poisonings. NCAHF (National Committee against Health Fraud) Newsletter 12 (3): 5, 1989. 72 Krakoff IH: Cancer chemotherapeutic agents. CA 37: 93– 105, 1987. Citing Literature Volume41, Issue5September/October 1991Pages 310-319 ReferencesRelatedInformation
Referência(s)