Portal de Periódicos da CAPES

PHENOMENAL CONSERVATISM AND THE PROBLEM OF REFLECTIVE AWARENESS

2018; University of Illinois Press; Volume: 55; Issue: 3 Linguagem: Inglês

10.2307/45128620

2152-1123

Luca Moretti,

Political Philosophy and Ethics

Abstract This paper criticizes phenomenal conservatism—the view according to which a subject S’s seeming that P provides S with defeasible justification for believing P. It argues that phenomenal conservatism, if true at all, has a significant limitation: seeming-based justification is elusive because S can easily lose it by just reflecting on her seemings and speculating about their causes. The paper also argues that because of this limitation, phenomenal conservatism doesn’t have all the epistemic merits attributed to it by its advocates. If true, phenomenal conservatism constitutes a unified theory of epistemic justification capable of giving everyday epistemic practices a rationale, but it doesn’t afford us the means of an effective response to the skeptic. Furthermore, phenomenal conservatism doesn’t form the general basis for foundationalism.