World Affairs Acknowledgment of Reviewers 2023–2024
2024; SAGE Publishing; Linguagem: Inglês
10.1002/waf2.12053
ISSN1940-1582
Autores ResumoWriting an excellent scholarly peer review—as most academics are acutely aware—takes considerable time, effort, thought, and skill. Good reviews not only point out the strengths and weaknesses of a paper in detail with authority and sensitivity but also give significant guidance to authors on how exactly to rectify the weaknesses and bolster the strengths in a revised version, along with invaluable lists of additional sources to help the diligent author do so. Great reviews are constructively critical: encouraging but firm, fair, detailed, and above all useful to the author in mapping out the revisions needed to bring a piece to publication standard. Relatedly, great reviewers advise editors on the legitimacy of claims to original contribution, check and correct facts and data, isolate errors, extraneous detail, and lack of clarity, and identify any problematic overlaps with already published work. More frequently than most authors imagine, they also advise editors if they have reviewed the paper before for another journal, how long ago, and if the paper has been adequately reworked before submitting to the new journal—or not. In so doing, reviewers facilitate dialog between editors from different journals to enhance ethical standards and act as the primary gatekeepers of the rigorous research we expect from prestigious journals. They likewise function as incredibly important, if anonymous, in-career mentors to authors—especially across the two or three rounds of reviews and revisions that the articles eventually published in World Affairs need to pass successfully. For these reasons, and many others, all editors and academic authors are extremely indebted to the sheer hard work that peer reviewers devote to our academic field in general and to each paper they review in particular. They do so in anonymity and, across the social sciences, contribute their time and expertise freely and often. As Editor of World Affairs, on behalf of myself, the Editorial Board, and the many authors whose submissions enter our review stage, I extend our heartfelt and sincere thanks to each and every reviewer who returned a review to us in the 2023–2024 production period. Your tireless and meticulous work—and I am sure a hefty amount of burnt midnight oil—continues to significantly enhance the quality of the research published in this old and very distinguished journal. You are appreciated by us all more than you know. Thank you, one and all! Escribir una excelente revisión por pares académicos, como la mayoría de los académicos saben, requiere mucho tiempo, esfuerzo, reflexión y habilidad. Las buenas críticas no sólo señalan en detalle las fortalezas y debilidades de un artículo con autoridad y sensibilidad. También brindan orientación importante a los autores sobre cómo rectificar exactamente las debilidades y reforzar las fortalezas en una versión revisada, junto con listas invaluables de fuentes adicionales para ayudar al autor diligente a hacerlo. Las buenas reseñas son constructivamente críticas: alentadoras pero firmes, justas, detalladas y, sobre todo, útiles para el autor a la hora de trazar las revisiones necesarias para que un artículo alcance los estándares de publicación. De manera relacionada, los grandes revisores asesoran a los editores sobre la legitimidad de las afirmaciones de contribución original, verifican y corrigen hechos y datos, aíslan errores, detalles superfluos y falta de claridad, e identifican cualquier superposición problemática con trabajos ya publicados. Con más frecuencia de lo que la mayoría de los autores imaginan, también informan a los editores si han revisado el artículo antes para otra revista, hace cuánto tiempo y si el artículo ha sido, o no, revisado adecuadamente antes de enviarlo a la nueva revista. Al hacerlo, los revisores facilitan el diálogo entre editores de diferentes revistas para mejorar los estándares éticos y actúan como los principales guardianes de la investigación rigurosa que esperamos de revistas prestigiosas. También funcionan como mentores increíblemente importantes—aunque anónimos—durante la carrera de los autores, especialmente a través de las dos o tres rondas de revisiones que los artículos se sujetan a aprobación para ser finalmente publicados en World Affairs. Por estas razones, y muchas otras, todos los editores y autores académicos están extremadamente en deuda con el arduo trabajo que los pares revisores dedican a nuestro campo académico en general, y a cada artículo que revisan en particular. Lo hacen de forma anónima y, en las ciencias sociales, aportan su tiempo y experiencia de forma libre y frecuente. Como editora de World Affairs, en mi nombre, en el del consejo editorial y en el de los numerosos autores cuyos envíos entran en la etapa de revisión, extiendo nuestro muy sincero agradecimiento a cada uno de los revisores que nos devolvieron una reseña en el período de producción 2023-2024. Su trabajo incansable y meticuloso (y estoy segura de que una gran cantidad de horas de trabajo) continúa mejorando significativamente la calidad de la investigación publicada en esta antigua y distinguida revista. Te apreciamos más de lo que crees. ¡Gracias a todos y cada uno! Dra. Emma R. Norman Editora en jefe, World Affairs [email protected] https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/waf 撰写出色的学术同行评审意见——大多数学者都敏锐地意识到这一点——需要花费大量时间、精力、思考和技巧。好的评论不仅能权威而敏感地详细指出论文的优缺点。它们还为作者提供了重要的指导,告诉他们如何在修订版中准确纠正缺点并增强优点,同时还提供宝贵的其他来源列表,以帮助勤奋的作者完成论文修订。出色的评论会给出建设性的批评:鼓舞人心但坚定、公平、详细,最重要的是,有助于作者规划使文章达到出版标准所需的修订。与此相关的是,优秀的审稿人会就原创文章的合法性向编辑提供建议,检查和纠正事实和数据,找出错误、无关细节和不清晰之处,并识别与已发表文章可能存在问题的重叠部分。比大多数作者想象的更频繁的是,同行评审会向编辑建议其是否曾为另一本杂志审阅过该论文,这发生在多久以前,以及论文在提交给新杂志之前是否进行了充分的修改——或者没有修改。 通过这种方式,审稿人促进了不同杂志编辑之间的对话,以提高伦理标准,并充当了严谨研究的主要守门人(我们期望著名杂志发表严谨研究)。审稿人同样是作者职业生涯中非常重要的导师,尽管是匿名的——这一点在《世界事务》中尤其明显,本刊最终发表的文章需要成功通过两三轮的审阅和修订。 出于这些原因以及许多其他原因,所有编辑和学术作者都非常感谢同行评审员为我们整个学术领域以及他们所评审的每一篇论文所付出的辛勤工作。他们的付出是匿名的,并且在社会科学领域经常免费贡献他们的时间和专业知识。 作为《世界事务》的编辑,我代表我自己、编辑委员会和许多投稿作者(他们的文章进入审阅阶段),向在2023-2024年文章生产期间为我们提供过审阅意见的每一位审稿人表示衷心的感谢。您孜孜不倦、一丝不苟的工作——我相信您熬夜加班——继续显著提高这本历史悠久而杰出的杂志所发表的研究质量。我们对您的感激之情超乎想象。谢谢大家! Emma R. Norman博士 《世界事务》主编 [email protected] https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/waf Ajide, Folorunsho M.—University of Ilorin, Nigeria Ajide, Kazeem—University of Lagos Alim, Eray—Batman University, Turkey Alola, Andrew Adewale—Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences Altin, Hasan—Shanghai University Altinors, Gorkem—Bilecik University, Turkey Alves, Ana Cristina—Mohammed VI Polytechnic University, Morocco Amable, Dennis—University of Nottingham-Ningbo, China Ara, Fardaus—University of Rajshahi, Bangladesh Asongu, Simplice—African Governance and Development Institute Ayhan, Kadir Jun—Seoul National University Azad, Tahir—University of Reading Bakhshandeh, Ehsan—University of Tehran Baloch, Muhammad Awais—Baoji University of Arts and Sciences, China Baris, Omer—Nazarbayev University Baser, Bahar—Durham University Basit, Abdul—Nanyang Technological University, Singapore Batrancea, Ioan—Babeș-Bolyai University, Romania Béland, Daniel—McGill University Berzina-Cerenkova, Una Aleksandra—Riga Stradins University, Latvia Borthakur, Anchita—Jawaharlal Nehru University Bragagnolo, Cassiano—Federal University of Sao Carlos, Brazil Brannagan, Paul Michael—Manchester Metropolitan University Brunello, Anthony—Eckerd College Byaro, Mwoya—Institute of Rural Development Planning, Dodoma, Tanzania Caballero Velez, Diego—University of Messina Chagas-Bastos, Fabricio—Harvard University Chattoraj, Diotima—Nanyang Technological University Singapore Clary, Christopher—University at Albany, SUNY Clary, Matt—Auburn University Colucci, Lamont—Concordia University Dada, James Temitope—Obafemi Awolowo University, Nigeria Davis, G. Doug—Troy University Deewanee, Azad—University of Bradford Eland, Ivan—The Independent Institute, Washington DC Faber, Michael—Ohio State University Fayomi, Oluwafemi—Federal University Oye-Ekiti, Nigeria Fisk, Jonathan—University of Utah Ganchev, Ivo—Queen Mary University of London Garrett, Terence—University of Texas Rio Grande Valley Gossel, Sean Joss—University of Cape Town Greco, Stefano—Chitkara University, India Grix, Jonathan—Manchester Metropolitan University Haider, Muhammad Waqas—Superior University, Pakistan Hall, Ian—Griffith University Hama, Hawre—University of Sulaimani, Iraq Handberg, Roger B.—University of Central Florida Harakan, Ahmad—Universitas Muhammadiyah Makassar, Indonesia Horowitz, Shale—University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Hunter, Lance—Augusta University Hussain, Mehmood—University of Azad Jammu, Pakistan Ibrahim, Ridwan Lanre—Independent Scholar Igwe, Paul Agu—University of Lincoln Iheonu, Chimere—University of Nigeria Islam, Maidul—Centre for Studies in Social Sciences Calcutta Ji, Xianbai—Nanyang Technological University Singapore Jones, Michael D.—Oregon State University Josefsson, Cecilia—Uppsala University Kalpakian, Jack—Al Akhawayn University in Ifrane, Morocco Katz, Mark—George Mason University Kaunert, Christian—Dublin City University Khashimwo, Pamreihor—Delhi University Kinyondo, Abel—University of Dar es Salaam Koga, Kei—Nanyang Technological University Singapore Konwer, Shubhrajeet—Gauhati University, India Koprulu, Nur—Near East University, Cyprus Kotokey, Angana—Jawaharlal Nehru University Kruiper, Thomas—Universidad Europea, Valencia Lahiry, Sujit—Panjab University Lai, Christina—Academia Sinica, Taiwan Lee, Hak-Seon—James Madison University Lemus Delgado, Daniel—Tecnológico de Monterrey (ITESM), Mexico Li, Mingjiang—S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), China Lin, Alex Min-Wei—National Chengchi University, Taiwan Makki, Mohammad—University of Wollongong Marques, Danusa—University of Brasilia McBeth, Mark—Idaho State University Mena Alemán, David—Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de México (ITAM) Mesagan, Ekundayo Peter—Pan-Atlantic University, Nigeria Motin, Dylan—Kangwon National University, South Korea Muhammed, Ali—Near East South Asia Center for Strategic Studies Myers, Nathan—Indiana State University Nguyen, Quyet—Vinh University, Vietnam Nwokora, Zim—Deakin University Nwozor, Agaptus—Landmark University, Nigeria Ojo, Olayiwola Victor—Shanghai University Omar, Majeda—University of Jordan Omelicheva, Mariya Y.—National Defense University Patra, Swapan Kumar—Sidho-Kanho-Birsha University, India Pelizzo, Riccardo—Nazarbayev University Proedrou, Filippos—University of South Wales Raadschelders, Jozef—Ohio State University Ramachandran, Veena—Birla Institute of Technology and Science, India Richey, Sean—Georgia State University Rubiolo, Florencia—National Scientific and Technical Research Council Argentina Rusu, Valentina Diana—Universitatea Alexandru Ioan Cuza (UAIC), Romania Shaykhutdinov, Renat—Florida Atlantic University Sixta Rinehart, Christine—University of South Carolina Skidmore, Max—University of Missouri Söylemez, Nagihan—Istanbul Bilgi University Stegmaier, Mary—University of Missouri Suchikova, Yana—Berdyansk State Pedagogical University, Ukraine Szulecki, Kacper—University of Oslo Tai Liu, Toni—National Chung Hsing University, Taiwan Teixeira, Victor Alexandre—Chulalongkorn University, Thailand Tella, Oluwaseun—University of Johannesburg Thornton, Songok—National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan Thornton, William—National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan Tusalem, Rollin—Arkansas State University Tursoy, Turgut—Near East University, Cyprus Ülgül, Murat—Karadeniz Technical University, Turkey Umland, Andreas—Institute of International Relations Prague Villanueva Ulfgard, Rebecka—Instituto Mora, Mexico Wenzelburger, Georg—Saarland University, Germany Yeung, May—University of Saskatchewan Zou, Xiaolong—Jilin University, China
Referência(s)